El Potro

200 E Main Cross St, Edinburgh
(812) 703-5037

Customers' Favorites

Photos

+22 photos
+21 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

My burrito was such a conversation piece when I brought it back to my group. I ordered the largest burrito they had, if you can eat it in a half hour it was free. But I knew that wasn't happening. I brought it back and shared it umongst 5 friends. The meat was tender, the beans flavorful, and the sauce was great. For a burrito the size of a small child, it was worth it.
Their menu is incredibly huge. It's quite daunting trying to figure out what to order. Especially since this was our first visit. The food was fine...nothing extraordinary in the realm of Mexican food. The steak was a bit tough and the salsa bland. The interior is incredibly over the top with the colorful decor. It isn't somewhere I need to go back to. The best part by far was the service...fast, friendly, and the prices are right.
This seems to be characteristic of Indy - some of the most memorable places I’ve eaten are tucked away in the middle of nowhere. This place had some of the most well flavored home made salsa. Their chips are served warm. The food is brought out (at least the fajitas) on a skillet cooking. The food just hit the spot for me. Very much recommend them especially after a day of intense physical work.

More Reviews