This was my first time ordering a custom cake for my birthday and I am so impressed! The price was reasonable and they interpreted the inspiration pictures and my requests perfectly to create a beautiful cake. Exactly what I wanted and tasted amazing too! Can’t wait to order again!
Wendy Thorpe
Thank you so much for the amazing cake! I get so many compliments every year at my son’s birthday party for your cakes and how amazing they are!
Lib DeWig
My Gilmore Girls cake is perfect!
Tiffany Wilson
The looks in the taste. You will not be disappointed.
ben b
Best cake in Evansville.
Haley Keenan
they do such a great job every time i order from them and staff is so friendly :)
Ravena Dowell
Amazing and friendly staff with delicious chess bars
Justina Price
Piece of Cake never disappoints. I'm picky about my cakes and I have never had any issues with them!
Zachary Morris
Fair prices for good baked goods. Worth it.
Kelly Trent
This cake made by them was absolutely beautiful and delicious!
This bakery was wonderful! The customer service was extremely professional and helpful. The cake we purchased was absolutely delicious. Highly recommend, if you are craving a confection that is out of this world!
Bob Krohn
We had the absolute pleasure of working with Piece of Cake Bakery in Evansville, Indiana, to celebrate our grandson Myles’ incredible victory over cancer. The bakery went above and beyond to create a stunning and delicious monster-themed cake that perfectly captured the spirit of this joyful occasion. Not only was the design of the cake absolutely beautiful, but the taste was out of this world. Every bite was a hit with our entire family, and there were rave reviews all around.
The team at Piece of Cake Bakery was fantastic to work with – incredibly accommodating, professional, and genuinely passionate about making this moment special. They made the process so easy, and the end result was more than we could have ever hoped for. If you’re looking for a bakery that delivers both on quality and service, Piece of Cake Bakery is the place to go! Thank you so much for helping us make Myles’ victory celebration even more memorable!
Faith Suver
Sent them Pinterest photos of what I was wanting! They got it on the nose! Check the comments for the photos but I wanted succulent themed cupcakes and they did amazing! They were a hit for my baby shower! Super sweet people working there as well everyone was so nice and so accommodating!
WE ALWAYS USE PIECE OF CAKE FOR ALL OUR BIRTHDAYS AND EVENTS!! THE STAFF ARE WONDERFUL AND KNOWLEDGEABLE AND JUST REALLY GREAT PEOPLE AND THEY DO WONDERFUL WORK!!
This was my first time ordering a custom cake for my birthday and I am so impressed! The price was reasonable and they interpreted the inspiration pictures and my requests perfectly to create a beautiful cake. Exactly what I wanted and tasted amazing too! Can’t wait to order again!
Thank you so much for the amazing cake! I get so many compliments every year at my son’s birthday party for your cakes and how amazing they are!
My Gilmore Girls cake is perfect!
The looks in the taste. You will not be disappointed.
Best cake in Evansville.
they do such a great job every time i order from them and staff is so friendly :)
Amazing and friendly staff with delicious chess bars
Piece of Cake never disappoints. I'm picky about my cakes and I have never had any issues with them!
Fair prices for good baked goods. Worth it.
This cake made by them was absolutely beautiful and delicious!
Restaurantji Recommends
This bakery was wonderful! The customer service was extremely professional and helpful. The cake we purchased was absolutely delicious. Highly recommend, if you are craving a confection that is out of this world!
We had the absolute pleasure of working with Piece of Cake Bakery in Evansville, Indiana, to celebrate our grandson Myles’ incredible victory over cancer. The bakery went above and beyond to create a stunning and delicious monster-themed cake that perfectly captured the spirit of this joyful occasion. Not only was the design of the cake absolutely beautiful, but the taste was out of this world. Every bite was a hit with our entire family, and there were rave reviews all around.
The team at Piece of Cake Bakery was fantastic to work with – incredibly accommodating, professional, and genuinely passionate about making this moment special. They made the process so easy, and the end result was more than we could have ever hoped for. If you’re looking for a bakery that delivers both on quality and service, Piece of Cake Bakery is the place to go! Thank you so much for helping us make Myles’ victory celebration even more memorable!
Sent them Pinterest photos of what I was wanting! They got it on the nose! Check the comments for the photos but I wanted succulent themed cupcakes and they did amazing! They were a hit for my baby shower! Super sweet people working there as well everyone was so nice and so accommodating!
Friendly staff with the best desserts in town!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Downtown Brownies Cake Pops Cookie Monsters
WE ALWAYS USE PIECE OF CAKE FOR ALL OUR BIRTHDAYS AND EVENTS!! THE STAFF ARE WONDERFUL AND KNOWLEDGEABLE AND JUST REALLY GREAT PEOPLE AND THEY DO WONDERFUL WORK!!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Pupcake, Strawberry Cake
Loading...