Old Tyme Deli & Meat Shop

307 N First Ave, Evansville
(812) 401-1030

Recent Reviews

Mont

Incredible, and the staff are happy to serve, I eat here pretty often, great prices, phenomenal food no matter what you get. Support your local bussiness

K Hillenbrand

Best owner you’ll ever meet!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chris Lantaff

Great place to pick up a good lunch meal. They also have some seating if you want to eat there.The main meal rotates daily, but all are good and a great value, with a few things daily.

Shawn Harrison

I've been visiting this place for atleast 10 years never once have I been dissatisfied great plate lunch offered from 10a-1p great food at a great price

Mel D.

Great plate lunches and the freshest burgers I have ever had. Could not ask for nicer people either. A+ Top Notch

Kristi Straub

Fresh food and great service. The cookies at the check out counter always give me something to look forward to on the next visit.

Justin Sweeney

They have the best burgers in town. Very reasonable on their prices

Troy Major

Their "ribeye sandwhich" should be called steak and cheese because it is pre-made and wrapped in foil with cheese on it. My wife heavily dislikes cheese on sandwhiches so she wouldn't eat hers. The steak itself was pretty rubbery and not very tender at all. My double cheeseburger was too greasy and it seems like they didnt season it whatsoever. The mashed potatoes and green beans were incredibly underwhelming and average at best. The only good thing i can say about this place is that it is cheap.

SM Clark

Hands down best burger in town.... and plate lunches are super affordable. If you dont come here for lunch at least once you are missing out.

Melinda Knotts

Every lunch plate is better than the last. I really think it’s the best place for lunch in Evansville

Travis Sutton

Great food and customer service! Plate lunches are excellent. Make sure you get the early KR they may sell out!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Me

Very fun experience and it really does feel old timey. I bought a seasoning (the chipotle one) and I use it on every dish possible

Miles McIntosh

Awesome Plate lunch for only $6.99!

Heather W.

I was working in the area and decided to check this little place out. Unfortunately I came a bit too late for the plate lunches. I was told by some of the patrons and the employees that if you get there before 11:30 ish there is usually plenty of choices. When I arrived around 12:30 there were only marinated chicken breasts and they were grilling fresh hamburgers. I decided to try a burger and also got some of the macaroni salad from the little deli case. The burger was made by hand from fresh ground beef and it was not bad. I've had better and I've had much worse. They do have a few condiments you can add such as pickles, onion, ketsup and mustard. The macaroni salad was creamy and delicious. I thought the burger could've used a little seasoning but overall it wasn't bad. My meal was less than $5 so I am calling it a win! There are a few tables and chairs where you can eat if you'd like but I took mine to go. They have coolers where you can get drinks, frozen meats and seafoods, deli sandwiches etc. and they have a few deli meats and cheeses and fresh cut meats for sale also. There are seasonings and a few bbq sauces for sale as well. Everyone I encountered was super friendly and helpful and I will definitely come back when I'm in the area again and the next time I'll make sure I am there by 11:30 so I can have a plate lunch!

Jennilyn Brown

Had everything i wanted. Good selection of rubs and spices. Offer plate lunch daily

Load More