Great find in Bluffton! So many options of pizza toppings and we didn't even look at the grinder menu! This place is perfect for vegan foodies! Our son is dairy and egg- free. The crusts are free of both and they have a gluten- free crust option. He had dairy-free cheese for the first time and lived it! We'll be back because it's very hard to find pizza places with vegan options! The pic is of a meal deal with pizza and dairy- free cheese garlic bread with drink. He loved having his own platter!
Dietary restrictions: Many options for dairy- free and egg-free
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Erin Toland
The BEST Gluten Free Pizza and Bailey bread! So thankful to have a gluten free option that is sooooo delicious!!
Tyeger's is one of Bluffton, Indiana's best pizza places. I fell in love with the pizza with the first bite, or maybe the 2nd was to make sure lol. (AMAZING)!! It's a friendly place and a busy place. Perfect for family dine-in or Take-out. Plenty of free parking, and you're definitely going to want to come back. My wife and I had an incredible experience. We added it to our favorites list.
Great pizza and atmosphere. If you get lucky and they have meatloaf pizza, it's a must try! Their lunch special is great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Deluxe Pizza, Garlic Bread with Cheese
Jennifer Lynn
We came to Bluffton to check out the community to see if we wanted move here. This place is amazing. Make sure you stop by.
Gordon Londini
Got a chance to visit Tyegers Pizza in Decatur this week and it was an interesting experience. Overall, the experience was a good one. The store shares a building with Subway and is decorated in a tiger theme. This kind of threw us off based on the Irish theme of the menu, but it didn't stop us from tasting the few of the pizzas they had to offer. Most of us went for the meal deal which is extended to any of the pizzas Ford $10.50 at the time that we were there. Basically you could get any pizza with cheese bread and a drink for the meal deal price listed on the menu. The drinks are limited to canned pop and bottled water. This in a way is a good idea on their part. With only himself and his family running the place, being able to clean up quickly is a must and there were no dishes or cups that needed to be cleaned after each patron. Everything is served on cardboard or to-go containers.
Now to the food. I thought the pizzas that we were able to taste were good. The Dubliner, Wexford, and Mick were my favorites. The loaded baked potato sounded really good but I think was a little undercooked and a bit soggy. The Wexford had a pretty good Buffalo and onion flavor that really came through. I forget the name of the mushroom and ricotta pizza but it was good. Nothing stood out to me as amazing, but we enjoyed our time and enjoyed the food.
Cheese bread was good and the gluten-free cheese bread as well was very good. The marinara sauce that came with everything was pretty sweet and I liked that better than a standard marinara sauce.
We have driven 90 minutes + at least 4 times to go eat there just to find out they’ve decided to close. Hours online are not accurate. Food is amazing but I have no idea how he stays open. If you ever get there and they’re open get the loaded potato pizza. The one with corned beef. It’s phenomenal. Just wish he had and kept his hours.
Great food. Great prices. Owner is always friendly and gives great suggestions on their menu. Pizza is great but they also have the best hot subs in town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kim S
Great food and fantastic service!
Vegetarian options: Many options can be made vegetarian.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tralee, Garlic Bread with Cheese
Brian Hubble
Great pizza, great owner, and overall a great place to be at. It’s a good local business that you can tell cares about doing their best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nicholas Huntley
Delicious. Nice & crispy cupped pepperonis and crust.
Great find in Bluffton! So many options of pizza toppings and we didn't even look at the grinder menu! This place is perfect for vegan foodies! Our son is dairy and egg- free. The crusts are free of both and they have a gluten- free crust option. He had dairy-free cheese for the first time and lived it! We'll be back because it's very hard to find pizza places with vegan options! The pic is of a meal deal with pizza and dairy- free cheese garlic bread with drink. He loved having his own platter!
Dietary restrictions: Many options for dairy- free and egg-free
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The BEST Gluten Free Pizza and Bailey bread! So thankful to have a gluten free option that is sooooo delicious!!
Dietary restrictions: Gluten Free
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Waterford, BBQ Chicken Pizza, Tyeger's Reuben Pizza, Bailey Garlic & Cheese Sticks Gluten Free, BBQ Chicken the Mick Pizza Gluten Free
Tyeger's is one of Bluffton, Indiana's best pizza places. I fell in love with the pizza with the first bite, or maybe the 2nd was to make sure lol.
(AMAZING)!! It's a friendly place and a busy place. Perfect for family dine-in or
Take-out. Plenty of free parking, and you're definitely going to want to come back.
My wife and I had an incredible experience. We added it to our favorites list.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Deluxe Pizza, Irish Loaded Baked Potato Pizza, BBQ Chicken Pizza, Parlour Pie, Pub Crawler Sub, Garlic Bread with Cheese, Tyeger's Reuben Pizza
Awesome pizza! Friendly, fast service! :)
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza and atmosphere. If you get lucky and they have meatloaf pizza, it's a must try! Their lunch special is great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Deluxe Pizza, Garlic Bread with Cheese
We came to Bluffton to check out the community to see if we wanted move here. This place is amazing. Make sure you stop by.
Got a chance to visit Tyegers Pizza in Decatur this week and it was an interesting experience. Overall, the experience was a good one. The store shares a building with Subway and is decorated in a tiger theme. This kind of threw us off based on the Irish theme of the menu, but it didn't stop us from tasting the few of the pizzas they had to offer. Most of us went for the meal deal which is extended to any of the pizzas Ford $10.50 at the time that we were there. Basically you could get any pizza with cheese bread and a drink for the meal deal price listed on the menu. The drinks are limited to canned pop and bottled water. This in a way is a good idea on their part. With only himself and his family running the place, being able to clean up quickly is a must and there were no dishes or cups that needed to be cleaned after each patron. Everything is served on cardboard or to-go containers.
Now to the food. I thought the pizzas that we were able to taste were good. The Dubliner, Wexford, and Mick were my favorites. The loaded baked potato sounded really good but I think was a little undercooked and a bit soggy. The Wexford had a pretty good Buffalo and onion flavor that really came through. I forget the name of the mushroom and ricotta pizza but it was good. Nothing stood out to me as amazing, but we enjoyed our time and enjoyed the food.
Cheese bread was good and the gluten-free cheese bread as well was very good. The marinara sauce that came with everything was pretty sweet and I liked that better than a standard marinara sauce.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Tralee, Irish Loaded Baked Potato Pizza, Bailey Garlic & Cheese Sticks Gluten Free, BBQ Chicken the Mick Pizza Gluten Free
Well done, 5 stars!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread with Cheese
We have driven 90 minutes + at least 4 times to go eat there just to find out they’ve decided to close. Hours online are not accurate. Food is amazing but I have no idea how he stays open. If you ever get there and they’re open get the loaded potato pizza. The one with corned beef. It’s phenomenal. Just wish he had and kept his hours.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Irish Loaded Baked Potato Pizza
Absolutely incredible pizza with regular monthly specials that are excellent. Staff has always been friendly. Best pizza in the region.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Great food. Great prices. Owner is always friendly and gives great suggestions on their menu. Pizza is great but they also have the best hot subs in town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food and fantastic service!
Vegetarian options: Many options can be made vegetarian.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tralee, Garlic Bread with Cheese
Great pizza, great owner, and overall a great place to be at. It’s a good local business that you can tell cares about doing their best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious. Nice & crispy cupped pepperonis and crust.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Easily the best pizza I've ever had.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...