HotBox Pizza

8938 E 96th St, Fishers
(317) 863-3303

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kristian Beltran

Breadsticks and cheese are top tier and the pizza is delicious. Dough is perfectly crisped and it's not swimming in sauce with the perfect amount of toppings. The vibe is super chill and cool too

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cate Falk

Not only was our PICKUP order 45 minutes late (which we ordered hours ahead of time), when we asked for resolution they all but walked us out the door with zero regard for how much they wasted our time and interruption for our night.
The disregard the manager had after we tried multiple times to politely ask for resolve of our non existing food was beyond disrespectful.
There’s no wonder this location has terrible service and execution, can’t keep it staffed with a manager that rude

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Joel Markiewicz

The quality of your food depends on who is working that day. Hit or miss at best

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 3

Shauna Duke

Payday Pizza Friday is my work's new thing. The lunch special deals are INSANE. The same guy works every Friday and knocks it out of the park; cheesy and consistently good pizza.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kayla Smith

I have been liking going to hotbox recently the pizza is amazing the staff is so friendly this is my favorite pizza restaurant so far I will be back here everytime I want to have a good meal.

Nathan Hair

Great pizza and amazing customer service!!! They always treat me very good with top notch customer service!!! Easily the best value pizza around!!!

Sean Hofsommer

I love the salads there, honestly I think they are better than the pizza

Rhonda Marshall

Very disappointed. I live 3 mins away and waited over an hour for pizza and stix. Called to check on it and they had no idea if it was sent out or not. Finally arrives. Did not bring the garlic sauce and I don’t know what happened to their stix tonight but they are not the normal HB stix. Dough did not rise or something. Have always had great service and food. Something is going on. Only 1 person working when I stopped in the other day for stix. Took almost 20 mins. Please fix the problems.

Zackeriah Steagall

Great place to eat. Staff is great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Large Supreme Pizza, Supreme Small 10, Salad, Stix, Supreme Large 14, Ballsagna X-Large 16, Small Porky the Pie Pizza, Popeye X-Large 16

Cyberkid57

I love Hotbox!! Their food is amazing!!! I love that when I go in the store I am greeted with smile. I highly recommend them.

Nicholas Hall

I place an online order at 6:04pm, given 614-624 pickup window. I arrive at 625. Customer in front of me placed a new order. Same customer receives pizza at 652 ahead of me, I receive mine at 655. Consistently the most disorganized pizza shop I've ever seen over the last year.

Alex Mills

To keep brief: There at 5:30 on a Saturday with (I see) 5 people working. No one acknowledges me for a few minutes. Tell employee info for picking up online order, looks confused and starts walking around, comes back to answer phone in front of me and TAKE SOMEONE ELSE’S ORDER. No acknowledgement of me being actively in front of him. Female worker comes up to apologize but then original worker continues to barely help. Also, LG cheese stix were cut like a pizza? Major fail.

Medoo 2k

The food is always hot on time and delicious can’t remember the last time I had a good pizza like that definitely going back there 10/10 experience

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza, Stix

Lucas Sweet

Food is always hot and delicious. People are friendly. Its the exact kind of atmosphere you would want from a great pizza place!

Don Padgett

Not good at all.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

Loading...