Twisted Tomato - North Side

2333 St George Rd, Evansville
(812) 401-2323

Recent Reviews

Erin

They messed up our sandwich orders 3 times in a row (different visits) and the waitress was really rude about it, the last time we went. We asked for a veggie stromboli and told her what we wanted on the sandwich (tomatoes, jalapeños, mushrooms, green peppers, and a couple other veggies, but no meat). We specifically said we didn’t want any olives as well. When she brought the sandwich out, all it had on it was olives and onions, and marinara sauce. It was disgusting. I tried to ask the waitress about it, and she got upset with me, and was extremely rude with us, almost in a scolding tone, told us that each topping costs extra and we can’t just have whatever we want on the sandwich. Okay, sooo the $9 to $10 we paid for the strom doesn’t cover the bread, sauce, and a handful of veggies??? She refused to have the kitchen make us another strom… When I called to speak to a manager, they accused me of just trying to get free food and demanded we provide a receipt. The waitress did not give us a receipt though. I should’ve asked for one. We will NEVER order from here again. Sad too.. because that business seems to have potential.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Tammy Welch

My first visit here was not good. Waitress seemed bothered by having to wait on us. Young kids were running around screaming. Dog laying on the floor at the table behind us. Not sure if we'll be back.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Cheese Bread

Heath Harlan

Classic una, no complaints, the 5th star is just for over the top. This is above avg so it's a solid 4 while 5 is for life changing experience. You will come away a happy customer eating here, no worries.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Karen R. Wallis

Food always good. Didn't seem to be enough people working, lots of people waiting on orders to go and those dining in hadn't even had order taken while I was there waiting (which was @ 15 min).

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Carnivore Pizza, Hawaiian 5-0, Cheese Bread

Steven Pike

We eat there several times a month, We love the pizza and sandwiches, the cheesy Bread and wings are outstanding. And the new baked potatoes are fantastic and a meal by themselves.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cj M.

food is great, but prices are OUTRAGEOUS. prices are DECEPTIVE. 1000%. I got 3 pizzas, and price came to $65.

Katie C.

My family got 2 pizzas last night for dinner! I will give it an4 because my family loves it but I'm not a huge fan. I only like going because it's close to our house. I personally think our pizza is super bland. I even added crushed red pepper to just give it some kind of flavor. Maybe it's my tastebuds, but I don't think it's that great.

Melody Bennett

We absolutely love their pizza! Great service and great food always. Shop small, shop local ✨️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Hawaiian

David Selner

Only open from 4 pm -9pm.... My wife and I were visiting from out of state thought we would try a local pizza place ... The crust tastes like it was a frozen pizza and before we left we found hair in the pizza.... I'm sorry but I would never go there again. The server was very nice and helpful.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 5

Alicia Renee Selner

Alfredo dipping sauce came out cold. Pizza tasted like it was frozen. Lots of toppings.. but was not impressed.

April Helfert

We had some amazing pizza's and sandwiches. We live supporting local!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Bacon Ranch, Wicked Stromboli

Beth Conaghan

Loved it! Bread was awesome, sauce was perfect, and friendly fast service. Perfect 5 stars ⭐️

Dawn Michelle Seidl Godsey

Delicious pizza and storms. Great customer service. Locally owned.Kid-friendliness: Just a great place for kids and the whole family.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sauce, Cheese Bread

K Broom

Really enjoyed the pizza - generous amount of toppings. Wait staff was excellent! Really felt like they wanted to be there doing their job which doesn't happen in a lot of places. Will definitely go back!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: House Specialty Pizza

Toby Kraft

Update, 6/2023, had pizza delivered the other day and it was pretty darn good! Ate in with some friends also and service and food were great.Original review: I want to like Twisted Tomato because the pizzas are actually pretty good. But, when it comes to ordering delivery over the phone, it's hit or miss, mostly miss. We ordered a chicken alfredo which is supposed to have chicken, broccoli, sauce. We get the pizza - no broccoli, no mention when we ordered that they had no broccoli! Instead there are mushrooms!Then the 2nd pizza was the taco pizza - it came with absolutely NO TACO BEEF on it!You have been warned!Note: tried to add photo of menu showing ingredients but Google can't seem to handle that (doubled one pic and lost the other) - but the only legible menu I could find was on zmenu.Update 3/5/19 - there is a new menu posted on FB that shows mushrooms, but that's NOT the menu shown when you click on Menu on their FB page - and the taco pizza still had no meat on it!Update, 6/2/19, just want to add that we've had delivery pizza a couple of times since and it's been good. We like the crust and sauce although they are a little light on the toppings for our taste. So when they get an order right, it's good. Give them a try!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Load More