Penny Lane Coffeehouse
600 SE 2nd St, Evansville
(812) 421-8741
Customers' Favorites
Janice's Ham & Cheese with Extra Hot Coffee
Everything Bagel with an Egg and Sausage
Breakfast Croissant Sandwich
Salted Caramel Turtle Latte
Egg and Sausage Sandwich
Sausage Breakfast Club
Chocolate Muffin
White Chocolate
Macadamia Nut
Lox and Bagel
Menu
Photos
+72 photos
+71 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
A great place to stop in with a friend to relax with a great cup of coffee and a sandwich. Have really enjoyed stopping in as well as looking at (…and purchasing) the local artwork that’s displayed. Still love the picture we bought a couple years ago!
Had my first real coffee here almost 25 years ago. It was a double Shot In The Dark/Black Eye and it was outstanding. Still to this day, after having been to numerous coffee shops throughout numerous cities, it is still the best Shot in the Dark I've ever had. Penny Lane has great a vibe with plenty of atmosphere and culture.
I love the atmosphere and taste of the food at Penny Lane, and I truly want to see it continue to be great. However, my recent carry-out experience left room for improvement:\n\nOrder Pickup Process: Our group placed a carry-out order in advance but picking it up was a hassle. A dedicated line for pre-placed orders that still need to be paid would streamline the process and reduce confusion.\n\nBreakfast Club Sandwich: The sausage links used in the sandwich kept rolling off, making...
