Up Cellar

63 Baldwin St, Bargersville
(317) 533-0845

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Cailey

Our reservation was set for 7:30, we were not sat till 8:00. If I knew we would be waiting for 30 mins I wouldn't booked. I talked to another couple there reservations was for 7:30 as well a they were sat before us at 7:45 but we then had to wait another 15 mins. Very disappointing. Yes it's hard to get people to leave from the tables but 30 mins delay with nothing offered for our time waited was poorly handled. For $250 food wasn't over the top.

Donald

The food was extremely salty. However, the service was excellent and the ambience was great for a romantic dinner.

Nancy

Lovely place with great service, delicious food and wonderful drink options. We will be returning.

Brian

Servers were awesome. When we called prior to the event to ask the price of the event, we were told $50-60 per person. We were in a bit of shock when we arrived and the price was $80 per person.

Nathan

Service was great our waitress was the highlight of our experience. But the food was subpar for the price.

Janet

The menu offered a nice selection. There is a very pleasant ambiance. The service was very efficient and attentive. The food was delicious and well prepared. The signature cocktails were also enjoyable! We will definitely be visiting again.

anne

Lexi and the rest of the staff did an awesome job with the crowd they had! Awesome per usual!

Elizabeth

Our waitress was excellent. However we had a reservation at 7:30. We didn't get seated until 7:50.

Marnie

Lexi was wonderful. She always is when we go to Up Cellar. The food was superb. We love going to Up Cellar. Always a relaxing time.

Morgan

We have been to Up Cellar several times, but this was a significant disappointment, and for a special occasion at that. We had to pay a deposit for a reservation, so I had high expectations. We waited 50 min beyond our reservation time for our table. Service was incredibly slow (and I understand timing of a meal from a serving standpoint, this was beyond that). The server did not offer the glasses of complimentary bubbles, we had to ask when entrees were brought out. The cost of our reservation was not taken off our bill. At the end of the night, I politely voiced my concerns and requested to talk to the manager. The manger didn't come to the table and they just took $10 off the meal (after then adding a 20% gratuity to the new bill). We were there for over 3 hours. Even a simple apology would have gone a long way. The food was great but the service was enough to prevent me from returning for any special occasion.

Doug

Great choice for New Year's Eve. Food was delicious and we were able to take our time and enjoy the evening.

Stacey

Perfect New Year's Eve dinner with our adult children. Thank you for the second year in a row and what is now a tradition:

casey jones

Ive been here twice now. Once was great, the 2nd time the steak was trash . Absolute joke of a meal .. and I ordered the same thing both times!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Bonnie

Another excellent experience at The Up Cellar. Our neighbors came with us to Happy Hour. We enjoyed the oysters, crabcake, filet sliders, wine,etc. All at a very reasonable price during Happy Hour. Our waitress Lexi always adds to the experience. Up Cellar is in a class of it's own. Thank you.

Christopher

My absolute favorite restaurant. Absolutely love their burger and happy hour specials. I'm shocked it's not busier.

Loading...