The flavors from Bruster’s Ice Cream will make your taste buds dance!! Every week different flavors and made fresh everyday. Graham Central Station is my favorite!! So are the people that work there. Usually a young team working but they have always get the orders right and quick to fill your order. Would recommend this place to anyone!!
Pruthvi Raju
From the moment we walked in, the staff greeted us with genuine warmth and friendly smiles. The place feels clean, welcoming, and full of energy — you can tell they really care about their customers.
The ice cream is on another level — super fresh, incredibly creamy, and bursting with flavor. Every scoop tastes like it was made just moments before. Their waffle cones are perfectly crisp, and the portions are generous. We tried a few flavors and each one was better than the last.
Special shout-out to the team working today — they were patient, helpful with recommendations, and made the whole experience extra enjoyable. It’s rare to find a place that nails both great service and amazing ice cream, but Bruster’s Fishers does it effortlessly.
Whether you’re stopping by with family, grabbing a late-night treat, or just craving something sweet, this location is a must-visit. Highly recommended! 🍨✨
Om Patel
Honestly phenomenal. never in my life have I gotten such an amazing service and ice cream. Could not recommend more to any and all people who are in the area. Easy 5 star
Jennifer Juday
This has become our go-to for a special treat after swim meets or school successes. The ice cream is always delicious, the service is friendly and fast, and the outdoor seating is perfect. We love that this is in our neighborhood!
Alexia Lopez
Nice little spot to get some ice cream at the walk up window. Yummy ice cream and very friendly staff that were extra helpful!
Tatiana Funes
I love Bruster’s. 🥰
Angela Rabus
Great ice cream with lots of choices. Friendly staff and easy access.
Randall Isley
Great flavors and excellent service.
Mark Moriarty
What's not to love about delicious ice cream!? My #1 stop after I've been kayaking!
Jessica Watson Coleman
The ice cream here always has ice crystals and is mediocre in flavor. They also are often out of the decent flavors and the oat milk ice cream has been out for months. Just have better local options.
Ice cream was good but do not get the blue ice. It made my brothers teeth turn into the color of an avatar
William Davis
I’ll give you 5 stars when graham centra comes back. Also the sea salt Carmel tastes like a chemical
Suchitra Tripathi
There is absolutely nothing I don’t like about this place! It’s just perfect! Perfect ice cream, perfect service providers, perfect atmosphere. I was just introduced to Brusters a couple of months before as I am from NY and I come here every week. I did not use to go and buy ice cream in NY before as they were tooo sweet and did not feel like ice-cream.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Seth Barrus
We loved Bruster’s! Two scoop waffle cones were big and the ice cream was delicious. It was a perfect night to sit outside. Employees were nice too!
The flavors from Bruster’s Ice Cream will make your taste buds dance!! Every week different flavors and made fresh everyday. Graham Central Station is my favorite!! So are the people that work there. Usually a young team working but they have always get the orders right and quick to fill your order. Would recommend this place to anyone!!
From the moment we walked in, the staff greeted us with genuine warmth and friendly smiles. The place feels clean, welcoming, and full of energy — you can tell they really care about their customers.
The ice cream is on another level — super fresh, incredibly creamy, and bursting with flavor. Every scoop tastes like it was made just moments before. Their waffle cones are perfectly crisp, and the portions are generous. We tried a few flavors and each one was better than the last.
Special shout-out to the team working today — they were patient, helpful with recommendations, and made the whole experience extra enjoyable. It’s rare to find a place that nails both great service and amazing ice cream, but Bruster’s Fishers does it effortlessly.
Whether you’re stopping by with family, grabbing a late-night treat, or just craving something sweet, this location is a must-visit.
Highly recommended! 🍨✨
Honestly phenomenal. never in my life have I gotten such an amazing service and ice cream. Could not recommend more to any and all people who are in the area. Easy 5 star
This has become our go-to for a special treat after swim meets or school successes. The ice cream is always delicious, the service is friendly and fast, and the outdoor seating is perfect. We love that this is in our neighborhood!
Nice little spot to get some ice cream at the walk up window. Yummy ice cream and very friendly staff that were extra helpful!
I love Bruster’s. 🥰
Great ice cream with lots of choices. Friendly staff and easy access.
Great flavors and excellent service.
What's not to love about delicious ice cream!?
My #1 stop after I've been kayaking!
The ice cream here always has ice crystals and is mediocre in flavor. They also are often out of the decent flavors and the oat milk ice cream has been out for months. Just have better local options.
Restaurantji Recommends
Bad customer service.
Ice cream was good but do not get the blue ice. It made my brothers teeth turn into the color of an avatar
I’ll give you 5 stars when graham centra comes back. Also the sea salt Carmel tastes like a chemical
There is absolutely nothing I don’t like about this place! It’s just perfect! Perfect ice cream, perfect service providers, perfect atmosphere. I was just introduced to Brusters a couple of months before as I am from NY and I come here every week. I did not use to go and buy ice cream in NY before as they were tooo sweet and did not feel like ice-cream.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We loved Bruster’s! Two scoop waffle cones were big and the ice cream was delicious. It was a perfect night to sit outside. Employees were nice too!
Loading...