AJ's Pizza Co

3050 Matson St, Chesterton
(219) 464-8282

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Sandra Allmon

Best pizza love their pizza. It's nice to get bonus things. Thanks

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Hippie Chick

We met friends here for dinner and hubs and I split a small pizza with tomatoes and onions and a small house salad. It was the perfect size for us! He ate four pieces of pizza and I ate two (one piece was a little bigger than the others), The sauce was a nice sweet sauce and there was lots of cheese with tiny diced tomatoes. We got to choose between white and red onions. We chose red, and they weren't too hot, so we were pleased. They had several crust types to choose from.

The salad was quite big; head lettuce, tomatoes, mushrooms, onions, cucumbers, green peppers, cheese, and croutons, and the ranch dressing was quite tasty.

Our friends split an XL sausage and cheese pizza and it was plenty big for the three of them. It probably could have easily fed four, five, six, depending on how hungry you are.

I believe that pizza isn't as good unless you drink root beer with it. The root beer was soooo good (of course, I haven't had a root beer in ages). This was definitely an excellent recommendation. Next time we're in town, we'll return.

The only issue we had was the volume level was quite loud. The ceilings are high and not finished, so the voices bounce all over the place, only getting louder and louder, and then you have to speak louder in order to be heard by the person sitting next to you, and it's a vicious circle. If they just lowered the ceilings or put in sound dampening panels, it would be much more enjoyable.

Andre Denman

My family of four Ate here. Server Julia was very nice and helpful. We ordered garlic cheese bread and large house pizza, 2 sodas and 2 waters. Total with tip $51. 4.5 stars

kelly hawkins

No matter if I’m dining in or picking up a to-go order, the serving team is always cheerful and smiling. I’m a huge fan of the thin, crispy crust pizza and can confidently award it the regions best! Everything about AJ’s is a crowd pleaser. The servers with smiles and good quality ingredients you can taste are definitely evident of a privately owned, small business! 10000% recommendation!

Tiffany Mathas

I love the pizza always amazing every time I order! Will always keep coming back!

Patricia Winter

AJ’s is a favorite of ours. Always ready on time, easily accessible, love the crispy crust and just a hint of sweetness in the sauce.

John Rivera

Had chicken tenders and a Caesar salad. Paid and waited 20 minutes or so. As I was waiting I sat down on the bench in front of the cashier one of the staff started to sweep the rug and I asked if I was in the way she continued to sweep the dirt from the rug directly to my feet I asked again I’m in your way she said no and continued sweeping that’s one. Two my order came from the back of the kitchen it’s take out no bag I had to ask for one but the lady got here order in a bag. That is why I gave one star. I’m just passing through but nevertheless customer service is what makes or breaks a restaurant. To the owner just look at the video and make your own decision.

Dan McKenna

It is under new management now, what a difference!!! (FOR THE BETTER)

Jordan Lane

Favorite place to dine in or take out! Our family loves AJs!

Alvin Hinchen

Excellent pizza Crust was outstanding Very reasonable prices Friendly service Highly recommended!!!

Jennifer Szukala

Highly recommend the boneless wings and fries!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad, Bread Twists, Fried Pickles

Nick Zaharias

We have had the food here many times between family gatherings, work get togethers and carry out. We had always loved the food but recently the quality has become terrible. It's dropped from being our favorite pizza place to one we will avoid completely. Our most recent bad experience was few days ago when we ordered 2 pizzas and wings and it went in the trash after a few bites. The crust orders were mixed up, which isn't a huge deal, and the food was cold. The cheese was runny and the wings felt like they came from a refrigerator. The order was picked up early as well but had obviously been sitting a very long time before it was picked up. We tried to give this place chances to win us back but after several bad experiences now we're not going back. There's a long list of good pizza places around us, unfortunately this is not on it anymore. RIP AJs.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 2

April Nunez

This has become a favorite of mine. The service has been hit or miss but not horrible, the food is delicious 😋

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

Teresa Mayle

We LOVE A.J's!!!! Great food, Drinks, and appetizers. Family friendly environment and games are always on.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Onion Rings, House Special Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Garlic Cheese Bread, Fried Green Beans, Italian Beef Sandwich, Bread Twists, Fried Pickles

Judith Martin

Love the "stuffed crust"

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...