Insomnia Cookies

318 Main St #100, Evansville
(930) 500-4814

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jessica Baker

The store is on the one-way street walkway. It look a couple of trips around the block to figure out the location because my navigation app was confusing me. Parking is difficult to find, and they don't have specific spots for pickups, so you might have to walk a bit. They sell ice cream and cookies.

Kit Geary

Two stars because the foods great but Destiny had very poor costumer service. I understand have a rough or busy night but I did not feel like a respected customer

Tabitha Hamilton

Went in at 9 pm and heard the girl behind the counter say “what on earth did I do to deserve to be in hell today” and acting as if I was a burden to be a customer and then another person walked in and the same girl said “why do people keep coming in”. You guys don’t close until 1 am and she is acting like this at 9 pm. Wonder how she treats the people who come in later than 9. Terrible customer service and will not be returning if this establishment is ran this way

Kairi Meyer

Staff are always amazing, Cookies are always fresh and the ice cream is delicious!! Definitely the perfect late night sweet treat spot

A Hatfield

Super good ice cream

Kim Giesler

Fast service, warm out of the oven cookies with great flavor!

Marty Howard

Cookies were tasty and service was friendly.

l e i r i n

I’m obsessed and addicted. Freshly baked cookies and exceptional delivery service. Definitely recommend insomnia cookies for midnight sugar cravings.

Dalton Davis

I understand there’s people that like this place, and I have no issues with it whatsoever, clearly, but if there’s multiple bad reviews talking about the same thing.. I’d pay attention and read them.
Sadly I gotta agree with them too.. the cookies truly aren’t that good .. not a welcoming place either.. just an overall bad place to go for cookies.
Go to Crumbl or My Cookie Plug if yall want really tasty cookies. Truly.

Alice Back

Delicious

Michael Rose

Seems to always be out of the limited time cookies, which is why I go. Cookies and service are good though.

AJ L

Ordered delivery & received in less than 20 mins. The cookies are all equally great & far better than Crumbl!

Eduard C Hanganu

Great little shop similar to Crumble, though the cookies are better here. Another advantage is that if you have insomnia the shop will deliver the cookies to your door at 3 am in the early morning. Bon appetit!

Kennedy Salts

There isn’t a day that goes by where I don’t think about these cookies.

Chris Berry

Went in and they said it was a 10 wait on chocolate chunk after I told them I wanted 6 of them in my dozen. Customers walked up 5 - 10 mins after and they said they just came up. I go back up and they said I'm sorry the people just got the last, it would be a wait. I just waited, I told her how many and she knew it. Yet she gave the ones I wanted and waited for away. Didn't wait again. Terrible service!!! Won't be back.

Loading...