Pizza on the pizza bar was good but some of it was cold.
Jamie Higgins
One member of our party got thick crust and it obviously was not thick crust and they argued that is was. Never got a refill on my water. Food that I got was pretty good. It was mostly just an issue with our waitress.
Bret McCutchan
Well I had not been there in 2 years. Everything started well. Then the food came out.I ordered wings and individual pizza. Ranch was spilled on plate before it was delivered and the pizza came to me Chicago style deep dish but I ordered thin crust. Was never offered a second mix drink. Food was ok but service was lacking.
Jeremy G.
Ok was in town and just wanted a good pie and surprisingly that's what I got tonight. I can only comment on the Thai pizza, but if this is any sign of the other food I'm all in. Chicken was great and the veggies were fresh and delicious. I do wish it had a lot more spice but I'm sure I could adjust my order sexy time to achieve that. So I do recommend trying this place and enjoy it.
Neya Rooney
Expect to wait an hour for your food. Then, when they do bring food they only bring one persons plate so they either sit there and let their food get cold while they wait on everyone else's food to arrive; or they eat in front of the rest who are HANGRY from waiting so long. They did comp 11 bucks off my bill but I really would have traded that for a pleasant experience.
Donna Clauson
My daughter and I went there for lunch. We had a Thai pizza and a craft beer. Both are awesome. Our server was Becky. She took great care of us. We'll definitely go there again.
Sam Jenny
Old Chicago was awesome. We had some Italian nachos and a Thai pizza. It was great! I highly RECOMMEND!
Kira Messer
We loved it. We just moved to town last week and decided to give it a try for lunch and we were definitely NOT disappointed. We walked in and had zero wait time, the hostess was friendly and sat us right away, our server greatest us almost instantly, We relied on him when asking what to try. First of all he was great, happy friendly and knowledgeable, I wish I could remember his name cause I'd totally recommend asking for him. He recommended that we try the Italian nachos and the pepperoni rolls we got the trio sampler so we could try both we also got some cheesy garlic bread for the kiddo on it also very tasty and we followed it up with some very delicious pizzas and ceasar salads I got a personal thin pepperoni my husband got a personal deep dish pepperoni/sausage and my little girl got a regular crust kids cheese and they were all fantastic. We will definitely be going back.
Justin DuPont
Old Chicago in Evansville is one of those places that is always consistent. The staff is always professional, the food is always good, and the beer is always plenty. If you are looking for something a little different, give their Thai Pie a try; the cooked broccoli might seem like an odd choice for a pizza topping, but everything blends perfectly in the end.
Joshua K.
First time there today will definitely be back often. All kinds of things to try on the menu...Plus a killer beer menu.
Great deep dish pizza restaurant. They also have great calzones and strombolis. Excellent beer selection, 30 -50 beers to choose from. Service is usually dependable, depending on the time you visit, the wait time can be longer than you'd expect based on how crowded the restaurant is. My guess is that they try to run a lean staff, which can lead to poor service. The last few times we've been, service has been fine.
Allison Allen
No wait at 5:30 on a Friday night was a pleasant surprise! Waitress was fast to take order, bring food, fill drinks, and bring check. Ordered 3 appetizers as our meal and they were fresh and delicious. Pizza rolls were great as always and bacon Mac n cheese bites were to die for!
jamieblaggbowlin
2nd time in a row with absolutely HORRIBLE experience. Took 3 times to get a simple app that was edible and our entree came out extremely cold in the middle. The manager wouldn't even look us in the face or come to our table when asked.
Eric Helfert
Had the buffet was really good. The server did a very good job taking care of us.
Michael R.
Wife's food came out after I had finished eating then it was completely wrong so they had to remake it. Atmosphere was not at all pleasant: unlike our previous visits that were great. Then the check came and we were charged $2 more than the advertised price on a blue moon and it was also two once's less than advertised in the restaurant. We won't be returning anytime soon.
Pizza on the pizza bar was good but some of it was cold.
One member of our party got thick crust and it obviously was not thick crust and they argued that is was. Never got a refill on my water. Food that I got was pretty good. It was mostly just an issue with our waitress.
Well I had not been there in 2 years. Everything started well. Then the food came out.I ordered wings and individual pizza. Ranch was spilled on plate before it was delivered and the pizza came to me Chicago style deep dish but I ordered thin crust. Was never offered a second mix drink. Food was ok but service was lacking.
Ok was in town and just wanted a good pie and surprisingly that's what I got tonight. I can only comment on the Thai pizza, but if this is any sign of the other food I'm all in. Chicken was great and the veggies were fresh and delicious. I do wish it had a lot more spice but I'm sure I could adjust my order sexy time to achieve that. So I do recommend trying this place and enjoy it.
Expect to wait an hour for your food. Then, when they do bring food they only bring one persons plate so they either sit there and let their food get cold while they wait on everyone else's food to arrive; or they eat in front of the rest who are HANGRY from waiting so long. They did comp 11 bucks off my bill but I really would have traded that for a pleasant experience.
My daughter and I went there for lunch. We had a Thai pizza and a craft beer. Both are awesome. Our server was Becky. She took great care of us. We'll definitely go there again.
Old Chicago was awesome. We had some Italian nachos and a Thai pizza. It was great! I highly RECOMMEND!
We loved it. We just moved to town last week and decided to give it a try for lunch and we were definitely NOT disappointed. We walked in and had zero wait time, the hostess was friendly and sat us right away, our server greatest us almost instantly, We relied on him when asking what to try. First of all he was great, happy friendly and knowledgeable, I wish I could remember his name cause I'd totally recommend asking for him. He recommended that we try the Italian nachos and the pepperoni rolls we got the trio sampler so we could try both we also got some cheesy garlic bread for the kiddo on it also very tasty and we followed it up with some very delicious pizzas and ceasar salads I got a personal thin pepperoni my husband got a personal deep dish pepperoni/sausage and my little girl got a regular crust kids cheese and they were all fantastic. We will definitely be going back.
Old Chicago in Evansville is one of those places that is always consistent. The staff is always professional, the food is always good, and the beer is always plenty. If you are looking for something a little different, give their Thai Pie a try; the cooked broccoli might seem like an odd choice for a pizza topping, but everything blends perfectly in the end.
First time there today will definitely be back often. All kinds of things to try on the menu...Plus a killer beer menu.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great deep dish pizza restaurant. They also have great calzones and strombolis. Excellent beer selection, 30 -50 beers to choose from. Service is usually dependable, depending on the time you visit, the wait time can be longer than you'd expect based on how crowded the restaurant is. My guess is that they try to run a lean staff, which can lead to poor service. The last few times we've been, service has been fine.
No wait at 5:30 on a Friday night was a pleasant surprise! Waitress was fast to take order, bring food, fill drinks, and bring check. Ordered 3 appetizers as our meal and they were fresh and delicious. Pizza rolls were great as always and bacon Mac n cheese bites were to die for!
2nd time in a row with absolutely HORRIBLE experience. Took 3 times to get a simple app that was edible and our entree came out extremely cold in the middle. The manager wouldn't even look us in the face or come to our table when asked.
Had the buffet was really good. The server did a very good job taking care of us.
Wife's food came out after I had finished eating then it was completely wrong so they had to remake it. Atmosphere was not at all pleasant: unlike our previous visits that were great. Then the check came and we were charged $2 more than the advertised price on a blue moon and it was also two once's less than advertised in the restaurant. We won't be returning anytime soon.