Old Mill Restaurant
5031 New Harmony Rd, Evansville
(812) 963-6000
Customers' Favorites
Mashed Potatoes with Gravy
Biscuits and Gravy (Breakfast)
Biscuits and Gravy
Omelets (Breakfast)
Linguica and Cheese
Ham and Cheese
Bacon Mushroom and Swiss Cheese
Ortega and Monterey Jack Cheese
Spinach and Swiss Cheese
Spanish
Vegetable
Chili and Cheese
Mushroom and Swiss
Griddle Combos (Breakfast)
Pancakes, Eggs, and Bacon
Pancakes, Eggs, and Sausage
French Toast, Eggs, and Bacon
French Toast, Eggs, and Sausage
Waffle, Eggs, and Bacon
Waffle, Eggs, and Sausage
2 Short Stack Cakes
1 Stack Cake
French Toast
Waffle
Cereal (Breakfast)
Oats
Cream of Wheat
Oats with Wheat
Cream of Wheat with Bread
Cold Cereal with Bread
Side Orders (Breakfast)
Potatoes
Hash Browns
Bacon
Sausage
Ham
Hamburger Steak
Bowl of Fruit with Toast
2 Eggs
1 Egg
Diced Ham Scramble
Cinnamon Toast and Jelly
2 Biscuits
English Muffin
Bagels
Toast and Jelly
Beverages
Soda
Cranberry Juice
Hot Tea
Iced Tea
Hot Chocolate
Cappuccino Mocha
Orange Juice
Grapefruit Juice
Tomato Juice
Apple Juice
Appetizers (Lunch)
Deep Fried Zucchini
Onion Rings
Chili Cheese Fries
Soups and Salads (Lunch)
Clam Chowder
Chili
Tuna Salad
Shrimp Salad
Spinach Salad
Teriyaki Chicken Salad
Hot Lunches
Hot Beef Sandwich
Hot Turkey Sandwich
Hot Prime Rib Sandwich
Burgers (Lunch)
Old Mill Bacon Cheese Burger
Old Mill Patty Melt
Ortega and Monterey Jack Burger
Giant Chili Burger
Mushroom Cheese Burger
Chucks Veggie Burger
Sandwiches (Lunch)
Grilled Chicken Breast with Cheese
Grille Ham and Cheese
Roasted Turkey Sandwiches
Tuna Melt with Cheese
Bar Q Beef Sandwich
BLT Sandwich
Cold Ham and Cheese
Cold Tuna
Cold Roast Beef
Fish Sandwich
Steak Sandwich
French Dip with Au Jus Sauce
Chicken Fry Steak Club
Slim N Trim Eaters (Lunch)
Char Broiled Ham Burger Steak
Char Broiled Chicken Breast
Diet Plate
Choice of beef or turkey.
Side Orders (Lunch)
French Fries
Potato Salad
Macaroni Salad
Onion Rings
Cottage Cheese
Egg's Breakfast
New York Steak and Eggs
Hamburger Steak and Eggs
Chicken Fried Steak and Eggs
Eggs Benedict
Bacon and Eggs
Sausage and Eggs
Pork Chop and Eggs
Ham and Eggs
Linguica and Eggs
Diced Ham and Scramble
Chorizo and Eggs
2 Eggs
1 Egg
Corn Beef Hash and Eggs
Photos
+23 photos
+22 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Although the cook didn't show up last night, the workers there strived to do their best. Our food was delicious & the waiter was phenomenal~so sweet & apologized for the delay. To those complaining in other reviews about the old look of the place, it's what gives it charm....hence it being the Old Mill that's been serving travelers & diners for decades. If you want modern look & feel, go to a modern place. Thanks again to the sweet waiter!
October 2024
I have to say Thankyou to the complete staff today on Sunday June 18th 2023. You have made this Father's day wonderful for my family. Thankyou miss Susie for taking my last min order an making it more than I ever expected. Can't tankyou you guys enough!Lindsay Cargill
June 2023
Love the place its self, but it was under staffed, poorly catered an illprepaired for reserved guests. I'm trying to be optimistic, I'm pretty easy to please. Overall it was aweful. Try it for the experience, or not.
April 2023
You May Also Like
Marx Barbecue & Catering - 3119 W Maryland St
![]()
Barbecue, Caterers, Barbeque, Salad
Hilltop Inn - 1100 Harmony Way
![]()
Family, Bar, American, German