After looking on your website. Decided to go a few nights ago.. CLOSED! Better update it online
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Pat Rabyk
We were finally able to go back, since we kept missing when they were open.Staff friendly as alwaysMenu, very limited (AND BTW not what’s advertised on here)!Quick serviceFood, WoW SO disappointed ☹️ I would have rather eaten at McDonalds ?I really don’t foresee them staying open much longerAnd we will NOT be going back!
Alaine Bohnsak
Goodfella’s Bar & Grill located on Wicker Ave in the town of Cedar Lake, IN is a gangster themed style bar & grille. There is access off Wicker Ave by side street to the parking area. My first impression was how eye catching the building was. It was brightly lit as you walk up to a chalk drawing of a body .. Off to the side props to take photos with.. Once inside famous gangsters lined the walls as well as machine gun. There is a photo opportunity to add your face to a wall of other (convict) customers should you choose which I thought fun ..Lots of stuff to look at! We showed up on a weekday night with a couple locals at the bar the food was good, restaurant clean & service spot on.. I had a cheese pizza and my friend the mozzarella burger which he said was delicious. All in all a good pub, gangster memorabilia & friendly atmosphere. Goodfella’s Bar & Grill would be great for a casual night out for adults.
Tom Perez
Very rude staff and dislikes anyone, how do I put this, that thinks there's only 2 genders. The parking lot 95% of the time has under 5 cars. You get better food out of a microwave. 110% chance this place will be bought up and turned into something nice, which I'm very happy about.
Michael Przybocki
First time ordering since they are new on Doordash. Ordered a large sausage pizza and mozzarella sticks. Expensive for mozz sticks... Nothing special about them. Your standard mozz sticks. The pizza was a disaster... Slices all flopped and folded over each other. Ordered because Rosati's in St John is closed on Tuesdays and always open to try something new. Didn't work out tonight. Now I love thin crust, but it was so thin it was in shambles when it arrived. And we literally had an average of one piece of sausage per slice. The sauce is VERY peppery. My wife took one bite and decided she's eating something else tonight. I stuck with it simply because we paid $35 for our food... But it's not really good. I won't order again. I was hoping the recent reviews were wrong and that the older reviews for the pizza were correct. That's the not case. It has the potential to be good... Figure out the crust, little more topping, and ease up on the pepper in the sauce. That's a recommendation from someone who makes his own pizza dough and sauce from scratch.
Mackenzie Lynn
We used to go here all the time. The pizza WAS great. Recent they must have recently changed the recipe because the pizza is so this it almost falls apart now. They also now charge a $3 credit card fee…3% I think is fair but $3 is very high for most transactions. Service is ok but really disappointing they changed the pizza recipe
Jeremy Beck
I love that they're bringing in Mario. Loved him at Nick's. Can't wait to start seeing him at Goodfellas.
Nicholas Radick
Yeah this place has got a great atmosphere, old-school mob themed bar, freaking awesome.
joshua rose
New Chef, Great food, Dedicated hard working staff, awesome environment. If it's been a while stop in, the pulled pork is amazing! This is not a "big chain" folks and that's a good thing. Food is made to order and not squeezed out of a bag and microwaved. Give'em a try and you will see!
Jodi Miller
Nikki was a wonderful out going bartender. The Bloody Mary was amazing!!! She is a keeper!
Do not and I repeat do not bring your family and especially your children here ever. Very rude staff, HORRIBLE food and bad environment. They really dislike cedar lake so that should tell you everything you need to know. I've never seen more then 10 cars ever in their parking lot. Please avoid at all costs.
Adri B.
Just ordered from here through GrubHub and got my delivery. Missing one complete meal so we have to go out and get something else for that person. Our order ended up being over $90 for 3 ppl. About $10 for delivery, $9 service charge, $12 for tip. GrubHubs solution was to refund the amount of the missing meal only ($10). On top of that, food had already cooled and burger completely dry and it was missing its paid addons when it got here. Buyer beware! I used to go to this restaurant years ago and was excited to introduce them.
Cheyenne McCormick
Awesome look, love Capone statue outside!!! Fire pit at night
Gail F.
The bathrooms were not clean and in bad repair. I waited 45 minutes for my burger only to be told they were "out of them." In reality, they were frozen and they didn't want to thaw them out. I then waited another 30 minutes for pulled pork sliders that had very little meat in them. I will not be back.
Thomas Frazier
Okay. So haven't been here in several years so I was open to come try it out and support local restaurant chains. But when we went to order they legit said they have this as the menu. And they said we have no hamburgers. So for your mains you have 3 of the 4 main items. So I refuse to order or even finished my drink. For the servers who knows who I am. You better believe I'm this petty.
After looking on your website. Decided to go a few nights ago.. CLOSED! Better update it online
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
We were finally able to go back, since we kept missing when they were open.Staff friendly as alwaysMenu, very limited (AND BTW not what’s advertised on here)!Quick serviceFood, WoW SO disappointed ☹️ I would have rather eaten at McDonalds ?I really don’t foresee them staying open much longerAnd we will NOT be going back!
Goodfella’s Bar & Grill located on Wicker Ave in the town of Cedar Lake, IN is a gangster themed style bar & grille. There is access off Wicker Ave by side street to the parking area. My first impression was how eye catching the building was. It was brightly lit as you walk up to a chalk drawing of a body .. Off to the side props to take photos with.. Once inside famous gangsters lined the walls as well as machine gun. There is a photo opportunity to add your face to a wall of other (convict) customers should you choose which I thought fun ..Lots of stuff to look at! We showed up on a weekday night with a couple locals at the bar the food was good, restaurant clean & service spot on.. I had a cheese pizza and my friend the mozzarella burger which he said was delicious. All in all a good pub, gangster memorabilia & friendly atmosphere. Goodfella’s Bar & Grill would be great for a casual night out for adults.
Very rude staff and dislikes anyone, how do I put this, that thinks there's only 2 genders. The parking lot 95% of the time has under 5 cars. You get better food out of a microwave. 110% chance this place will be bought up and turned into something nice, which I'm very happy about.
First time ordering since they are new on Doordash. Ordered a large sausage pizza and mozzarella sticks. Expensive for mozz sticks... Nothing special about them. Your standard mozz sticks. The pizza was a disaster... Slices all flopped and folded over each other. Ordered because Rosati's in St John is closed on Tuesdays and always open to try something new. Didn't work out tonight. Now I love thin crust, but it was so thin it was in shambles when it arrived. And we literally had an average of one piece of sausage per slice. The sauce is VERY peppery. My wife took one bite and decided she's eating something else tonight. I stuck with it simply because we paid $35 for our food... But it's not really good. I won't order again. I was hoping the recent reviews were wrong and that the older reviews for the pizza were correct. That's the not case. It has the potential to be good... Figure out the crust, little more topping, and ease up on the pepper in the sauce. That's a recommendation from someone who makes his own pizza dough and sauce from scratch.
We used to go here all the time. The pizza WAS great. Recent they must have recently changed the recipe because the pizza is so this it almost falls apart now. They also now charge a $3 credit card fee…3% I think is fair but $3 is very high for most transactions. Service is ok but really disappointing they changed the pizza recipe
I love that they're bringing in Mario. Loved him at Nick's. Can't wait to start seeing him at Goodfellas.
Yeah this place has got a great atmosphere, old-school mob themed bar, freaking awesome.
New Chef, Great food, Dedicated hard working staff, awesome environment. If it's been a while stop in, the pulled pork is amazing! This is not a "big chain" folks and that's a good thing. Food is made to order and not squeezed out of a bag and microwaved. Give'em a try and you will see!
Nikki was a wonderful out going bartender. The Bloody Mary was amazing!!! She is a keeper!
Restaurantji Recommends
Do not and I repeat do not bring your family and especially your children here ever. Very rude staff, HORRIBLE food and bad environment. They really dislike cedar lake so that should tell you everything you need to know. I've never seen more then 10 cars ever in their parking lot. Please avoid at all costs.
Just ordered from here through GrubHub and got my delivery. Missing one complete meal so we have to go out and get something else for that person. Our order ended up being over $90 for 3 ppl. About $10 for delivery, $9 service charge, $12 for tip. GrubHubs solution was to refund the amount of the missing meal only ($10). On top of that, food had already cooled and burger completely dry and it was missing its paid addons when it got here. Buyer beware! I used to go to this restaurant years ago and was excited to introduce them.
Awesome look, love Capone statue outside!!! Fire pit at night
The bathrooms were not clean and in bad repair. I waited 45 minutes for my burger only to be told they were "out of them." In reality, they were frozen and they didn't want to thaw them out. I then waited another 30 minutes for pulled pork sliders that had very little meat in them. I will not be back.
Okay. So haven't been here in several years so I was open to come try it out and support local restaurant chains. But when we went to order they legit said they have this as the menu. And they said we have no hamburgers. So for your mains you have 3 of the 4 main items. So I refuse to order or even finished my drink. For the servers who knows who I am. You better believe I'm this petty.