Papa Johns Pizza

709 Plaza Dr #3, Chesterton
(219) 395-9220

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jonathan Asbridge

Absolutely worst papa John’s in the region, terrible management/workers. Card machine wasn’t working so the manager “from a different store” decided to call papa John’s support and just let me order sit on the counter for 30 minutes with no solutions. Had to just walk out waste of time

Dianna

Zach was amazing he was very patient and helpful. This was my first time visiting a papa John's and I have to say he made the experience a good one!

Karl Last

Easy place to grab a quick bite

Mark Hartman

Ordered last night. Showed up cold. Delivered by door dash unsealed. Total joke. I don’t expect my food to look like the website pics, but come on. I poked one of these scarcely sauce covered Tyson chicken nuggets and it reacted like rubber. I threw them all in the trash. Last time ever ordering from here.

John

Ordered delivery, paid the built in charge plus 25% for a single pizza and pop.
Order was sent out without box being sealed, left at front desk and missing pop...all because they use DoorDash.
Manager was polite when I called, but at this point it was just an FYI call.
Lesson learned though.

CJ Wilson

Sadly, there are no bean pizzas at this restaurant, so i must insist on giving them the stars they forgot to add to the menu.

Austin Burke

pizza is usually really good but every now and then it isn't great but passable. food is usually done very quickly. friendly staff

Joseph Hughes

I see a lot of poor reviews, but the girls working there were pleasant and kind, and the pizza was great.

Larry Taylor

I ordered well done which did not happen but that’s not what bothers me. What really bothers me is they either changed the crust or are no longer making it correctly. The edges used to be nice and puffy all the way around but I got two pizzas and they were both flat and I ordered all original. It’s just not the same as it used to be. One of my pizzas was a meatball pizza and I’m noy joking when I say there weren’t even one whole meatball ever two slices and most only had one quarter piece of ball on the slice like wth.

Christina Mihalek

Th see worker was super nice!

mark labere

Worst os called pizza that I ever
Ate the box it came
In probably had more flavor.

RJ K

Worst pizza ever. Paid almost $26 for a large sausage, green pepper and onion pizza. About an ounce of sausage, barely any green peppers and no noticeable onions. Total rip off. You’re better off getting a good frozen pizza. Oh and one pepperoncini and one tiny packet of special spice. What the Heck!!!!

And I noticed that the manager does not respond to any of the reviews, whether they be good or bad. So, there's no way to tell if he or she is addressing problems noted by customers.

robert schultz

They will not deliver a pizza 3 Mi away what a joke

Karlie Jackson

Food wasn't cooked. All dough was raw.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

fortn “nite”

I called asking for a bean pizza, a humble request. This is a delicacy in my home town, but instead, i was treated very rudely. One star, the food was horrible, there was none, the service was horrible, the staff were rude, one star atmosphere. It's in indiana for christ's sake.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...