Classic City Cookies

110 N Main St, Auburn
(260) 350-9134

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Donald Dickison

Best and fanciest cookies around!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Patrick Metsker

Selection was very slim. The taste is very almond forward, not a traditional sugar in my opinion. Also, 3 cookies not worth 10 dollars in my opinion.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Ashley Smith

These are some of the worst cookies I have ever had! The owner is rude…for being a small business owner you would think she could muster up some kindness.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Dan

Fantastic cookies! Highly recommend!

Becky Rush

We use Classic City Cookies every year for my kiddos birthday (among other occasions). They are wonderful and we never have any left because they are such a hit. We love that we can pick any theme and she makes it work every single time.

Erik Kitchen Agency- Shelter Insurance

Stopped by and bought a couple dozen of mixed variety cookies! They were great and a big hit!

Jay Shaffer

This was our first time stopping here and just to be clear it was a little later in the day so I can only speak to our experience. The place is a neat little shop in an older building so there is a nice atmosphere in there. The person that was there was very nice and helpful. Our selection of cookies was limited due to the time of day we were there. We got a frosted sugar cookie, triple chocolate chip cookie, and a snicker doodle. All were good size. Taste was good but felt like they were missing just a little something. Overall it was a good experience and would recommend checking it out. Go early for best selection ?

Michael Slavin

I just like how she handles the business. if you read this hi

Julie Voirol

We tried three big buttery cookies and they were perfectly baked and very satisfying. They have the classics, iced sugar cookies, snickerdoodles, peanut butter, and chocolate chip, as well as a couple other choices.

Diane Vance

Good cookies and friendly staff

nancy simmons

Wonderful variety of cookies... shared with friends and took a box to meet a new friend! Great hostess gift! Delicious!

Catherine Napier

Our favorite cookie place worth every penny!! Always friendly service and great products

Julie Lounds

I was extremely hurt and disappointed yesterday. I have gotten many cookies here for special occasions. Yesterday was different. I had correspondence via instagram for an order. The owner responded and said, she would do it but needed my email address to send an invoice. I had been looking for it and did not get one. These were important to me because my brother has been extremely sick and he turns 60 in a few days. I wanted to cheer him up. As stated, I’ve done business before and had her phone number so I texted to ask about invoice. The owners response…”this is my personal phone number do not text it for business”. Nothing else… seems like the nice way to respond would be, “youmust not know we have a store phone number now, I’ll get the invoice to you but next time use this number.” So unprofessional and basically unkind. I have always been happy enough with the product. Hence multiple orders for special events. I apologized and promptly went to instagram and cancelled my order and apologized again. Again zero response. I think good business practice would, be an apology for her rudeness. I guess a dozen cookies aren’t worth her concern. I am very sad about this. Very doubtful I will do business again. I have always been an understanding consumer and know how busy the shop is. HOWEVER, I will not tolerate being treated disrespectfully.

Bonnie Parker

The rich flavor of these cookies, definitely hit the obsession part of the brain. Ordered out of state, cookies were broken upon arrival. I was offered a refund but didn’t take it, it wasn’t about the money for me personally. Maybe we should look into different packaging or shipping methods.

Lilah Contreras

The rich flavor of these cookies, definitely hit the obsession part of the brain. Ordered out of state, cookies were broken upon arrival. I was offered a refund but didn’t take it, it wasn’t about the money for me personally. Maybe we should look into different packaging or shipping methods.

Loading...