Every time I’m there I love the experience. Try the earl grey cinnamon rolls! They are wonderful! Also I hear they do tea and d for all u lovely nerdy needs.
Tiffany Rupp
Paula, I love your tea shop! You've done an amazing job. Quaint, unique, and 1337 selection of teas. If you wish to do afternoon tea please be sure to schedule that online.
Jabberwocky: An interesting spin on this indigiouns caffeine tisane. I would suggest letting the yaupon steep longer and using a bit less orange juice but otherwise a nice refreshing drink.
Kayla Christine
The owner was super sweet and helpful! The cinnamon roll was delicious, and I highly recommend the Jabberwocky specialty tea.
CoCo
Love this experience! Tea selection, food and owners are wonderful. 🤩
Jessica
What a fun place! I visited with my mom yesterday and we had such a great experience. The staff is very kind and knowledgeable. We had afternoon tea and we enjoyed all the delicious food, and also appreciated the time that was spent explaining how the tea wall works. I look forward to coming back in the future!
Melania Barbulescu
Nice ambiance, good tea
Trisha Cassaro
Food was good, service was excellent. There was a bit of a mix up but it was corrected fast. I asked for butter or jam for the Scones because I like to have something to spread on my scone. My daughter was ok with no spread for the Scones and said they were her favorite! Our tea was really good. The quiche was good, I loved the lemon feta. We will be back!
Diana Di Domenico
Unique and delicious afternoon tea service that changes monthly, so you'll never get bored. Lots of awesome loose leaf teas to try and to buy. The owners are super hospitable and friendly, too, so stop on by whenever you're in Woodstock or make a special trip because it's worth it!
C B
Casting Whimsy is the absolute best! Their variety of tea blends is amazing & unique and they're all delicious. Their baked goods are fabulous (the Sticky Snickets cookies are totally my downfall!) and the selection is rotated on a regular basis so there's always some new concoction to try. The atmosphere in the shop is absolutely charming & delightfully nerdy with a good eye towards sustainability practices. I've done a number of their events held at the space and they're always great fun. The owners are such genuine people, really passionate about their craft. All in all Casting Whimsy is a complete gem!
Katie Whitaker
Had afternoon tea to celebrate my daughter’s birthday. The tea, food and staff were all fantastic.
The staff went above and beyond to ensure all of our guests enjoyed themselves.
We did the afternoon tea and everything was delicious. Perfect portions for us to share all the treats. I highly recommend it for any occasion!
Charlie McNicholas
I'm not a big fan of tea, but I always find a drink here that I can enjoy! I was just in the other day and the chai macarons were so amazing I had to buy a second pack to take home. Not only is their food amazing, the owners and staff are all delightful! I've been coming here since before they switched locations, got hooked on the snickets and can't stop going back!
Rob McFadzean
Just go here. Stop reading reviews because they won't ever do it justice. But if you insist on still reading...
Randy and Paula treasures and their staff are a delight too. The vibe, much like the owners, is whimsical and cute and is perfectly rounded out with a geeky/nerdy cherry on top.
The menu and theme change monthly and I'm always excited to see what Randy has for us this time! I have been trying to go at least once a month for afternoon tea and I have had absolutely no complaints on any of my visits.
Every single time I have the pleasure of visiting is better than the last.
Support an awesome local business and #FreeRandyFromHisCorporateShackles so he can make this his full time passion.
Kid-friendliness: I wouldn't bring kids here for Afternoon Tea but they may like the tea fizz drinks for takeout on a warm day
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwich, Assorted Cookies, Shortbread Cookies, Afternoon Tea, Macarons, Earl Grey Cinnamon Rolls, Tarts and Cookies
Penny
Sorry I did not enjoy this tea shop. Quiche was overcooked and dry and not flavorful. The caramel apple treat was hard and not very tasty. I did enjoy my tea. Had to ask for sugar and cream for the tea. Maybe the high tea experience is different-I’ll never know because I probably won’t return.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Nate Kinkley
Loved it, we took the inlaws for an afternoon tea (reserved) and they were very happy with it. They lived in the UK for years and we're all a bit nerdy so this was an incredible afternoon activity for a chilly day. Owner was just the nicest.
Every time I’m there I love the experience. Try the earl grey cinnamon rolls! They are wonderful! Also I hear they do tea and d for all u lovely nerdy needs.
Paula, I love your tea shop! You've done an amazing job. Quaint, unique, and 1337 selection of teas. If you wish to do afternoon tea please be sure to schedule that online.
Jabberwocky: An interesting spin on this indigiouns caffeine tisane. I would suggest letting the yaupon steep longer and using a bit less orange juice but otherwise a nice refreshing drink.
The owner was super sweet and helpful! The cinnamon roll was delicious, and I highly recommend the Jabberwocky specialty tea.
Love this experience! Tea selection, food and owners are wonderful. 🤩
What a fun place! I visited with my mom yesterday and we had such a great experience. The staff is very kind and knowledgeable. We had afternoon tea and we enjoyed all the delicious food, and also appreciated the time that was spent explaining how the tea wall works. I look forward to coming back in the future!
Nice ambiance, good tea
Food was good, service was excellent. There was a bit of a mix up but it was corrected fast. I asked for butter or jam for the Scones because I like to have something to spread on my scone. My daughter was ok with no spread for the Scones and said they were her favorite! Our tea was really good. The quiche was good, I loved the lemon feta. We will be back!
Unique and delicious afternoon tea service that changes monthly, so you'll never get bored. Lots of awesome loose leaf teas to try and to buy. The owners are super hospitable and friendly, too, so stop on by whenever you're in Woodstock or make a special trip because it's worth it!
Casting Whimsy is the absolute best! Their variety of tea blends is amazing & unique and they're all delicious. Their baked goods are fabulous (the Sticky Snickets cookies are totally my downfall!) and the selection is rotated on a regular basis so there's always some new concoction to try. The atmosphere in the shop is absolutely charming & delightfully nerdy with a good eye towards sustainability practices. I've done a number of their events held at the space and they're always great fun. The owners are such genuine people, really passionate about their craft. All in all Casting Whimsy is a complete gem!
Had afternoon tea to celebrate my daughter’s birthday. The tea, food and staff were all fantastic. The staff went above and beyond to ensure all of our guests enjoyed themselves.
Restaurantji Recommends
We did the afternoon tea and everything was delicious. Perfect portions for us to share all the treats. I highly recommend it for any occasion!
I'm not a big fan of tea, but I always find a drink here that I can enjoy! I was just in the other day and the chai macarons were so amazing I had to buy a second pack to take home. Not only is their food amazing, the owners and staff are all delightful! I've been coming here since before they switched locations, got hooked on the snickets and can't stop going back!
Just go here. Stop reading reviews because they won't ever do it justice. But if you insist on still reading...
Randy and Paula treasures and their staff are a delight too. The vibe, much like the owners, is whimsical and cute and is perfectly rounded out with a geeky/nerdy cherry on top.
The menu and theme change monthly and I'm always excited to see what Randy has for us this time! I have been trying to go at least once a month for afternoon tea and I have had absolutely no complaints on any of my visits.
Every single time I have the pleasure of visiting is better than the last.
Support an awesome local business and #FreeRandyFromHisCorporateShackles so he can make this his full time passion.
Kid-friendliness: I wouldn't bring kids here for Afternoon Tea but they may like the tea fizz drinks for takeout on a warm day
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwich, Assorted Cookies, Shortbread Cookies, Afternoon Tea, Macarons, Earl Grey Cinnamon Rolls, Tarts and Cookies
Sorry I did not enjoy this tea shop. Quiche was overcooked and dry and not flavorful. The caramel apple treat was hard and not very tasty. I did enjoy my tea. Had to ask for sugar and cream for the tea. Maybe the high tea experience is different-I’ll never know because I probably won’t return.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Loved it, we took the inlaws for an afternoon tea (reserved) and they were very happy with it. They lived in the UK for years and we're all a bit nerdy so this was an incredible afternoon activity for a chilly day. Owner was just the nicest.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...