Third and Main Restaurant

223 3rd St, Aurora
(812) 655-9727

Recent Reviews

Courtney Savilla

My husband and I have been here once before and it was great, but we came when very busy. This time we stopped for an early dinner when it was relatively calm. Our waitress Haley was excellent, quite possibly the best service either of us have ever had. We got drinks, I had sushi, he had the lamb. Honestly the best sushi I've ever had, and I'm not new to this. The thai basil sauce was fabulous. The lamb was phenomenal as well (that mint pesto? Chef's kiss). We had cheesecake for dessert. The restaurant has been remodeled since our last visit and it looks great, loved the vibe. The owners clearly understand that you have to spend money to make money. Overall 10/10, one of our favorite places ever.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Rack of Lamb, Mashed Potatoes

Pete Roush

What a great find. The food was excellent from the shrimp cocktail to the steak (add the crab and shrimp topper) to the salad. The service was amazing. Atmosphere perfect. This a must go. I enjoyed my birthday dinner.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wagyu, Mashed Potatoes, Salad

Mike Lotz

The best selection of steak in the area.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

SuzanneC

Absolutely delicious meal from start to finish. Started with the mussels appetizer. We had the filet and strip Australian Wagyu. Best steak we have ever eaten. Ended with cheesecake. Worth every penny.

D.Y. H.W.

So this post is super late... But my husband and I went for our 12th Anniversary and we are coming up on our 13th Anniversary hehehehe. Music was a bit loud but our waiter was phenomenal. Debating if we should come back again this Anniversary. We sat at a high top table, next to some small historical trinkets around us and posted on the walls. Food was amazing. My husband got the lamb.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Rack of Lamb, Creme Brulee

Brian Wunderlich

Great for a date night!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Rack of Lamb, Creme Brulee

Michael Schwaller

Wife and I drove about an hour away for me birthday and we were not disappointed. Coming from a couple who work in the steakhouse industry this place was an absolute dime and we intend to come back in the future. Thanks to Matt Everything was a 10/10

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jessica B.

Third and Main is a great place where you should consider celebrating important days. It is expensive but well worth it for a special occasion.

Highly recommend to everyone! Love this place cause you can go big or not. And either way your treated the same which is incredible! The food is always incredible, gotta try the ham and cheese grits side. If you haven't been be sure to go soon!

Mae Renners

This is one of THE BEST restaurants I have ever been. The atmosphere is welcoming yet sophisticated. The employees are super friendly, accommodating, and knowledgeable. The chef is AMAZING! I was especially impressed because I am a vegetarian and the menu mostly has meat entrees, but the waiter talked to the kitchen and they made me a special meal that I requested!!! Everything is delicious; you can not go wrong. It's worth every penny! I will definitely go back and soon.Vegetarian options: The chef and wait staff will help and accommodate.

Recommended dishes: Steakhouse Cheese Cake, KeyLime Pie, Creme Brulee, Chocolate Cake, Mashed Potatoes, Cake, Salad

GingerL

We hadn't been there in a few years and all I can say is “wow”! Exceeded our expectations. Not only great food but the ambiance was fantastic. Waiter was awesome and made our experience extra special. We will definitely be back! Ginger Love

TammyG

Went our son's birthday and everything was great. The service was great, the food was great and the ambiance was great. We had a great time and our waitress was the sweetest and nicest person.

beerlover

Went for wife's birthday. We let them know with the reservation that our toddler would be joining also, they had a high chair set up and ready at the table. Best steak in the region. The Australian wagyu strip and filet were both fantastic.

John Carnevale

Great service, very good steaks with a small town charm.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Samantha Eam

The price wasn’t worth the food.

Load More

Third and Main Restaurant

223 3rd St, Aurora, IN 47001
(812) 655-9727