Thank you so much for the funetti cookie cake and flamingos and cake cookies! They were a big at our mom's surprise party.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Adam Frankhauser
Got a chance to try their snickerdoodle and chocolate chip cookies at an event last night-so good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Julia Federle
Sugar Bayer’s is such a wonderful bakery run by the sweetest mother and daughter team. They have been doing beautiful decorated cookies for all my special occasions for many years- graduations, baby showers, birthdays and even for a house warming. Always beautiful and delicious! I love to stop in for cookies or an ice cream treat. Yes, they have fantastic ice cream that is so decadent! On Wednesdays they have specials. They also offer a flight of 4 kinds of ice cream! Yay!! In addition they have delightful truffles that are great for gifting or just treating yourself! Oh, and they have the cutest doggy treats too! Pam and Jenny are amazing! I love their little business that is such a happy place to visit. I know you'll love it too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sandy Williamson
Not open. Why have a shop and not open at 3:45 on a Friday?
Jasmine Kuntz
They did a great job with my custom order!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Ley
This place is awesome!! Great cookies and Ice cream. I recommend getting a flight so you don’t have to pick just one flavor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Robert Smith
tried for the first time on my days off. the chocolate chip cookies are some of the best I have ever had. my dog loves her dog treats and they are definitely some of the nicest made dog treats I have ever seen.
Megan Chamberlain
BEST ice cream in town - great brand! I hope your hours expand so we can come here regularly for ice cream
Food: 5
Steffany Battin Van Epps
I highly recommend Sugar Bayer’s Cookie Co.!! I ordered cookies for a bridal shower from them and they sure did an amazing job! My expectations were exceeded in all aspects! I will definitely be using them again!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Kyla Ramirez
Everything was so yummy, and the owners are so sweet. Definitely a local gem in Columbus!
The icecream is amazing as is their cupcakes and custom orders cookies!
Brittney Record
So many yummy ice cream flavors! It was hard to decide what we wanted 😅 They also have several different cookies, truffles, solid chocolate bunnies,.. all kinds of goodies! They were super friendly & welcoming 🙂 We will definitely be back again soon!
Debra
I am so thankful for Sugar Bayers! They went above and beyond for a work order during their busiest season of the year! Love the cookies and the owners’ warm, generous spirit!
Brittany Webb
Cute and tasty cookies, they were the cutest little take home additions to my son’s first birthday. 1000% recommend!
Donmichael Thompson
Every thing Sugar Bayer's Cookie Co does is done with excellence. Their cookies are amazing, and the detail of their specialty cookies is unmatched. I've included some samples of cookies they made for trivia themed game nights I've led. Their cookies are also delicious. Each month they have a specialty cookie. When I try them I also have to get a chocolate chip because they're too good to pass up. They have specialty ice cream and also decorated dog treats.
Thank you so much for the funetti cookie cake and flamingos and cake cookies! They were a big at our mom's surprise party.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got a chance to try their snickerdoodle and chocolate chip cookies at an event last night-so good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sugar Bayer’s is such a wonderful bakery run by the sweetest mother and daughter team. They have been doing beautiful decorated cookies for all my special occasions for many years- graduations, baby showers, birthdays and even for a house warming. Always beautiful and delicious! I love to stop in for cookies or an ice cream treat. Yes, they have fantastic ice cream that is so decadent! On Wednesdays they have specials. They also offer a flight of 4 kinds of ice cream! Yay!! In addition they have delightful truffles that are great for gifting or just treating yourself! Oh, and they have the cutest doggy treats too!
Pam and Jenny are amazing! I love their little business that is such a happy place to visit. I know you'll love it too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not open. Why have a shop and not open at 3:45 on a Friday?
They did a great job with my custom order!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is awesome!! Great cookies and Ice cream. I recommend getting a flight so you don’t have to pick just one flavor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
tried for the first time on my days off. the chocolate chip cookies are some of the best I have ever had. my dog loves her dog treats and they are definitely some of the nicest made dog treats I have ever seen.
BEST ice cream in town - great brand! I hope your hours expand so we can come here regularly for ice cream
Food: 5
I highly recommend Sugar Bayer’s Cookie Co.!! I ordered cookies for a bridal shower from them and they sure did an amazing job! My expectations were exceeded in all aspects! I will definitely be using them again!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Everything was so yummy, and the owners are so sweet. Definitely a local gem in Columbus!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
The icecream is amazing as is their cupcakes and custom orders cookies!
So many yummy ice cream flavors! It was hard to decide what we wanted 😅 They also have several different cookies, truffles, solid chocolate bunnies,.. all kinds of goodies! They were super friendly & welcoming 🙂 We will definitely be back again soon!
I am so thankful for Sugar Bayers! They went above and beyond for a work order during their busiest season of the year! Love the cookies and the owners’ warm, generous spirit!
Cute and tasty cookies, they were the cutest little take home additions to my son’s first birthday. 1000% recommend!
Every thing Sugar Bayer's Cookie Co does is done with excellence. Their cookies are amazing, and the detail of their specialty cookies is unmatched. I've included some samples of cookies they made for trivia themed game nights I've led. Their cookies are also delicious. Each month they have a specialty cookie. When I try them I also have to get a chocolate chip because they're too good to pass up. They have specialty ice cream and also decorated dog treats.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...