Custom Cakes in Evansville, IN

“Tried Cookie Plug today & wow. the cookies are wonderful & Marcie (I think that was her name) was so friendly & helpful. Forget the other cookie places because this is the BEST“

“I recently stopped by Cold Stone Creamery and tried something called the Mud Pie Mojo, and I’ve got to say—it was seriously good. The ice cream had big, chunky pieces of cookies and nuts mixed all throughout it, and whatever else they add in there just works perfectly together. Every bite had a nice crunch and tons of flavor. 🍪🥜🍨
One of the coolest parts is watching them actually make your order on the frozen stone. They scoop the ice cream out, then start chopping, crunching, and folding all the mix-ins right into it. It’s kind of fun to watch and makes the whole experience feel fresh and custom.
The atmosphere inside is great too. You can see all the toppings and all the different ice cream flavors lined up. Honestly, it almost overloads your brain trying to decide what to get because there are so many options. In the end I just went with the Mud Pie from one of their menu suggestion boards (the little sticker menu), and I’m glad I did.
Overall, I’m really impressed. If you’ve got a sweet tooth like I do, this place is a must-try. I’d honestly take Cold Stone Creamery over Dairy Queen any day. 🍦🔥“