Ordered (2) 16” Pepperoni Feast pizzas (not just pepperoni, PEPPERONI FEAST), regular cheese (no Extra cheese) for pickup. $72.50 and left the change from my $80 tendered for tip. When I got home I had to chew my way through 3 full pieces before I got the first speck of pepperoni! Again, these were to have been PEPPERONI FEASTS. I blame myself, really, as this is typical for the Bluffton store. But since it was raining I chose not to drive the extra 16 miles round trip to Decatur where I’ve always been served good pizza, at $15-20 cheaper (for 2 pies). The Bluffton store has friendly service, but they consistently scrimp on toppings. I don’t care if it’s raining, snowing or a hurricane Decatur Pizza King will be my store from here on out.
Food: 1
Service: 5
Nicolas Loves traveling
I used to work there and good God, being there was miserable. Actually let me rephrase that, being here on days that Sheila and Haleigh were working was miserable. They got such toxic attitudes, it’s no wonder why they struggle to find anyone. When it comes to how they do things, they do things immaturely and it’s all so disorganized in which it creates a bunch of chaos. Anytime you make a mistake, even a small one like maybe accidentally knocking over a cup of water, Haleigh or her mother Sheila will lash out on you. There’s a difference between helping someone and being a jerk treating someone as though you can’t do anything right. Any mistake that’s made, the managers will treat you like a scapegoat and it’s not cool. Shelia and Haleigh are those kind of people where they want to act like God and that they don’t make mistakes. They want to be all good with the customers but when the customers aren’t around, the managers will treat their coworkers like Garbage. All the other coworkers are good people but Shelia and Haleigh are not. It’s not worth working here as I’m trying to improve my mental health and when Haleigh and her mom keep on attacking me, it doesn’t help at all. Don’t work here if you’re looking for a job, look for a different place in which the manager is kind and respectful and who won’t lose their temper over the smallest stuff.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Marvin Isch
Bluffton Pizza King has always had a great atmosphere and very kind waitresses. The food is a little bit more expensive but is always delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Smorgasbord, Breadstix, Royal Feast Pizza, Bread Sticks
Heath Gibson
Best pizza in Bluffton. It never disappoints. Those edge triangles are my fav.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rebecca Wurzelbacher
Pizza crust was very thin. The toppings were scarce. The breadsticks were ok but pretty wimpy. The cheese sauce was the best part of the meal.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Joanne Fox
They are a part of Wells council on aging and honor their discount card !!!!Parking: Sometimes parking can be a challenge when an event is going on across the street
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, All Meat Feast Pizza, Royal Feast Pizza, Bread Sticks, Hawaiian Pizza
Sherry Zoll
The best pizza king around. Pricing is somewhat reasonable. The food is great and the atmosphere is very retro. I dig it. Try the buffet.Parking: AmpleKid-friendliness: It's a joy watching youngsters enjoy their first taste of the best pizza around.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Smorgasbord, Salads, Garlic Bread, Royal Feast Pizza, Bread Sticks, Chef Salad
Seth Stout
The "Castle Room" with black lights was kinda odd. I don't like eating in a darker area but the kids liked it. Pizza was really good and friendly
Ashley Spillman
The food was so gross. I only got bread sticks thank God because they were not done not real breadsticks and soggy as a wet paper towel.
S Gerber
Great local staple for many years. Nice upstairs all-you-can eat pizza and salad bar buffet. Reasonable price. One of the last places in town post pandemic that you can still get all you can eat other than the China Buffet. I still think Pizza King pizza is the best pizza.
"Buffet" is the price of a medium pizza. Sat us down, no bread sticks(cost extra and separate from buffet. Kids cup lids don't work. Manager/waitress asked us what pizza we like so they can make it "fresh". We don't know what we like. That's why we are eating the buffet. we Said we enjoyed the chicken bacon ranch from the past and would like to try the taco pizza. The buffet table can't hold more than 3 pizzas kitchen doesn't hold any in a warmer in the back so you wait. And when it came out to the buffet it was a split pizza of chicken bacon ranch and taco. The place was half full upstairs. Our table of FOUR was able to get 3 slices in total until we were waiting for food again. Not waiting for food got up to leave and the manager wanted to charge us for a full price because we had a 1/8th of a pizza
Corey Sparks
I love Pizza King, mainly the BBQ Sauce on the Hawaiian Pizza. We don't frequent it as much, due to the high prices. It's only Pizza... The highest priced Pizza in town. Make sure you have your rewards card stamped.
David Koedel
Only been here once this year. Beyond expectations and great food. Unfortunately they don’t open until 4. I believe I would purchase more from here if they opened sooner than 4 pm
Shawna Scott-Hamilton
This place had been a favorite my whole life until I went keto 4 years ago. But last night, I learned they have both crustless and cauliflower crust options!! Great Indiana chain of restaurants, and The Castle Room is a black light fun time!!Dietary restrictions: Keto, gluten-free
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brent and Rosemary Kirby Kirby
We ate here on 1 of the nights they had the buffet. It was loud and busy but the service was good. We didn't get the buffet so I assumed it would take a long time to get our order. Actually it came out really fast and surprised us. We got a medium pepperoni feast, an order of breadsticks and 1 of us got the salad bar. The breadsticks looked nicely browned but were undercooked and doughy inside. They gave a large helping of nacho cheese for dipping. The pizza was unusually greasy, even for a pepperoni feast, but tasted okay otherwise. Salad bar was stocked okay and was reasonably priced.
Ordered (2) 16” Pepperoni Feast pizzas (not just pepperoni, PEPPERONI FEAST), regular cheese (no Extra cheese) for pickup. $72.50 and left the change from my $80 tendered for tip. When I got home I had to chew my way through 3 full pieces before I got the first speck of pepperoni! Again, these were to have been PEPPERONI FEASTS. I blame myself, really, as this is typical for the Bluffton store. But since it was raining I chose not to drive the extra 16 miles round trip to Decatur where I’ve always been served good pizza, at $15-20 cheaper (for 2 pies). The Bluffton store has friendly service, but they consistently scrimp on toppings. I don’t care if it’s raining, snowing or a hurricane Decatur Pizza King will be my store from here on out.
Food: 1
Service: 5
I used to work there and good God, being there was miserable. Actually let me rephrase that, being here on days that Sheila and Haleigh were working was miserable. They got such toxic attitudes, it’s no wonder why they struggle to find anyone. When it comes to how they do things, they do things immaturely and it’s all so disorganized in which it creates a bunch of chaos. Anytime you make a mistake, even a small one like maybe accidentally knocking over a cup of water, Haleigh or her mother Sheila will lash out on you. There’s a difference between helping someone and being a jerk treating someone as though you can’t do anything right. Any mistake that’s made, the managers will treat you like a scapegoat and it’s not cool. Shelia and Haleigh are those kind of people where they want to act like God and that they don’t make mistakes. They want to be all good with the customers but when the customers aren’t around, the managers will treat their coworkers like Garbage. All the other coworkers are good people but Shelia and Haleigh are not. It’s not worth working here as I’m trying to improve my mental health and when Haleigh and her mom keep on attacking me, it doesn’t help at all. Don’t work here if you’re looking for a job, look for a different place in which the manager is kind and respectful and who won’t lose their temper over the smallest stuff.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Bluffton Pizza King has always had a great atmosphere and very kind waitresses. The food is a little bit more expensive but is always delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Smorgasbord, Breadstix, Royal Feast Pizza, Bread Sticks
Best pizza in Bluffton. It never disappoints. Those edge triangles are my fav.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza crust was very thin. The toppings were scarce. The breadsticks were ok but pretty wimpy. The cheese sauce was the best part of the meal.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
They are a part of Wells council on aging and honor their discount card !!!!Parking: Sometimes parking can be a challenge when an event is going on across the street
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, All Meat Feast Pizza, Royal Feast Pizza, Bread Sticks, Hawaiian Pizza
The best pizza king around. Pricing is somewhat reasonable. The food is great and the atmosphere is very retro. I dig it. Try the buffet.Parking: AmpleKid-friendliness: It's a joy watching youngsters enjoy their first taste of the best pizza around.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Smorgasbord, Salads, Garlic Bread, Royal Feast Pizza, Bread Sticks, Chef Salad
The "Castle Room" with black lights was kinda odd. I don't like eating in a darker area but the kids liked it. Pizza was really good and friendly
The food was so gross. I only got bread sticks thank God because they were not done not real breadsticks and soggy as a wet paper towel.
Great local staple for many years. Nice upstairs all-you-can eat pizza and salad bar buffet. Reasonable price. One of the last places in town post pandemic that you can still get all you can eat other than the China Buffet. I still think Pizza King pizza is the best pizza.
Restaurantji Recommends
"Buffet" is the price of a medium pizza. Sat us down, no bread sticks(cost extra and separate from buffet. Kids cup lids don't work. Manager/waitress asked us what pizza we like so they can make it "fresh". We don't know what we like. That's why we are eating the buffet. we Said we enjoyed the chicken bacon ranch from the past and would like to try the taco pizza. The buffet table can't hold more than 3 pizzas kitchen doesn't hold any in a warmer in the back so you wait. And when it came out to the buffet it was a split pizza of chicken bacon ranch and taco. The place was half full upstairs. Our table of FOUR was able to get 3 slices in total until we were waiting for food again. Not waiting for food got up to leave and the manager wanted to charge us for a full price because we had a 1/8th of a pizza
I love Pizza King, mainly the BBQ Sauce on the Hawaiian Pizza. We don't frequent it as much, due to the high prices. It's only Pizza... The highest priced Pizza in town. Make sure you have your rewards card stamped.
Only been here once this year. Beyond expectations and great food. Unfortunately they don’t open until 4. I believe I would purchase more from here if they opened sooner than 4 pm
This place had been a favorite my whole life until I went keto 4 years ago. But last night, I learned they have both crustless and cauliflower crust options!! Great Indiana chain of restaurants, and The Castle Room is a black light fun time!!Dietary restrictions: Keto, gluten-free
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We ate here on 1 of the nights they had the buffet. It was loud and busy but the service was good. We didn't get the buffet so I assumed it would take a long time to get our order. Actually it came out really fast and surprised us. We got a medium pepperoni feast, an order of breadsticks and 1 of us got the salad bar. The breadsticks looked nicely browned but were undercooked and doughy inside. They gave a large helping of nacho cheese for dipping. The pizza was unusually greasy, even for a pepperoni feast, but tasted okay otherwise. Salad bar was stocked okay and was reasonably priced.