Town Square Tavern & Eatery

Hidden Gem. Food was amazing, service and atmosphere great, i recommend 100% give it a try you won’t regret it. Wings are out of this world.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Service was great, and the food was phenomenal! We are already planning our next visit back. The owner is awesome and was great to talk to!

EXCELLENT, EXCELLENT Food and service. We had dinner tonight, all 4 of us ordered something different and everything was phenomenal. The owner was so friendly and chatted with us, we even had a connection with my home town Crown Point which made my heart so happy; totally enjoyed our experience. Our server was a delight. We will definitely be back! Thanks for a great night!

Fantastic fish dinner and great waitress. We will be back. ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We went here on 1/5/25 and was very happy with the all ya can eat walleye very filling . But what really impressed us was the waitresses and the kindness and friendliness that they showed towards ever customer that walked in. And they took the time out too help customers to their car and opened the door for the elderly. Very impressive we need more of this in this screwed up world now a day's. Cant say enough about the friendly atmosphere this place has, thank ya for the best 1st time experience. We will difentaly be going back.

TLDR: I waited 70 minutes after ordering and the table behind us got the last ribeye that I ordered 10 minutes before them. I can’t review the food because I never got my meal.After hearing glowing reviews on the radio and having a relative highly recommended Town Square, I had my hopes set high.It started out great. I got a close parking spot which I thought was a good sign. My party of 3 walked in and was told it would be a few minutes before we would be seated. There was one clean and one dirty booth open on the diner side when we walked in and almost all of the barstools were unoccupied. After standing inside the front door for a few minutes a couple guys who looked like they had been waiting to be seated for a while got up from the only wait bench and left. I gathered my patience which I had plenty of because I was craving a good ribeye steak and didn’t care if it took a while.After some time, which didn’t seam long in comparison to the rest of our visit, a gentleman came out, cleaned the dirty booth, asked us which booth we wanted, seated us, and took our drink order: 2 waters and 1 sweet tea. That’s when it became apparent that there wasn’t much communication between the wait staff and servers.The gentleman returned with the drinks with the help of another server who we thought would take our order since we were more than ready. We waited a few more minutes when another server returned to take our order: 1 fried pickles, 3 side salads, 1 smash burger, 1 ribeye steak. Nothing was mentioned about the steaks being in short supply.About 10 minutes pass and a party of 4 takes the booth behind us. They are waited on promptly and told there are only 2 ribeyes left. They order the last ribeyes. Forty minutes pass and our pickles arrive and our drinks are refilled by yet another server. Nothing is mentioned about how the food is coming along. I try a few fried pickles and they remind me of Texas Roadhouse. Nothing special but good.Twenty minutes pass and the table behind us gets their ribeyes but not their salads. At this point I’m really worried that I won’t be getting the ribeye I had been craving and patiently waiting for. I start the clock.The guy in the booth who had one of the ribeyes hears me talking about leaving and asks us if our food has come. He gets up and waves down the gentleman who seated us and he asks us what we ordered, no apology for the wait. The gentleman says he will check on our order.Five minutes pass with no sign of any worker and we decide to leave. Not having anything but large bills we leave a $20. I’m willing to give Town Square another shot once the communication improves.

Service: 1

Had prime rib on a Saturday night. Friendly staff and good service. Food was amazing!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Had the brisket sandwich and it was absolutely delicious and reasonably priced. Would return!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The Philly Cheese Steak sandwich is FIRE!! I don't eat red meat often but, daaamn!! Papa Mike knows what he is doing. I've had the beef ribs, the pulled pork, turkey panini and smashburger and it is all A1 quality!! Shelly is almost always our server and she is on point and attentive! For a small town restaurant it is fantastic!! If you live within an hour of this establishment, there is zero reason not to give it a try! You will not be disappointed!! I make an hour drive, each way, once a week for this establishment and never regret it!! Annnd they have fabulous beer and now hard liquor!! It's a win-win!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

What an improvement over previous brew pub. The remodel is very well done. Prime rib special was the best prime rib in the Plymouth-Culver area. Servers were very friendly and helpful. We will eat here again.

Took my parents there for our first time. We got two full slabs of ribs and a walleye dinner. Everything was excellent! Well, definitely be going back to try other things. Their prices are very reasonable.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great food, welcoming and inviting staff, overall a wonderful place to eat. Clean and inviting! No attitudes or drama. We are so glad you are here❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great service, great food. Will be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Thank you for great food and prices the staff is great the ownee is great she is always on the floor to

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great food and beer! Everyday has a different special and the BBQ sauce and meat was so perfect.The summer blond beer was light and refreshing and they're bread pudding was fantastic, make sure you save room for desert.More is to come as well since they just opened.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5