Insomnia Cookies

318 Main St #100, Evansville
(930) 500-4814

Recent Reviews

Toby Phillips

Employee was stressed. Seemed like too busy for 1 person. The first few items we asked for were not available, too busy to bake. It was 5 pm. Cookies were overpriced for the size

Kura williams

Shout out to the girl who remade my order , because doordash stole mine . And Rafael for delivering it . Y’all are a

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip

Gamewiz Deluxe

3.50 for a water, $6-10 for cookie. Not worth your time, and especially not worth your

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jeanie A.

To be honest they're not that great, baking store bought cookies seem fresher. ‍ I was really excited to finally be near this business to try and it just was not what I had thought.

Mikey S.

Tucked into a small lil shop on Main Street. Seating options are both indoors and out. Cookie was fresh but kinda small for the price. My wife and I got 2 ice cream sandwiches and one 12oz milk and the bill was over $20 so I don't we will frequent.

Eli’s World

Nice and clean environment, convenient in downtown. We got there right before closing and they were very accommodating. We only wish we had one here in Nashville,TN! I am officially obsessed with the ice cream here. It is loaded like ice cream is supposed to be ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Snickerdoodle

Prod. By Elan

UH-MAY-ZING!!! When you first walk in you smell cookies, not sugar, cookies. We normally go to Tiffs Treats solely for their snicker doodle, bc everything else tastes the same. THAT IS NOT THE CASE AT INSOMNIA ?‍? every cookie has its own unique flavor profile and believe the hype about the ice cream, it’s hella good. We got a 4 pack, 2 snicker doodle, 1 macadamia nut and 1 s’more the girl at the front gave us 2 additional carrot cake cookies and my GAWDDDDD!!! Forget Crumbl forget Tiffs get Insomnia ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

DJNJD 6

They take cash. The girl was very nice and helpful. Delicious cookie and ice cream. My first of many visits.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip Cookie

Pam Carson

Best cookies ever made. Try the salted carmel. It is to die for!

Angela Nichols

Sooooo freaking good! Can't believe how late they are open and they deliver!! You gotta try this place. Take a friend. You'll thank me.

amber sheets

you guys always close 20 minutes early. either stay open or change your hours.

Sarah Hartman

Modest menu of cookies and ice cream, to be combined if desired. The cookies tasted delicious and was warm when ordered. Loved that the drink stand included milk, it paired so well with the cookies. Staff were friendly and the price was reasonable. Shop was clean.

Alexandria Riddle

Second time placing an order through the app and within 10 minutes the status says delivered. So, we’re once again waiting, clueless and randomly checking to see if our order has been delivered or not.

Adrienne Jones

Delicious cookies. Cookie Magic is a great deal if you're downtown often.

Raegan T.

The cookies are phenomenal definitely eat them when you first get them while there still warm. We went around 10 pm on a Saturday night and they were out of several flavors of cookies unfortunately. It was our first time trying an insomnia and the lady working the counter was not the most helpful and kinda rude about how long we were taking to decide even though there were no other customers in the store. Overall the cookies were good would more than likely go back just earlier in the day.

Load More