Johnny Carino's

870 Creekview Dr, Columbus
(812) 372-2266

Recent Reviews Order Online

Menu

APPETIZERS
CALAMARI FRITTA
Thinly cut and lightly fried calamari and pepperoncinis. Served with spicy marinara sauce. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
SPINACH ARTICHOKE DIP
Mozzarella and Parmesan cheese, fresh spinach, artichokes and crispy pepperoni. Served with crispy pasta chips. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
FRIED RAVIOLI
Cheese raviolis lightly breaded with Italian seasoning and bread crumbs. Served with sweet chili dipping sauce. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
ITALIAN NACHOS
Crispy pasta chips, black olives, pepperoncinis, Roma tomatoes, jalapeños, Alfredo sauce, Mozzarella and Parmesan. Your choice of Chicken, Sausage, or Combo. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
MOZZERELLA STICKS
Breaded in special seasonings. Served with spicy marinara sauce. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
BAKED STUFFED MUSHROOMS
Spinach, Parmesan, red onions and garlic topped with lemon basil cream sauce, Roma tomatoes and basil. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
JOHNNY'S 15 MINUTE WINGS
Choose traditional or boneless and your choice of one of the following sauces or seasonings. Served with a side of ranch (100 Cal.). FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
APPETIZER SAMPLER
Enjoy all your Johnny Carino's favorites – Italian Nachos (Chicken, Sausage or Combo), Mozzarella Sticks and Calamari Fritta. Served with spicy marinara sauce. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM

HANDCRAFTED PIZZAS
TRADITIONAL MARGHERITA
Tomato sauce, Roma tomatoes, Mozzarella, Parmesan, fresh basil. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
BBQ CHICKEN
Sliced grilled chicken, barbeque sauce, pepperoncini, red onions, Mozzarella, Parmesan. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
PEPPERONI & PEPPERONI
Tomato sauce, Mozzarella, layers of pepperoni. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
JOHNNY'S FAVORITE
Italian sausage, pepperoni, applewood smoked bacon, green bell peppers, mushrooms, black olives, red onions, Roma tomatoes, Mozzarella, Parmesan. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
PEPPERONI & SAUSAGE
Pepperoni, Italian sausage, tomato sauce, Mozzarella. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM

SALADS
PECAN CHICKEN
Fresh spinach, Gorgonzola, Roma tomatoes, applewood smoked bacon, red onions, candied pecans, and crispy onion straws with a warm bacon vinaigrette on the side. Topped with our handmade chicken Parmesan. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
CLASSIC CAESAR
Fresh romaine, Roma tomatoes, black olives, red onions, Parmesan and garlic croutons with a Caesar dressing on the side. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
JOHNNY'S CHOPPED SALAD
Chopped romaine with Italian vinaigrette and ranch dressing on the side. Topped with applewood smoked bacon, Roma tomatoes, pepperoncini, red onions, Mozzarella cheese and artichokes. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
ITALIAN WEDGE
Iceberg wedge, applewood smoked bacon, candied pecans, Gorgonzola, Roma tomatoes, apple sticks with ranch dressing on the side. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
SIDE SALAD
FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM

CLASSIC ITALIAN
CREATE YOUR OWN PASTA
Choose your favorite pasta, one of our signature sauces and get creative! FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
BAKED CHEESE TORTELLONI
Cheese stuffed tortelloni with a creamy meat sauce. Baked with Mozzarella and Parmesan. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
CLASSIC FETTUCCINE ALFREDO
Choice of Alfredo sauce or Green Chile Jalapeño Alfredo. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
JOHNNY'S FRESH BAKED LASAGNA
Layers of pasta, Italian sausage, beef, meat sauce, ricotta, Mozzarella and Parmesan...while supplies last. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
SIZZLING SKILLETINI® CACCIATORE
Sizzling skillet with spaghetti, spicy marinara sauce, Parmesan, marinated peppers and onions. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
TIMBALLO
Hot skillet filled with spaghetti, fresh onions, peppers, mushrooms, black olives and pepperoni, baked with Mozzarella and Parmesan. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
JOHNNY'S COMBO
Johnny's Fresh Baked Lasagna, Classic Chicken Parmesan and spaghetti with tomato sauce. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
TUSCAN FIVE MEAT RIGATONI
Rigatoni, meat sauce, Italian sausage, bacon, salami, pepperoni, freshly sautéed onions and green bell peppers. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
SPAGHETTI WITH ARTICHOKES
Spaghetti sautéed with Roma tomatoes, garlic, capers, basil, black olives and Parmesan. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
CLASSIC CHEESE RAVIOLI
Large ravioli stuffed with a blend of creamy cheeses. Served with your choice of sauce. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
ITALIAN COMBINATIONS
CHOOSE ANY 2 ITEMS. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM

CHICKEN SPECIALTIES
SPICY ROMANO CHICKEN
Bowtie sautéed with sliced chicken, cayenne pepper, Romano cream sauce, mushrooms, artichokes, sun-dried tomatoes and green onions. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
CHICKEN PENNE GORGONZOLA
Penne pasta, Gorgonzola cream sauce, freshly sautéed mushrooms, garlic and Roma tomatoes. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
LEMON ROSEMARY CHICKEN
Grilled chicken breast with spaghetti, spinach, Roma tomatoes and Parmesan. Served with fresh vegetables. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
GRILLED CHICKEN BOWTIE FESTIVAL
Bowtie sautéed with sliced chicken, bacon, garlic, red onions, Roma tomatoes and Asiago cream sauce. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
CHICKEN MARSALA
Sautéed chicken breast with mushrooms and sweet wine sauce. Served with your choice of fettuccine or sautéed spinach. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
HANDMADE PARMESAN
Our signature recipe. Served with spaghetti and tomato sauce. Classic Chicken or Grilled Chicken topped with tomato sauce, Parmesan and Mozzarella. Eggplant topped with spicy marinara sauce, Parmesan and Mozzarella. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
CHICKEN SCALOPPINI
Sautéed chicken breast, mushrooms, Roma tomatoes, bacon and lemon butter cream sauce. Served with spaghetti. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
GRILLED CHICKEN JALAPEÑO RAVIOLI
Cheese-filled ravioli cooked in a green chile jalapeño Alfredo sauce with onions and peppers. Topped with grilled chicken, tomatoes, green onions and Parmesan cheese. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
CHICKEN PARMESAN RIGATONI FESTIVAL
Rigatoni pasta tossed in an Asiago cream sauce with bacon, garlic, red onions and Roma tomatoes. Topped with our Classic Chicken Parmesan and Parmesan cheese. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM

SEAFOOD
JALAPENO GARLIC TILAPIA
Tilapia sautéed in lemon butter cream sauce with garlic, spinach, jalapeños, Roma tomatoes and spaghetti. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
SHRIMP SCAMPI
Spaghetti, mushrooms, roasted garlic, Roma tomatoes, basil, Parmesan in a white wine lemon butter sauce. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
LOBSTER RAVIOLI
Served with spinach, Roma tomatoes, Asiago and lemon basil cream sauce. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
SPICY SHRIMP & CHICKEN
Penne sautéed with shrimp, sliced chicken, cayenne pepper, Romano cream sauce, mushrooms, sun-dried tomatoes and green onions. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
LEMON PEPPER SALMON*
Marinated in Italian herbs, topped with sautéed artichoke hearts, Roma tomatoes, spinach and a wine lemon butter sauce, with fresh vegetables. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
SHRIMP CARBONARA
Sautéed shrimp, bacon, peas, onions, fresh garlic and black pepper tossed with spaghetti in a lemon butter & egg cream sauce. Topped with Parmesan cheese and fresh parsley. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
SEAFOOD RIGATONI ALFREDO
Tender calamari, shrimp and mussels sautéed with fresh garlic and tossed with rigatoni in a creamy lemon basil sauce FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM

BURGERS & SANDWICHES
CLASSIC AMERICAN BURGER*
Onion, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise and ketchup. Served with fries (350 Cal.). We grill our burgers medium-well. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
JOHNNY'S BBQ BACON CHEESEBURGER*
Cheddar, onion strings, applewood smoked bacon, lettuce and barbeque sauce. Served with fries (350 Cal.). We grill our burgers medium-well. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
CHEDDAR, BACON & RANCH BURGER*
Cheddar cheese, Applewood smoked bacon, onion, lettuce, tomato and ranch dressing. Served with fries (350 Cal.). We grill our burgers medium-well. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
CHICKEN PARMESAN CLUB
Our handmade chicken Parmesan, topped with applewood smoked bacon, Mozzarella, lettuce, tomato and spicy marinara sauce. Served with fries (350 Cal.). FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM

FAMILY PLATTERS
SIZZLING SKILLETINI® CACCIATORE FAMILY PLATTER
Sizzling skillet with spaghetti, spicy marinara sauce, Parmesan, marinated peppers and onions. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
CHICKEN SCALOPPINI FAMILY PLATTER
Sautéed chicken breasts, mushrooms, Roma tomatoes, bacon and lemon butter cream sauce. Served with spaghetti. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
JOHNNY'S FRESH BAKED LASAGNA FAMILY PLATTER
Layers of pasta, Italian sausage, beef, meat sauce, ricotta, Mozzarella and Parmesan...while supplies last. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
GRILLED CHICKEN BOWTIE FESTIVAL FAMILY PLATTER
Bowtie sautéed with sliced chicken, bacon, garlic, red onions, Roma tomatoes and Asiago cream sauce. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
SPICY ROMANO CHICKEN FAMILY PLATTER
Bowtie sautéed with sliced chicken, cayenne pepper, Romano cream sauce, mushrooms, artichokes, sun-dried tomatoes and green onions. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
LEMON ROSEMARY CHICKEN FAMILY PLATTER
Grilled chicken breast with spaghetti, spinach, Roma tomatoes and Parmesan. Served with fresh vegetables.
CLASSIC FETTUCCINE ALFREDO FAMILY PLATTER
Choice of Alfredo sauce or Green Chile Jalapeño Alfredo. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
HANDMADE PARMESAN FAMILY PLATTER
Our signature recipe. Served with spaghetti and tomato sauce. Classic Chicken or Grilled Chicken topped with tomato sauce, Parmesan and Mozzarella. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
SPICY SHRIMP & CHICKEN FAMILY PLATTER
Penne sautéed with shrimp, sliced chicken, cayenne pepper, Romano cream sauce, mushrooms, sun-dried tomatoes and green onions. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
CREATE YOUR OWN PASTA FAMILY PLATTER
Choose your favorite pasta, one of our signature sauces and get creative. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM

DESSERTS
STRAWBERRY CHEESECAKE
Creamy, smooth vanilla New York cheesecake served with strawberry sauce and topped with whipped cream. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
CHOCOLATE CAKE
Rich, warm chocolate cake topped with chocolate icing. Served with vanilla ice cream. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
LEMON CREAM CAKE
Two layers of lemon soaked cream cake filled with lemon mascarpone mousse and finished with powdered sugar. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
TIRAMISU
Ladyfinger cookies soaked in coffee and layered between a sweet Italian custard blended with rum and coffee liqueur. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
TURTLE CHEESECAKE
Topped with caramel, chocolate, candied pecans and whipped cream. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM

BEVERAGES
FOUNTAIN SODAS
FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
ICED TEA
FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
ITALIAN SODAS
Choose your favorite flavor. Made with or without cream. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
FLAVORED ICED TEA
FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM

KIDS MEALS
PASTA
Pick your favorite pasta with your choice of sauce. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
PIZZA
Choose one of the following kid-size pizzas: FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
CHICKEN & BROCCOLI PENNE
Penne pasta with sliced chicken and broccoli with Alfredo sauce. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
GRILLED CHICKEN
Grilled chicken with spaghetti & tomato sauce (360 Cal.) or Fresh Vegetables (320 Cal.). FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
CHEESE TORTELLONI
Cheese-stuffed pasta with tomato sauce. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
CHICKEN NUGGETS WITH FRIES
Breaded chicken nuggets served with fries and a side of BBQ Sauce. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
MAC AND CHEESE
Bowtie pasta with Alfredo cheese sauce. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
RIBS WITH FRIES
Ribs slathered with BBQ sauce and served with fries FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM

SIDES
ADD CHICKEN
Sliced grilled chicken seasoned with salt, pepper and garlic. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
ADD SHRIMP
Sauteed shrimp seasoned with salt, pepper and garlic. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
ADD SALMON
Grilled salmon filet seasoned with salt, pepper and garlic. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
ADD MEATBALLS
Three of our handmade meatballs. Beef and pork combined with our special seasoning blend and slow cooked in our signature tomato sauce. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
ADD ITALIAN SAUSAGE
Two Italian sausage links slow cooked and served with our signature tomato sauce. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM

ADD ONS
ADD ADDITIONAL BREAD (TWO HALF LOAVES)
Our fresh-baked loaf of Tuscan bread split in two. Served with a side of olive oil and garlic. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
UTENSIL SET
This item won't be added unless you ask. Includes fork, knife, spoon and napkin. Please note we limit 1 utensil set per entrée. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM
STRAW
This item won't be added unless you ask. Please note we limit 1 straw per beverage. FREE DELIVERY AND BEST PRICE AT CARINOS.COM

Photos

Photo credit: foursquare
Photo credit: foursquare
Photo credit: foursquare
+36 photos
Photo credit: foursquare
+35 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

First time going and over all it was ok. The food to me was a little over priced but it was good. Not Buca good but good. The bloody mary had a watermelon taste to it and wasn't all that great. The salad was the best part of it all, the pecan salad was really good. We got apps and the mushrooms was also really good. Overall just an ok experience.
July 2023
I enjoy coming to Johnny Carino’s with my family.The food is delicious and while it took a little while, it was worth it. The servers were very friendly!The restaurant was very clean and the environment welcoming.I like their unlimited soup and salad.
June 2023
Amber really outdid herself with the customer service. She is kind, friendly and very attentive to the customers needs. Thank you so much Amber!! You’re amazing and the drink you made us was absolutely FANTASTIC!!
June 2023

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Penn Station East Coast Subs - 1310 N National Rd
Sandwich Shop
Chick-fil-A - 1250 N National Rd
Fast Food, Chicken Shop, Salad, Vegan, Chicken
Chili's Grill & Bar - 1079 N National Rd
Tex-Mex, American, Bar

Johnny Carino's

870 Creekview Dr, Columbus, IN 47201
(812) 372-2266