Papa John's in Evansville

“I ordered a pizza using the app, and it was easy to place my order and pay for it. I ordered the pizza to be take out, and my pizza was hot and fresh when I got there, like they were expecting me, even when serving my 20oz drink to me. And the food tasted wonderful.

Parking: Parking lot is just right in front of the store. And there's plenty of it.“

“Totally Awesome Papa John's Pizza Experience! Eli and Reese took Awesome care of us, made us feel welcomed as if we were family. Eli took my order, and started the dough, while we had a conversation as if we had been friends for years. Same with Reese as he put the string cheese in the dough for our Stuffed Crust Pizza with Sausage, Pepperoni, and Bell Peppers. I am sure the other Papa John's are just as nice, however, we always go to this one as we are always treated like Friends and Family. Stop by and see the crew, as they will be more than happy to hook you up with a Delicious Pizza!!“

“My order has always been accurate and hot. For some reason they've never actually gotten my order done at the right time when I do a future order from the app. Yesterday I stood there waiting for 30 minutes after an order I had put on an hour in advance (future time). ASAP orders tend to be done as expected.“

“In looking for NY Style pizza in Evansville, PJ might be the best option. Lombardi's is the only other option I've found, and when they hit, they hit, but they aren't consistent. PJ is consistent, you will get the same close but not quite right NY style every time. The best of that style that you can get in Evansville consistently.“

“I’m from Indianapolis and currently staying in Evansville for work. My coworker took me out for sushi at a local restaurant she recommended, but unfortunately, it wasn’t what she remembered, and we barely ate. Back at the hotel, we decided to order Papa John’s since it was late, and they delivered.

Let me tell you—this was not only the fastest delivery I’ve ever experienced, but it was also the best Papa John’s pizza I’ve ever had. In fact, it was the best pizza I’ve ever eaten from a food chain franchise! And that’s saying a lot because my family owned 11 Little Caesars locations in the Indianapolis area.

It was so good that we ordered it again the second night, and it was just as phenomenal. The consistency was truly impressive! I even called the store to share my compliments, and the manager, Dylan, was incredibly kind.

Thank you, Dylan, and your amazing team for the outstanding service and top-tier pizza. P.S. Please consider relocating to the Indianapolis area—we need your magic there!“