Be Happy Pie Company

I stopped by Be Happy to get some treats and was offered a raisin oatmeal cookie for my birthday. Guess where I'm going tomorrow to get a dozen of the best raisin oatmeal cookies around!!!

Be Happy has the most delicious, fresh savory and sweet pies. Additionally, their staff is so kind and patient when trying to choose from all the amazing flavors. Lastly, Judy, the owner is amazing. She is so smart, so determined and wants all her customers to leave happy!

The strawberry pies are exceptional!

Selection is excellent and the quality stellar across the board!!

I love the great options for main meals and wonderful desserts!! I can stop in pick up for dinner or great options for bringing items to an event. Keep doing what your doing, we love it!!!

I'm a long ways from home and Be Happy Pie Company makes me feel like I'm home again. Great desserts and people

My husband & I are traveling from TX, we went here for the first time and we actually met Rick. He was so kind and very welcoming! We ordered a shepherd’s pie Wednesday and it was ready on Friday. It was sooo freaking good! Each component was good on their own: the crust, the filling, and omg the mashed potatoes on top. They made it so easy to bake at home, you just throw it in the oven and it’ll be ready in about 40 mins or so. It was so good I forgot to take a picture before we ate it, LOL 💛 so cheap for how good it was!!! We’re definitely coming back to try their other savory pies!

I got a slice of the sausage and cheddar quiche as well as one of the small butterscotch pies. To say I am impressed is an understatement. I was so excited after I arrived home (I live in Indianapolis) that I didn't even hear the quiche up. It was amazing. It is the mark of a quality quiche that it tastes good cold. As I type this, I am only half way thru the butterscotch pie and rather sad I got a little one. I can not wait to come back to Evansville if only to get more pie. Tho next time, I will be taking more home! I'll be recommending Be Happy to everyone I know!

We had our pie shipped to us, it came packaged well and arrived as expected. We orders the apple streusel pie. It was amazing. The crust was great, the apples were fresh and the streusel was tasty. It was like fresh apple crisp in a great crust.

The oatmeal creme pie was fantastic.

The staff was extremely nice! The chicken pot pie is available on Wednesday and I highly recommend it. It was to die for. The cookies are also delicious.

I ordered a pie as a birthday gift for a family member. She told me it was the best pie she ever had in her life. I ordered it over the phone and spoke with Jenny. She was so nice. I highly recommend this company. I even received a text letting me know the pie was ready to be picked up. They seem very organized. I can't say enough good things about this company. Five stars all the way!!

Amazing Local Business. Highly Recommend 🍒

Be Happy Pie in Evansville is an absolute gem! Every bite is a reminder of why supporting local is so important.

The flavors are out of this world, and you can taste the love and effort that goes into each pie. The atmosphere is welcoming, and the staff is friendly, making the whole experience even better. If you’re looking for a sweet treat that’s made with care, this is the spot! Can’t wait to come back.

Also the smile and service I got from Josh was truly one of the best parts of the interaction!

#EvansvilleEats #LocalLove #PiePerfection 🥧❤️

Parking: Lots of space!

Kid-friendliness: Awesome atmosphere for anyone!

Wheelchair accessibility: Lovely space with plenty of room

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pie Bites, Cherry Pie

Fresh muffins, scones and quiche all made in house was our breakfast. As always, great products. Be sure to support local artisians making their own products in house.

Be Happy Pie in Evansville is an absolute gem! Every bite is a reminder of why supporting local is so important. The flavors are out of this world, and you can taste the love and effort that goes into each pie. The atmosphere is welcoming, and the staff is friendly, making the whole experience even better. If you’re looking for a sweet treat that’s made with care, this is the spot! Can’t wait to come back. Also the smile and service I got from Josh was truly one of the best parts of the interaction! #EvansvilleEats #LocalLove #PiePerfection 🥧❤️