Piloni's Italian Steakhouse

My boyfriend and I are major foodies & travel all over the country trying new restaurants along the way.

This is hands down in my top 3 favorite restaurants I’ve EVER been to. I ordered the shrimp scampi. The pasta is fresh and clearly homemade- the thickness, the butteriness, the taste, the texture- everything was on point. My boyfriend ordered the Surf & Turf, which is served with broccoli and risotto on the side. The risotto is one of my favorite foods I’ve ever had. I ordered a large side to take home with me. Overall, the atmosphere is warm and inviting, and our server was awesome! 100/10 will be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The fried mushrooms are divine! I really enjoyed my seafood salad as well, and my fiance loved his T-bone steak. This place is pricey, but the food really is very good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

We went on new year's eve so it was very crowded and loud. Service was mediocre, but she was very busy.Food was very good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 3

Food was very good. Definitely be back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I was very disappointed. This was my first time to this establishment and while we were finishing up our drinks our waitress asked us to leave our table for another party. I was offended and will not be returning to either location again.
BY THE WAY WE WERE THERE DECEMBER 30, 2025. THAT IS NOT NEW YEARS EVE! DON'T WORRY I WILL NOT BE BACK! STABLES HAS MUCH BETTER FOOD, ATMOSPHERE AND SERVICE FOR THE SAME PRICE!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Probably true Italian style - I’m a fan of more Americanized versions.
I had arugula salad, spaghetti w/marinara sauce only, and Italian Cream Cake.
All very good - noodles were al dente - not my favorite.
Great service - owners present
Very clean
I would definitely go back - maybe order a pizza or one of the many other options.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Always the best food and service. Very well done.

very good food! clean, nice people!

Amazing, helper server. 5 star blue gill, pasta and steak! What a great experience!

We became fans when they just had the Terre Haute location. Both of these places are amazing. If you like authentic Italian there is no better place.

Everything was good! I’d give my dish 5 stars, but my friends weren’t as impressed — so I went with a 4 🙂

The Alfredo had enough cheese for this cheese lover.

I ordered ribeye steak medium which was cooked well done which was so dry it was not edible. Stuffed mushrooms were so overcooked the mushrooms inside were hard as rocks and again inedible. Chicken fettuccine Alfredo had no Alfredo sauce and the noodles were barely cooked and chewy. This meal cost over 100.00. The only portion of the meal that was good was the chef salad. Extremely disappointed. I will not eat here in the furure.

Wife ordered ny strip steak. It was paper thin and full of fat. 34 dollars. My meal did not arrive until after she finished. Lasagna was just OK. The only thing that was good was the tiramisu for dessert.Would not recommend this place if you are looking for good quality.

Outstanding service & food ! Very friendly.