18 Best Bakeries in Evansville

Crumbl - Evansville Bakery • $
939 N Burkhardt Rd Suite B, Evansville

Customers` Favorites

Semi Sweet Chocolate Chunk
All the Flavors of Cookies
Chocolate Cupcake Cookie
4 Pack Variety Cookies
Chocolate Dream Cookie
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Peanut Butter Cookie
Milk Chocolate Chip
Cookie Dough Cookie
Cinnamon Fry Dough

“The eastside location is so good when it comes to making your cookies look like they should in the advertisements and the workers always make sure to show you the cookies/cakes so you don't walk away unsatisfied, the workers are also super friendly at this location and I can genuinely tell that they love making making customers smile when they hang them the pink box! 10/10!“

4.7 Superb297 Reviews
GaylaCake Bakery • $
320 North Main Street, Evansville

Customers` Favorites

1 Dozen Homestyle Cookies
6-Pack Specialty Cupcakes
6-Pack Gourmet Cupcakes
1 Dozen Regular Cupcakes
German Chocolate Cake
Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake
Dessert Cake
Gayla Cakes
Cake Pop

“our daughter, Leann Weyer, got her dad a german chocolate cake for fathers day and it was the best german choolate cake we have ever had.... it was just fantastic...thank you so much“

4.9 Superb54 Reviews
Be Happy Pie Company, LLC Bakery • $$
2818 Mt Vernon Ave B, Evansville

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Pot Pie
Chocolate Chess
Blueberry Pie
Key Lime Pie
Cherry Crumb
Coffee Cake
Cherry Pie
Pie Bites
Apple Pie
Taco Pie

“Amazing Local Business. Highly Recommend 🍒“

4.9 Superb43 Reviews
panaderia San Miguel Bakery • $
2004 Washington Ave, Evansville

Customers` Favorites

Mexican Cheesecake
Tres Letche Cake
Pan Dulce
Conchas

“They have the most delicious baked treats! The gingerbread pig is my new favorite! 😍“

4.8 Superb44 Reviews
Piece of Cake Bakery • $
210 Main St, Evansville

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Birthday Cake with Chocolate Buttercream Frosting
Downtown Brownies Cake Pops Cookie Monsters
Baby Shower Cakes
Six Pack Cupcakes
6 Pack Cupcakes
Strawberry Cake
Wedding Cake
Doggie Bag
Cup Cakes
Pupcake

“Sent them Pinterest photos of what I was wanting! They got it on the nose! Check the comments for the photos but I wanted succulent themed cupcakes and they did amazing! They were a hit for my baby shower! Super sweet people working there as well everyone was so nice and so accommodating!“

4.7 Superb51 Reviews
Nothing Bundt Cakes Bakery • $$
6436 E Florida St Suite 100, Evansville

Customers` Favorites

Red Velvet Cake
Bundt Cake

“Carrot Cake has been my favorite then the new flavor of the month for May is now Lemon Blueberry. It is delicious. Wish they would keep it year round! If you haven’t tried it … do yourself the favor !! You’ll be happy you did.

Parking: Able to pull up to the front of the business. Plenty of parking“

4.5 Superb23 Reviews
Just Rennie's Cafe & Cookie Company Bakery • $
102 SE 4th St, Evansville

Customers` Favorites

Tropical Chicken Salad
Grilled Vegetables
Ham & Swiss
Grape Salad

“We love Just Rennie’s ! Doug was so accommodating to help us with our mom’s cerebration of life event. Doug worked with us on the menu! Everything was absolutely perfect! The food was absolutely incredible! We highly recommend Just Rennies for any event ! The chocolate Grenache cake was beyond amazing, delicious and was the star of the party.“

4.8 Superb11 Reviews
Parlor Doughnuts Donut Shops • $
301 N Green River Rd, Evansville

Customers` Favorites

Seasonal Banana Cream Pie Layered Doughnut
Honey Glazed Chocolate Crunch
Turtle Cheesecake Doughnut
Keto Friendly Doughnut
Strawberry Shortcake
Doughnuts and Coffee
Raspberry Pistachio
Coconut Cream Donut
Maple Bacon Donut
Rainbow Sprinkles

“First time trying Parlor doughnuts. I bought a dozen and my first one was mallo cup. A very good doughnut and I'm excited to try the rest of the flavors as soon as I can find room to eat another one. I'll definitely be buying more of the doughnuts.“

4.3 Superb96 Reviews
Cookies & Cupcake by Design Bakery • $$
419 Metro Ave, Evansville

“Cookies by design donated 60 cookies to deaconess gateway observation unit. Cookies were so good. Staff at the store was kind and friendly! Love this local cookie place! The nurses and techs were very appreciative. Thanks cookies by design!“

4.5 Superb14 Reviews
Lewis Bakery Bakery • $
500 N Fulton Ave, Evansville

“I placed an order for keto breads and buns after trying some and finding them to be delicious and also pretty compatible with my diet. They did not disappoint. The Hawaiian style keto hot dog buns were the best buns I have had period and that includes high carb brioche buns. I love this company and their product. They definitely have giving me a quality of life upgrade with their awesome products that I can eat and still loose weight and feel healthy.“

4 Good21 Reviews
Granola Jar Caterers • $$
1033 Mt Pleasant Road # J, Evansville

“Huge thanks to the GJ team for the delicious and beautifully catered meal to wrap up my mother in laws celebration of life. Everyone enjoyed the assortment of sandwiches and salads and of course the cookies were a favorite of all!“

4.9 Superb19 Reviews
Great Harvest Bread Co. Bakery • $
423 Metro Ave, Evansville

Customers` Favorites

Cookies

“Scones!❤️. I never liked scones because they were dry. But the lady in here promised me these were not like the ones I have tried before. Omg!❤️. Im so glad I got one. It was like a muffin and biscuit got together and had a baby. Sweet but not to sweet. Firm on the outside like a biscuit but soft yet dense inside. I got the blackberry which had little pieces of creamcheese bits thruout. The bread is also devine! Definitely stop by this bakery to grab yourself some good eats or even get a sandwich.“

3.7 Good26 Reviews
The Granola Jar East Cafe • $
5600 E Virginia St, Evansville

Customers` Favorites

Three's Company Lunch Special
Grilled Pimento Cheese
Jive Turkey Sandwich

“Huge thanks to the GJ team for the delicious and beautifully catered meal to wrap up my mother in laws celebration of life. Everyone enjoyed the assortment of sandwiches and salads and of course the cookies were a favorite of all!“

4.9 Superb13 Reviews
Donut Bank Donut Shops • $
1200 Lincoln Ave, Evansville

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Cake Donut Ball
Plain Vanilla Cake Donut
Tiger Tail
Bagel

“I love Donut Bank and am a loyal customer. However, today I wasted precious calories! I've been anxious to try the almond bear claw. I LOVE almond! I was terribly disappointed! It was very sweet and I tasted NO almond flavor whatsoever! Today was the 1st time I've ever been disappointed.“

4.3 Superb22 Reviews
Insomnia Cookies Dessert • $
318 Main St #100, Evansville

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chip Cookie
Peanut Butter Chip
Classic with M&M's
Chocolate Chunk
Snickerdoodle
Confetti

“UH-MAY-ZING!!! When you first walk in you smell cookies, not sugar, cookies. We normally go to Tiffs Treats solely for their snicker doodle, bc everything else tastes the same. THAT IS NOT THE CASE AT INSOMNIA ?‍? every cookie has its own unique flavor profile and believe the hype about the ice cream, it’s hella good. We got a 4 pack, 2 snicker doodle, 1 macadamia nut and 1 s’more the girl at the front gave us 2 additional carrot cake cookies and my GAWDDDDD!!! Forget Crumbl forget Tiffs get Insomnia ?“

3.9 Good61 Reviews
Donut Bank Donut Shops • $
1950 Washington Ave, Evansville

“I love Donut Bank and am a loyal customer. However, today I wasted precious calories! I've been anxious to try the almond bear claw. I LOVE almond! I was terribly disappointed! It was very sweet and I tasted NO almond flavor whatsoever! Today was the 1st time I've ever been disappointed.“

4.1 Good23 Reviews
North Main Annex Gourmet Catering & Deli Deli • $
701 N Main St, Evansville

Customers` Favorites

Vegetable Salad

“I just went by North Main Annex Gourmet Catering and Deli for lunch and I got a ham, bacon and Swiss sandwich. For just a simple sandwich it was fantastic! Priced very well! They have a ton to choose from. Soups, salads & sandwiches of all kinds and a great assortment of desserts! It's in an unassuming location on main so it's easy to miss but well worth looking out for! Definitely will be back!“

4.9 Superb7 Reviews
Great American Cookies Bakery • $
800 N Green River Rd, Evansville

Customers` Favorites

Blueberry Muffin Cookie
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Double Doozies
Brownies

“Ordered a Frankenstein cookie cake for a family gathering! It was decorated fantastically, tasted great! The lady who took my order seemed as excited as I was, and kept me updated. Unfortunately I ate half the 16" cookie myself, SO GOOD...“

3.2 Average40 Reviews