15 Best Bakeries in Evansville

“The eastside location is so good when it comes to making your cookies look like they should in the advertisements and the workers always make sure to show you the cookies/cakes so you don't walk away unsatisfied, the workers are also super friendly at this location and I can genuinely tell that they love making making customers smile when they hang them the pink box! 10/10!“

“This was my first time ordering a custom cake for my birthday and I am so impressed! The price was reasonable and they interpreted the inspiration pictures and my requests perfectly to create a beautiful cake. Exactly what I wanted and tasted amazing too! Can’t wait to order again!“

“They have the most delicious baked treats! The gingerbread pig is my new favorite! 😍“

“I stopped by Be Happy to get some treats and was offered a raisin oatmeal cookie for my birthday. Guess where I'm going tomorrow to get a dozen of the best raisin oatmeal cookies around!!!“

“Doug recently catered our event at a home in Newburgh! He and his crew did a fantastic job! Nothing was left undone. As far as the food, it was superb! Could not have gone to a restaurant and had anything close to what chef Doug Rennie made us. I highly recommend for your catering needs! Restaurant is great as well!“

“Just want to say we love Zoe! She’s sweet, very friendly, and sincere.“

“Really cool environment! Love everything this place has to offer!“

“I placed an order for keto breads and buns after trying some and finding them to be delicious and also pretty compatible with my diet. They did not disappoint. The Hawaiian style keto hot dog buns were the best buns I have had period and that includes high carb brioche buns. I love this company and their product. They definitely have giving me a quality of life upgrade with their awesome products that I can eat and still loose weight and feel healthy.“

“Cookies by design donated 60 cookies to deaconess gateway observation unit. Cookies were so good. Staff at the store was kind and friendly! Love this local cookie place! The nurses and techs were very appreciative. Thanks cookies by design!“

“Huge thanks to the GJ team for the delicious and beautifully catered meal to wrap up my mother in laws celebration of life. Everyone enjoyed the assortment of sandwiches and salads and of course the cookies were a favorite of all!“

“Huge thanks to the GJ team for the delicious and beautifully catered meal to wrap up my mother in laws celebration of life. Everyone enjoyed the assortment of sandwiches and salads and of course the cookies were a favorite of all!“

“I just went by North Main Annex Gourmet Catering and Deli for lunch and I got a ham, bacon and Swiss sandwich. For just a simple sandwich it was fantastic! Priced very well! They have a ton to choose from. Soups, salads & sandwiches of all kinds and a great assortment of desserts! It's in an unassuming location on main so it's easy to miss but well worth looking out for! Definitely will be back!“

“Insomnia Cookies is a must-visit! The warm cookies are absolutely delicious, and they offer an impressive variety of flavors to choose from. The service was great and incredibly friendly, making the experience even better. I highly recommend this place to anyone looking for a sweet treat!“

“Wow 😋 We were in from out of town and it was 9:30pm and suddenly I needed ice cream🍦🍦Saw that Lic's was less than two miles up the road, AND OPEN UNTIL 10:30!! We swing by and get a regular vanilla cone and the choco cream treats... So quick and they did not disappoint!! So good, I wish we lived closer so we could have these tasty treats all the time, 10/10, highly recommend!! Definitely get some good eats here“

“I love Donut Bank and am a loyal customer. However, today I wasted precious calories! I've been anxious to try the almond bear claw. I LOVE almond! I was terribly disappointed! It was very sweet and I tasted NO almond flavor whatsoever! Today was the 1st time I've ever been disappointed.“