Two Guys Catering and Bakery

everything i've had here is excellent but a special shout out to the cinnamon rolls and pasta salad!
worth traveling in for even if you're staying over by the lakes!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

My daughter got me the vanilla cookie sandwich for Valentine’s Day! It was the best cookie I’ve ever eaten!

Always good no matter what you get.

Can get cramped and overwhelming very easily. The line/ordering situation could be improved. With that said, the food and pastries here are THE BEST in the area!!!!! EVERYTHING is good here!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Doughnuts, Home Fries

Two Guys is just amazing! They have a wonderful and friendly staff and the food is always delicious. You can’t go home without a box of baked goods, either!

I went into Two Guys Bakery after a disaster cookie order from another bakery left me without cookies I needed in just a few hours. I needed them for a special event and there was no way I was going to serve the cookies the other bakery made. I spoke with someone at 12:50 and she made magic happen. She had 2 dozen custom cookies ready for me by 4:00. She took care of me! I will definitely be back!

It pains me to write this review, but, after years of going to this bakery, my family will not be going again. My wife, children, and one of my wife's friends went into the bakery today, November 30, 2024, about 30 minutes before closing. The entire experience screamed "No kids preferred."

Before even entering the establishment, one is greeted with lovely Christmas decorations that have very un-lovely signs stating how one should stay way from the decorations and make sure not to touch the merchandise.

The experience did not improve while in the establishment. While eating, they felt rushed by the staff, being continually asked, "Do you need a box for that?" I get it, it's close to closing time, but please allow them the time necessarily to peacefully eat their food.

The most egregious part came when my son, who has special needs, was playing with one of the suckers - continually asking his mommy if he could have it. Eventually, after reaching her limit, my wife asks him to put it up, which he started to do. Immediately, the person behind the counter, who had apparently been watching the entire situation unfold, states, "You cannot put that back. He licked the wrapper." Okay. So be it. My wife paid for them. BUT, rather than spending much more money on other sweets - as she was planning to do - she decided to pay for the two suckers at $1.89/piece and then leave.

The worker's overreaction to the situation stinks. I wished it could have been laughed at, and then moved forward. We would have even paid for the suckers, but the worker's overreaction was too much. Please do better.

Service: 1

I quit Krispy Kreme and Crumbl Cookie but
#ICantQuitYou You’re simply the best!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great bakery. A little pricey but most are if they are good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pastries, Cream Horns, Cinnamon Rolls, Cookies

2 dozen donuts for for work pre order were waiting within 15 mins great staff and delicious food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Doughnuts

Breakfast was wonderful. Wish we had a place like this in our big city.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This is a great local bakery, the cinnamon rolls are amazing!

Saturday was the first time I went to the zionsville farmers market. Two guys bakery was at the market and they will be the sole reason I come back to the market. The most amazing donut holes and cinnamon roll I have ever had. I can’t wait to try more of their delicious treats!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The food is amazing. We had our wedding catered and have received SO many compliments on the food!!! If you are considering catering with them JUST DO IT!!!!

Hosted a graduation breakfast and needed donuts. Because we live in Monticello, I was going to need to pick them up on Friday to have them on time. Randy said, absolutely not, they wouldn’t want us to serve their donuts day old and that I could pick them up before they opened on Saturday. Not only was their service outstanding but the donuts received rave reviews. Working with Two Guys was hands down the best experience. Thank you so much!

Food: 5

Service: 5