Proper Coffee

301 N Green River Rd, Evansville
(812) 303-4754

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Hansen Cox

Ordered a Carmel latte and a hot chocolate with whole milk. Hot chocolate was made with water (shouldn’t have left a tip before tasting). Not sure if they put the Carmel in the latte or not but it just taste burnt and was steamed much longer than it should have been. I consider myself to be a connoisseur of coffee, and the drinks I received today aren’t fit for a truck stop. Extremely disappointed, wouldn’t recommend to a soul. Won’t be back to waste my money because there are countless good coffee shops who care about providing quality and meeting customers expectations.

ismail koyaş

Best coffee in town.. Gorgeous place with awesome service..

Dave Dozier

What a great fit, Proper Coffee and Parlor Doughnuts. I found Proper last year and was disappointed to see it had "closed", but then I realized the location had changed!This is some great espresso! I stop here every time I am in Evansville and will continue to do so!

Zack Beliles

I'll start with my only issue, maps got me here but the address gives you the next door sprint. The front of the bld says parlor donuts and coffee which is confusing when you navigate to proper coffee. It's the same place, not too hard to Sherlock my way through it, just felt worth mentioning. Great atmosphere, the staff at the counter was top notch and gave recommendations per my request. Both my chorizo breakfast tacos and cold brew were wonderful. All around great . Coming back with friends and family.

Colin Runnion

Proper Coffee Roasters was the first coffee company in Evansville that brought third wave coffee fully. Their interpretation of craft coffee from the current wave was executed from sourcing to roast to service, the full third wave experience. While there are many coffee shops in Evansville, they are the only one that could deliver completely. Proper Coffee Roasters did not start out roasting their own coffee, but would sell/make coffee from industry leaders around the US. That was the first indication that the owners had knowledge of the industry, in a way that foreshadowed their eventual success in delivering high quality roasted coffee to Evansville. While their cafe was open on the East side, they delivered on the experience from well trained baristas, to high quality equipment (Slayer Espresso machines, Yama cold brew makers, Fellow Stagg Kettles, Hario V60 pour overs and much more) and a great aesthetic. I went to this cafe hundreds of times while I lived in Evansville during college. For many years I exclusively bought their freshly roasted coffee for my personal consumption at home, until I moved away from Evansville. While their cafe is no longer open, they still roast coffee that can be found at Parlour Donuts and their online store. As far as Evansville coffee roasters, I still believe they are the best roasters in Evansville. So if you are looking for locally roasted coffee, look no further (I am pretty sure I have tried them all)! I do however think that there was something lost in their transition from the cafe, that is likely not entirely their fault, but the circumstances of operating alongside a food business. Where I stand now is they are 5 stars for their coffee roasting in Evansville, but 4 stars for their current cafe experience - at least until they open up a cafe again.Edited: July 7, 2020

Mary Taylor

The coffee shop is attached to a salon school, which I thought was kind of an interesting conflation. But otherwise everything was great.

Daryl Bradhust

Since today was my first visit to Bert's Diner, I chose to order the "Bert's Burger," as I prefer to order the "classic," or "stock" burger during my fist visit, as that will give me a good idea of what the restaurant is all about. Of course, I went with "Bert's Fries," as I can't resist fries with my burger.

MikeD587

Another visit to this location that turned bad for us. We had to wait in line for quite a while, the woman ahead of us had 2 pounds of coffee she had brought into the store to be ground, which took a few minutes. Then we get up to order and they don't have the caramel syrup which nearly every drink these days uses, so they are using caramel drizzle to sub in. We then ordered iced black teas. The iced teas were made and set out and I should have said something but there was no way it was black tea, it was too light for black tea, maybe a white tea? It tasted weak. The trash can was once again overflowing loke last visit. They have no care for customers or to cleanliness in the lobby area. There are other locations which out do the performance of this subpar staff.

Tyler Byars

Pretty good coffee and fairly decent WiFi. My vanilla latte tasted great (even though the didn’t have any pour overs available while I was there) Staff was very friendly and honestly the only bad thing I have to say is that the bathrooms didn’t smell great (but they were still pretty clean) Would definitely recommend visiting if you’re in the area!

Veronica Reed

Stress free atmosphere, beauty, tasty, healty & cozy ????

Russell Brown

Very coffee and tea drink selections. Less expensive than Starbucks. Nice quiet atmosphere.

Anne Frobenius

Awesome drinks, great atmosphere, friendly, great workers and a great way to start my school day next door!

MikeD587

This store seems to be a blemish compared to others. This visit was riddled with issues and lack of any concern for handling it. First they said they were unable to make nitro cold brew as they were having problems with the nitro system, they were prompt to interrupt when I ordered missing thst I wanted the cold brew with sweet cream and instead offering iced cold brew. They then said they were without strawberries for other drinks. The service was slow compared to other locations which are just as busy. Then the drinks came out in odd order as one couple ahead of us ordered two of the same and got them between other orders. My drink came out eithout the sweet cream and it has to be asked for and they acted like they didn't understand. The staff are friendly and welcoming but just can't handle complicated orders or things not on the regular menu. Oh then so we get over by the trash cans and the floor is wet, and I look down to see why. They havented emptied the trash and the recipticle is full and overflowing.

Sajad Al-Sumayin

The best coffee in town. Everything is decent. However, the staff should be a little friendlier.

Craig Seal

The coffee shop is attached to a salon school, which I thought was kind of an interesting combination. When asking to use the restroom, I was pointed in the direction through the salon to use their facility. This seemed odd to me, but I was okay with it, nonetheless. I will say, however, the restroom was not very clean and was out of paper towels.

Loading...