Sugar Bayer's Cookie Co
1109 16th St, Columbus
(812) 552-5359
Menu
Photos
+20 photos
+19 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Every thing Sugar Bayer's Cookie Co does is done with excellence. Their cookies are amazing, and the detail of their specialty cookies is unmatched. I've included some samples of cookies they made for trivia themed game nights I've led. Their cookies are also delicious. Each month they have a specialty cookie. When I try them I also have to get a chocolate chip because they're too good to pass up. They have specialty ice cream and also decorated dog treats.
Wonderful experience working with them! They took the pictures I sent and made them look exactly the same! Great communication all via text which was super helpful with my schedule.
I've ordered these for two different events now and they have been SO cute and personalized and delicious both times. They're the only place I'll order from for cookies - I also love that they all come individually wrapped. The owners are also so friendly and clearly love what they do.
You May Also Like
Donut Central - 1504 Central Ave
![]()
Donuts, Coffee & Tea
Apna Kitchen - 1609 Cottage Ave
![]()
Indian, Vegan, Vegetarian
Sojourn Coffee Company - 1580 Central Ave
![]()
Coffee Roasteries, Coffee & Tea