Old Mill Restaurant

5031 New Harmony Rd, Evansville
(812) 963-6000

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Dean Newell

Wonderful place, limited menu. Went this past weekend and had amazing service.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Christopher Shell

The food was alright but there was very very little to choose from. When we finished we were shorted about $7-$8 and didn't realize it till we got home and I didn't bother calling or going back to collect. The place itself on the inside was awesome though

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 1

Bill, Carolyn & Carrie Stader

Although the cook didn't show up last night, the workers there strived to do their best. Our food was delicious & the waiter was phenomenal~so sweet & apologized for the delay. To those complaining in other reviews about the old look of the place, it's what gives it charm....hence it being the Old Mill that's been serving travelers & diners for decades. If you want modern look & feel, go to a modern place. Thanks again to the sweet waiter!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bill, Carolyn \u0026 Carrie Stader

Although the cook didn't show up last night, the workers there strived to do their best. Our food was delicious & the waiter was phenomenal~so sweet & apologized for the delay. To those complaining in other reviews about the old look of the place, it's what gives it charm....hence it being the Old Mill that's been serving travelers & diners for decades. If you want modern look & feel, go to a modern place. Thanks again to the sweet waiter!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cory Ray

No organization, prices are good but it takes forever to get served. Bathroom was filthy. My food was finally brought out after everyone else was finishing up eating and the steak was cold and not cooked how I asked for it. I dent it back and went to Arby's

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Regina Henry

Very dark inside. Very slow service. Buffet only on sundays very invited options. Came back from getting our food and there was someone else sitting at our table so we had to move. Definitely will not be back.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

James House

Okay, if you have any dietary issues don't come here. If You're expecting fast service don't come here. There was only one waiter for about a dozen customers. We tipped the guy well because we kind of felt sorry for him.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Iambydefault

It took over an hour to get our food. When we did, it was cold. Potatoes tasted instant, (very cold), corn was cold and definitely from a can, green beans were unseasoned from a can, gravy on roast beef was too salty-likely a can or mix. Rolls were cold- decent but cold. Roast beef was stringy. We were offered no refills on our drinks. It was obvious they were understaffed, but the food wasn’t good either. This place used to be great! I’m sad.It appeared two people total were working. Also- menu said cole slaw- no Cole slaw was offered. No butter for rolls, no knives on table, it was hot- no ac.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Regina Dillworth

Very dark inside. Very slow service. Buffet only on sundays very invited options. Came back from getting our food and there was someone else sitting at our table so we had to move. Definitely will not be back.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Lindsay Cargill

I have to say Thankyou to the complete staff today on Sunday June 18th 2023. You have made this Father's day wonderful for my family. Thankyou miss Susie for taking my last min order an making it more than I ever expected. Can't tankyou you guys enough!Lindsay Cargill

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Mashed Potatoes with Gravy

Adrianna Gerteisen

Food was good, service very slow and to dark inside. Seems they need faster servers.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 2

Rick Thomas

Love the place its self, but it was under staffed, poorly catered an illprepaired for reserved guests. I'm trying to be optimistic, I'm pretty easy to please. Overall it was aweful. Try it for the experience, or not.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 3

April Lewis

Food could definitely use an update and the whole place needs a deep clean.

Ted Miller

We had a fundraiser here. Sandy Mazzier did an excellent job. Very good meal of lasagna, rolls and salad. We had a bar and a bartender.

Kristy Belt

We enjoyed our meal and our service! Understandably, some items were unavailable due to delays in deliveries. That didn’t stop us from having a nice meal and wonderful service from Will! It took a little while to get our food, but we were happy to have the extra time to spend together on our date night. Overall, good food, good service, would come back! Would recommend maybe having some good instrumental country music or something in the background, if possible. I loved the decor and the ambiance! It’s a really cool place if you have the extra time to dine ◡̈

Loading...