Mandy's Ice Cream

1042 E Main St, Brownsburg
(317) 350-2467

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kyle Beswick (Bezzquik)

Best customer service I've ever had anywhere. Mandy is awesome. And the ice cream itself is incredible (sourced from Madison)

Karynn Lorenzini

This is one of our favorite places to go as a family. The flavors are unique and absolutely delicious - in my personal top 3 ice cream places of all time. The staff is so friendly and welcoming. We live 30 minutes away, but whenever we make it to Brownsburg we try to get to Mandy’s.

Will Smith

Best ice cream I've ever had. Love this place!

Ro Indy Realtor

This was my first visit. It seems like a family business. There was a small wait as only two people were working. They didn't seem stressed or overwhelmed and both were very patient. They didn't have my flavor ice cream but I was able to make it work by adding toppings. It wasn't bad. There are also benches outside as well to sit. There wasn't a trash outside so you had to go back in to throw away the garbage.

Emma Rose

Nothing is better than Mandy’s ice cream! Such a gem in town! We love stopping in!🤍

Ashley Smith

The worker scooping our ice cream promptly blew his nose after and didn’t wash his hands. My husband noticed people dipping ice cream directly in sprinkles. Definitely some food and health safety concerns here 😬

Beth Sweet

Always excellent service and great selection. Love the ice cream nachos! So good!!! We got the peanut butter cookie dough!

Paul Cooper (Coops)

Awesome place. Always good service. This place rocks. It can be a wait but they keep the line moving and it is well worth the wait. Lots of options and a great selection to pick from

Tasha Baker

Best ice cream and staff in Brownsburg!!!

Kaiya Cummins

I’ll forever be grateful to Mandy - a wonderful woman, mother, and local entrepreneur that we should all be proud of - for her ice cream shop! The staff is always friendly and can’t beat the ice cream and shakes! Everything is made with love every time i go. I’ve created so many memories at the shop and cant wait to make more!!! everytime the sun starts going down on a summer night i can’t help but crave sitting out on the patio at Mandy’s laughing with friends and family. GIVE THIS PLACE A TRY IF ITS THE LAST THING YOU DO.

Courtney Scott

The staff overlooked the people who were next in line, tried to humiliate patrons, and threw items at a child. Not worth the ice cream. I like the Owner but she needs to find better staff.

Mary Catherine Bloxham

Just had the best Zanzibar chocolate milkshake made by Logan. Ask for him if you want the best milkshake ever!

Eric Cottongim

Simply the Best

Lauren Anno

Mandy's is the best! Amazing ice cream and the staff is the friendliest in town.

Emily Stefanelli

We visited this ice cream shop yesterday while visiting the area from out of state. It is an absolute gem! They have tons of options, all bursting with flavor. The customer experience is unmatched. Mandy is an absolute delight! She genuinely listened to my likes and dislikes and continued to offer suggestions and samples of flavors she thought I’d love (all of which I did!). Her clear passion for what she does shines through in her interactions with customers. I travel to the area often for work and most definitely will be back! This place is a must stop. Do not pass by Mandy’s without coming in for a sweet treat!

Loading...