Piece of Cake

210 Main St, Evansville
(812) 424-2253

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Faith Suver

Sent them Pinterest photos of what I was wanting! They got it on the nose! Check the comments for the photos but I wanted succulent themed cupcakes and they did amazing! They were a hit for my baby shower! Super sweet people working there as well everyone was so nice and so accommodating!

Kenneth Tidwell

Friendly staff with the best desserts in town!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Downtown Brownies Cake Pops Cookie Monsters

Kemberle Weightman

WE ALWAYS USE PIECE OF CAKE FOR ALL OUR BIRTHDAYS AND EVENTS!! THE STAFF ARE WONDERFUL AND KNOWLEDGEABLE AND JUST REALLY GREAT PEOPLE AND THEY DO WONDERFUL WORK!!

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Pupcake, Strawberry Cake

Ashton Crowe

My husband and I had never been here and we live out of state but we hired this company to provide the cake and cupcakes for our wedding. The presentation, food, and service was outstanding. My husband is still raving about their peanut butter chip recipe, he said he's never had a cake as moist and delicious. Thank you again to the whole team for making our big day so special!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ally Renee Walker

Please don’t hate me for what I’m about to say. But I had never had one of your cookies…. Until today. I’ve had your cakes. They’re incredible. Everyone knows that. Butttt- again. I had never had a cookie. When I say it was easily one of the best cookies I have ever had. I don’t say that lightly. By far- the best. I will order your cookies for every future function that I have. I will probably be ordering a dozen just to eat and hide from the kids. You have a new customer for life! I am obsessed! ❤️

Christina Aud

This place is phenomenal! We walked in there a half hour before they closed on a Saturday trying to order a wedding cake for the following Saturday. We had just had a bad experience with another bakery the previous day. We spoke to the owner who went over what we wanted in detail. She was so polite and helpful and we just hoped to get it on time. This cake was stunning! Better than I would have ever hoped for, especially on short notice. I will definitely use them again when I need a cake

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Adam Trinkel

Every sweet treat I’ve had from Piece of Cake is delicious. Cate, Kristi, and the entire team are professionals. Cupcakes are often my go-to for birthday celebrations, but they also have a great (and delicious) variety of cookies.

Parking: Parking is free along the street. There are always lots of parking options nearby.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cup Cakes, 6 Pack Cupcakes, Downtown Brownies Cake Pops Cookie Monsters

Chrystal Long

Cake and cupcakes for wedding were beautiful and delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake

Miranda Conners

We ordered a cake over the phone for my son’s birthday/graduation from firefighter training. I didn’t give specific details, but asked them to do something fire-related. The cake was PERFECT! We knew they make the most delicious cakes, but so perfect looking too!! Thank you!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Julia Carver Kathary

I've been getting pastries from Piece of Cake for a long time! They did my wedding cake 21 years ago. We've gotten innumerable plates of cookies, cupcakes, cakes through the years - our folks' 55th anniversary cake, logo cookies for our new business grand opening recently, my sister's birthday cake 2 weeks ago. We love Piece of Cake!

Colin Gwiazdowski

Great work by a great team. Had two other cookies from here as well which were also fantastic. Thank you guys for making my boy’s second birthday so great (:

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pupcake

Cassie Morris

The atmosphere there was lovely and the customer service was top notch! I gave them my idea and they went above and beyond my expectations. The cake was beautiful and delicious!! 10/10 Def recommend and will definitely will be going back next year for my daughter's 18th birthday/ graduation party

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

Jeremy Gicale

Our go to shop for birthdays, graduations and great treats. Always excellent quality and delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Angie Yellig

From our wedding cake 20 years ago, to any celebration, Piece of Cake is always my go to when I come in town.
The Pina Colada cake is amazing!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bill Wazny

Due to a cancellation by another cake decorator, I was in desperate need of a custom cake with only 3 days before the event. Piece of Cake came thru with flying colors for a beautiful cake for my daughters Promotion Ceremony to Lt. Colonel in the USAF. She absolutely LOVED it! So did everyone else! THANK YOU so much.

Loading...