Great Harvest Bread Co.

423 Metro Ave, Evansville
(812) 476-4999

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Cha Cha

The loaf bread that I bought yesterday December 17th, 2024 was too salty. Very salty! No one can even eat it.

Food: 1

Corey Hayes

They close early and don't make cooked sandwiches anymore. Don't go here. The one in Owensboro is far more courteous and serviceable.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Shannon Reznik

Worst cinnamon rolls ever! Dry and hard as a rock, even in the middle. Two employees just stood around while another made previous customer’s order. Finally when that order was done, my Husband had to speak to them first. No “hi, be with you in a minute”, or “how can we help you”. So disappointed. We were every Saturday regulars at our shop in Peoria. This location isn’t worth it.

BTW - pumpkin chocolate chip bread was an every day, year round bread there, and they sold a ton of it, every day, for 12 years. People didn’t tire of it because it was so good! It’s seasonal at your location? Might want to rethink that. Unless yours is as bad as your cinnamon rolls.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Georgia Wright

This place has changed more limited menu for catering. Disappointed some of the goodies are gone. Overall the food was good and crowd pleaser, would have been nice to have utensils included and napkins.

Food: 4

Service: 4

TruckerKatHikes

Scones!❤️. I never liked scones because they were dry. But the lady in here promised me these were not like the ones I have tried before. Omg!❤️. Im so glad I got one. It was like a muffin and biscuit got together and had a baby. Sweet but not to sweet. Firm on the outside like a biscuit but soft yet dense inside. I got the blackberry which had little pieces of creamcheese bits thruout. The bread is also devine! Definitely stop by this bakery to grab yourself some good eats or even get a sandwich.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Meg V

This place is a mixed bag. I like their cookies and baked goods and different varieties of bread. I tried a sandwich here recently and custom ordered it. It was prepared wrong, took a long time to make, and was extremely soggy. Another time I ordered a salad and was given the wrong salad. They give free samples of some their items. However, I noticed they will ask some customers upon them entering if they want a sample, but I always have to plead for a sample lol. I have ordered a coffee here before too and it's always lukewarm so I would recommend passing on the coffee here. No one here has ever wowed me by their customer service and it's always been slow. The only reason to go here on occasion is if I want a cookie or bakery item or certain loaf of bread as I said before because they are good.

Parking: Free parking lot

Kid-friendliness: Yeah kids can eat here

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Cookies

M S (Sue)

This place is a mixed bag. I like their cookies and baked goods and different varieties of bread. I tried a sandwich here recently and custom ordered it. It was prepared wrong, took a long time to make, and was extremely soggy. Another time I ordered a salad and was given the wrong salad. They give free samples of some their items. However, I noticed they will ask some customers upon them entering if they want a sample, but I always have to plead for a sample lol. I have ordered a coffee here before too and it's always lukewarm so I would recommend passing on the coffee here. No one here has ever wowed me by their customer service and it's always been slow. The only reason to go here on occasion is if I want a cookie or bakery item or certain loaf of bread as I said before because they are good.

Parking: Free parking lot

Kid-friendliness: Yeah kids can eat here

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

JJ

First time here today, their sandwich was really good and reasonably priced. Love supporting local!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

JJTheJetPlane

First time here today, their sandwich was really good and reasonably priced. Love supporting local!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jenna Brown

My husband and I have eaten here many times and have always had a 10/10 experience! We love their sandwiches, pepperoni bread, pumpkin bread, cinnamon rolls, and no bake cookies!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Belinda King

Loved the rolls for our Thanksgiving feast! The cookie was a treat!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookies

Caitlyn Schaber

They closed early I had a pick up order

Chris Garrett

Great breakfast and wonderful staff

Brittney Bell

Good service

Jan Heriges

Friendly staff, fresh products.

Loading...