Hunt Brothers Pizza

4010 IN-47, Crawfordsville
(765) 361-1800

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Brothers Pizza

the Chinese food was excellent and would get the tacos again

Nicole Greer

I got a slice of Hunt's Brothers Pizza for the first time today at the Jackson Center Sunoco and it completely mystified me. The crust tasted like absolutely nothing. It wasn't yeasty, seasoned, buttery, or.even cardboard flavored. It had absolutely no taste to it at all. I've never found that in anything before. I know I won't be getting Hunt's Brothers pizza again though.

Sarah Renee

ordered our first pizza. got wings and 2 pizzas, $32. felt the wings were small and didn't get many. flavor was good for spicy one. pizza was more like a medium sized but tasted good not greasy. ingredient amount was awesome. Will get again. loved how you express your love for God on box.

marlom731

Sandwiches were awesome. Skip Subway & go here where it's about half the price & near the town square if you're on the way to Turkey Run.

Curious64620029929

Really good spot! Fast and delicious, would recommend to others! Respectful and also great quality ingredients. I would come here again!

Maria Jones

I like that it's cost affordable, and it has the right amount of space and the cheese melts perfectly..

Tom G

Hotel desk suggested Brothers "best pizza in town." We ordered a pizza for delivery. After an hour and 20 minutes I called to ask. No apology: "it's out for delivery, be there soon." It arrived 10 minutes later, cold -- stone cold. Had to warm it in the microwave. For taste, the ham, pepperoni and bacon were good, but very little tomato sauce and not much cheese. Here's a thought: Delivering to a hotel room? Bring napkins, and paper plates to offer. Next time we're in the area, we'll look elsewhere.

flnine300

We arrived at our hotel and did not care to go out searching for dinner. Tried this place and appreciated the quality of the product for the price. Quick delivery and very convenient. A large pizza is plenty for three people to share.

HOTROD37

We took a chance on a chain we didn't know. Ordered online. Very easy. Delivery was faster than promised by 15 minutes. The deliveryman had us open the box to make sure the pizza was OK because he had to make an abrupt stop. The pizza was a little squished together. He offered to make us a fresh one but we declined. We straightened the pizza out and it was fine. High grades for the driver being very honest with us. Pizza was pretty tasty. As good if not better than other chains I know. Glad we gave them a try.

Joe H

Large group ordered take out to Backstep brewery across the street. Sampled several pizza's and everyone enjoyed. The staff at Brothers was very friendly and hustled the pizza over to us.

7duncanf

12" Supreme was Excellent. Ordered online - they advised a delivery time and beat it by 10 minutes. Very good pizza.

LilRDWgn

We have been enjoying pizza and breadsticks from Brother’s since late summer of 2018. We got a recommendation around that time. Their sauce and crust is the best anywhere. So we recently heard they also have a killer Chicago Style pie. But we didn’t see it on the menu. So I called in and walla, the sure enough do offer a Chicago Style pie. It is more expensive than their regular menu pie. But wow! What a wonderful pizza it is. We highly recommend Chicago Style pie from Brother Pizza.

Suzi F

We checked into a hotel in Crawfordsville. We wanted pizza, but no chains. We found this one. They delivered within 30 minutes. The pizza was pretty good--a little bready for us, but still hit the spot.

Scott A

Got into Crawfordsville at about 9:30 and checked into the hotel. Looked for delivery and gave Brothers a call. While they couldn't deliver that late, they said they could do take out for me, even though they were getting close to closing time. Pizza was quick and was ready by the time I got there. Food was great and service was great. Definitely recommend.

RICART75

Though we have had their pizza delivered to our hotel before, this is the first time we've eaten in the restaurant. The facility is older, basic, and fairly well maintained. While we were waiting for our order, several law enforcement officers came in for a meal; which we usually consider a good recommendation for an eatery. Our server was friendly and intermittently attentive. Our shared salad was fresh and amply portioned. Our large sausage pizza (extra sausage, extra cheese), was quite flavorful (we enjoy the chewy crust); and left us plenty for another meal at home. We ended with the wonderfully indulgent cinnamon breadsticks (also enough to bring some home). Whereas most places just put cinnamon on top of their breadsticks; here they also roll cinnamon into the breadsticks themselves. AND, then they also provide a side of cinnamon dipping sauce to complete the splurging. All and all, if one wants a great pizza (and breadsticks), at a reasonable price; this place is a solid option.

Loading...