We visited Ahlemeyer Bakery last week.
Though I've been wanting to write a post about their pies since then, life got in the way.
We bought three pies: apple, mixed berries, and sugar cream. Oh, the sweet taste of American pies! I'm salivating just thinking about them.
My favorite was their apple pie: a perfect blend of tart and sweet. Their pie crust, oh heaven, was soft, airy, crunchy, and buttery. I could form a mattress out of that pie crust and sink my whole body in there for eternity.
And, may I recommend vanilla ice cream to go with them pies?
Your life will feel so complete, even just for a sweet moment.
Philip
I can write a novel about how great their pie I had was. It's the closest thing to what my mom made when she was healthy.
Sara McAninch
This is my go-to local bakery for pies, cookies, cakes, and so on. My favorite thing is the German chocolate brownies. They're gooey, fresh, and always have plenty of nuts in the topping.
Debbie Hemmelgarn
I received a sugar cream pie as a gift and it was sooooo good. I’ll be coming up to get more items.
Matt Buzzard
Great place! Wonderful service and delicious desserts. Staff always nice and helpful
Jennifer Flanagan
Called from out of state to order a pie for my mom's birthday. The customer service was great. Samantha took my order and boxed up the pie for pick-up by my dad. Parents said the Sugar Cream pie was delicious! A true Indiana tradition. Thank you!
Julia Nelson Federle
I love Ahlemeyer Bakery and I go there weekly. Sarah Beth and Samantha are amazing! Everything they make is delicious! Their pies are scrumptious. in addition to all their regular goodies, they do special orders and can prepare desserts according to dietary restrictions. They do special menus for holidays and events like PI day! They are kind, helpful,friendly and have the best attitudes. We are so fortunate to have this wonderful bakery in Columbus.
Atharva t
Great vegan options !!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eva Cagwin
The vegan molasses cookies we ordered were outstanding! They were loved by our vegan and non-vegan guests.
Vegetarian options: Vegan available. You may have to pre-order.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cookies
Rhonda Davis
cookies crumbled in my hands and tasted really old. A waste of money. I won't say any more than that.
Dietary restrictions: Glutton free options if you call ahead
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cherry Pie
Robin Niedbalki
Anything you buy here is always fantastic.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeromy Bilbrey
So wonderful and easy to do business with for my son’s birthday. Thank you so much!
Matt Mottier
Very good pies. The most recent key lime pie was the best we had ever had. Amazingly good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hannah Bowman
I have been a customer of theirs since 2007. I have always loved their cherry pies. However, it seems since the new ownership has started in 2023 the cherry pie crust isn't the same anymore. It used to be flaky and cooked. Below is a picture of how they used to come and another of how they come now. When I called to ask what I need to do or ask to get the crust to rise and be flaky, Samantha was not nice because I told her I didn't have access to an oven on Memorial weekend camping to cook the top more. My family advised the dough to be soggy and inedible. I told Samantha it was gross. She got upset and told me not to use the term "gross" for it. Soggy dough is gross and I am sure not going tell her it was good. She did offer to switch it out on Tues after Memorial but I was taken back by her getting upset when I merely wanted to know how to get the crust cooked like it used to be cooked. If the crust is soggy and gross then it's soggy and gross. I'm not going to sugar coat it . If you can't handle someone saying that something didn't turn out right for a 20$ pie making it gross then maybe customer service isn't your forte. I surely wasn't rude about it but it definitely made me change my mind about supporting local small business. At least yours
We visited Ahlemeyer Bakery last week. Though I've been wanting to write a post about their pies since then, life got in the way. We bought three pies: apple, mixed berries, and sugar cream. Oh, the sweet taste of American pies! I'm salivating just thinking about them. My favorite was their apple pie: a perfect blend of tart and sweet. Their pie crust, oh heaven, was soft, airy, crunchy, and buttery. I could form a mattress out of that pie crust and sink my whole body in there for eternity. And, may I recommend vanilla ice cream to go with them pies? Your life will feel so complete, even just for a sweet moment.
I can write a novel about how great their pie I had was. It's the closest thing to what my mom made when she was healthy.
This is my go-to local bakery for pies, cookies, cakes, and so on. My favorite thing is the German chocolate brownies. They're gooey, fresh, and always have plenty of nuts in the topping.
I received a sugar cream pie as a gift and it was sooooo good. I’ll be coming up to get more items.
Great place! Wonderful service and delicious desserts. Staff always nice and helpful
Called from out of state to order a pie for my mom's birthday. The customer service was great. Samantha took my order and boxed up the pie for pick-up by my dad. Parents said the Sugar Cream pie was delicious! A true Indiana tradition. Thank you!
I love Ahlemeyer Bakery and I go there weekly. Sarah Beth and Samantha are amazing! Everything they make is delicious! Their pies are scrumptious. in addition to all their regular goodies, they do special orders and can prepare desserts according to dietary restrictions. They do special menus for holidays and events like PI day! They are kind, helpful,friendly and have the best attitudes. We are so fortunate to have this wonderful bakery in Columbus.
Great vegan options !!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The vegan molasses cookies we ordered were outstanding! They were loved by our vegan and non-vegan guests.
Vegetarian options: Vegan available. You may have to pre-order.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cookies
cookies crumbled in my hands and tasted really old. A waste of money. I won't say any more than that.
Restaurantji Recommends
Dietary restrictions: Glutton free options if you call ahead
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cherry Pie
Anything you buy here is always fantastic.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
So wonderful and easy to do business with for my son’s birthday. Thank you so much!
Very good pies. The most recent key lime pie was the best we had ever had. Amazingly good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have been a customer of theirs since 2007. I have always loved their cherry pies. However, it seems since the new ownership has started in 2023 the cherry pie crust isn't the same anymore. It used to be flaky and cooked. Below is a picture of how they used to come and another of how they come now. When I called to ask what I need to do or ask to get the crust to rise and be flaky, Samantha was not nice because I told her I didn't have access to an oven on Memorial weekend camping to cook the top more. My family advised the dough to be soggy and inedible. I told Samantha it was gross. She got upset and told me not to use the term "gross" for it. Soggy dough is gross and I am sure not going tell her it was good. She did offer to switch it out on Tues after Memorial but I was taken back by her getting upset when I merely wanted to know how to get the crust cooked like it used to be cooked. If the crust is soggy and gross then it's soggy and gross. I'm not going to sugar coat it . If you can't handle someone saying that something didn't turn out right for a 20$ pie making it gross then maybe customer service isn't your forte. I surely wasn't rude about it but it definitely made me change my mind about supporting local small business. At least yours
Food: 2
Service: 3
Loading...