This McAlister's has been around for a long time and it's easy to see why. I've never had a bad experience here. My go-to is the McAlister's Club, potato salad, and a sweet tea. Sitting on the porch in the summer just adds to the experience. I will continue to return here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Club Sandwich Tray
Benjamin Huang
Shout out to Mary, Aurora, Carter, Rachel, Brandon, and that one awesome guy with the beard and the ponytail who says "good morning" no matter what time it is. There's more on the same shift, but sorry I can't remember all your names! You all make my day every time I see you. In terms of friendliness and team camaraderie, this Fishers location probably has the best and most cohesive team. Awesome customer service, always eager to get to know the customers, they work quickly and accurately, and you always leave happier than when you went in. Other locations, take note! Corporate also needs to take note of the great things they're doing here and approve more raises and bonuses at this location. God bless you all!
The Fishers location also stands out with their incredible chocolate chip cookies, freshly baked in-house. Soft, doughy, and every bite is so delicious (see the attached photos). Wow! Other locations, take note; this right here is how to make a cookie!! Buy these cookies here and not the hard cookies that other locations have.
Check out the Fishers location for their amazing spuds as well!
McAlister's Deli is wonderful! They have delicious and healthy sandwiches, salads made with clean and fresh vegetables, the best spuds you'll ever eat, and best of all, McAlister's Famous Tea!!! 🍵 The sandwiches and salads are at the same price point as that of Panera Bread, and it's apparent that McAlister's Deli is a competitor to Panera. But what sets McAllister's Deli apart in the higher-end sandwich and salad industry is McAlister's Famous Tea! 🍵
The tea is an experience. Make sure to fill your cup to the brim with ice, because McAlister's Deli brews its tea strong and hot. The tea is a perfect combination of flavors, from the earthy bitterness from the premium black tea leaves, balanced by the zing of freshly squeezed lemon! To top it off, add a couple shots of real fruit puree! The best combination is the peach tea. 🍑 🍵 Recommendation: Add two or three pumps of peach puree 🍑 to a glass of unsweetened tea 🍵, and squeeze in two or three slices of lemon. 🍋 The result is perfection! Like a hug in a glass, just the right amount of fruity sweetness, and an excellent source of vitamin C! 🍋
Other recommendations:
- Savannah chopped salad 🥗, with Sherry shallot dressing; - Pecanberry salad 🥗, with Sherry shallot dressing; - Colossal carrot cake 🥕 🍰; - Chocolate chip cookie (get these soft and delicious cookies at the Fishers location, and avoid the hard cookies at other locations); - Spicy southwest chicken 🐣 🪓 ➡️🍗🥑; and - Spud max, but also add avocado, extra green onions, and extra butter! Perfect with a side of tomato and cucumber salad.
5/5; highly recommend!
Vegetarian options: If you'd prefer not to eat meat, try one of the delicious salads, the veggie sandwich, or the veggie spud. Multi-colored roasted bell peppers, spinach, broccoli, all the vegetables you can dream of.
Dietary restrictions: Fair warning that this place serves products containing gluten, dairy, and tree nuts. If you cannot eat gluten, I would recommend the delicious spuds and salads!
Parking: The plaza is pretty packed during business hours, but you can usually get a good parking spot as long as it's not during the lunch or dinner rush. Parking is free, thankfully. Rest assured, McAlister's Deli does not try to profit off of a piece of asphalt.
Kid-friendliness: With a wonderful kids menu that includes sandwiches, salads, and spuds, what's not to love for your kiddos here! Regarding the delicious tea, though, just make sure to refrain from giving kiddos too much caffeine.
Wheelchair accessibility: Aside from entrance doors that you must pull to open, the rest of the restaurant is rather accessible to
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chips, Club Sandwich Tray, Grilled Chicken Salad, Turkey Sandwich, Chicken Tortilla, Choose 2, Pickles, Broccoli Cheddar, Baked Potato, Grilled Chicken, Ham & Cheese Melt, Club Sandwich and Steamed Broccoli, Savannah Chopped Salad, Harvest Chicken Salad
Mando
This McAlister’s location is conveniently located near downtown Fishers. The restaurant was clean, and the staff provided friendly service. The food was good, offering a variety of options like sandwiches and soups. Overall, it’s a solid choice for a quick meal in the area.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Lori Compton
Good food. Great tea. Every worker is nice. Clean restaurant.
The best place for quick, fresh food that is a good price and makes you feel good about what you're eating. Sweet & Smoky chicken sandwich is delicious
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rebecca Cook
Ordered a doordash through this location, called to request extra pickles and Evan came in clutch! Great experience, love mccalisters
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jenna Reynolds
Very clean, employees were very friendly and double checked with me about getting order correct. Food was prepared well
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Deena G
Oh my goodness this place was amazing You have to get the iced tea lemonade Sandwiches where the best
As expected. Cuban sandwich and chips were very tasty.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chips, Pickles
L C
This is a great McCallister's. A young man named Carter assisted us and he was incredibly kind and helpful. We will be back!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
thealmightytoad1
$12 for an avocado and chicken salad and this is all the avocado you get?? That's just not right...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Brandon Perry
Things missing from the order that I didn’t notice until I was already home. The place was not clean (drink stand, and bathroom). McAlisters is not what it was. Why don’t you guys fill the beverages anymore? That public drink stand is a bad move.
Silly Nurse
We had a wonderful lunch!! The sandwiches and potato salad were pretty amazing!!
Clean, fast service, good food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This McAlister's has been around for a long time and it's easy to see why. I've never had a bad experience here. My go-to is the McAlister's Club, potato salad, and a sweet tea. Sitting on the porch in the summer just adds to the experience. I will continue to return here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Club Sandwich Tray
Shout out to Mary, Aurora, Carter, Rachel, Brandon, and that one awesome guy with the beard and the ponytail who says "good morning" no matter what time it is. There's more on the same shift, but sorry I can't remember all your names! You all make my day every time I see you. In terms of friendliness and team camaraderie, this Fishers location probably has the best and most cohesive team. Awesome customer service, always eager to get to know the customers, they work quickly and accurately, and you always leave happier than when you went in. Other locations, take note! Corporate also needs to take note of the great things they're doing here and approve more raises and bonuses at this location. God bless you all!
The Fishers location also stands out with their incredible chocolate chip cookies, freshly baked in-house. Soft, doughy, and every bite is so delicious (see the attached photos). Wow! Other locations, take note; this right here is how to make a cookie!! Buy these cookies here and not the hard cookies that other locations have.
Check out the Fishers location for their amazing spuds as well!
McAlister's Deli is wonderful! They have delicious and healthy sandwiches, salads made with clean and fresh vegetables, the best spuds you'll ever eat, and best of all, McAlister's Famous Tea!!! 🍵 The sandwiches and salads are at the same price point as that of Panera Bread, and it's apparent that McAlister's Deli is a competitor to Panera. But what sets McAllister's Deli apart in the higher-end sandwich and salad industry is McAlister's Famous Tea! 🍵
The tea is an experience. Make sure to fill your cup to the brim with ice, because McAlister's Deli brews its tea strong and hot. The tea is a perfect combination of flavors, from the earthy bitterness from the premium black tea leaves, balanced by the zing of freshly squeezed lemon! To top it off, add a couple shots of real fruit puree! The best combination is the peach tea. 🍑 🍵 Recommendation: Add two or three pumps of peach puree 🍑 to a glass of unsweetened tea 🍵, and squeeze in two or three slices of lemon. 🍋 The result is perfection! Like a hug in a glass, just the right amount of fruity sweetness, and an excellent source of vitamin C! 🍋
Other recommendations:
- Savannah chopped salad 🥗, with Sherry shallot dressing;
- Pecanberry salad 🥗, with Sherry shallot dressing;
- Colossal carrot cake 🥕 🍰;
- Chocolate chip cookie (get these soft and delicious cookies at the Fishers location, and avoid the hard cookies at other locations);
- Spicy southwest chicken 🐣 🪓 ➡️🍗🥑; and
- Spud max, but also add avocado, extra green onions, and extra butter! Perfect with a side of tomato and cucumber salad.
5/5; highly recommend!
Vegetarian options: If you'd prefer not to eat meat, try one of the delicious salads, the veggie sandwich, or the veggie spud. Multi-colored roasted bell peppers, spinach, broccoli, all the vegetables you can dream of.
Dietary restrictions: Fair warning that this place serves products containing gluten, dairy, and tree nuts. If you cannot eat gluten, I would recommend the delicious spuds and salads!
Parking: The plaza is pretty packed during business hours, but you can usually get a good parking spot as long as it's not during the lunch or dinner rush. Parking is free, thankfully. Rest assured, McAlister's Deli does not try to profit off of a piece of asphalt.
Kid-friendliness: With a wonderful kids menu that includes sandwiches, salads, and spuds, what's not to love for your kiddos here! Regarding the delicious tea, though, just make sure to refrain from giving kiddos too much caffeine.
Wheelchair accessibility: Aside from entrance doors that you must pull to open, the rest of the restaurant is rather accessible to
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chips, Club Sandwich Tray, Grilled Chicken Salad, Turkey Sandwich, Chicken Tortilla, Choose 2, Pickles, Broccoli Cheddar, Baked Potato, Grilled Chicken, Ham & Cheese Melt, Club Sandwich and Steamed Broccoli, Savannah Chopped Salad, Harvest Chicken Salad
This McAlister’s location is conveniently located near downtown Fishers. The restaurant was clean, and the staff provided friendly service. The food was good, offering a variety of options like sandwiches and soups. Overall, it’s a solid choice for a quick meal in the area.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Good food. Great tea. Every worker is nice. Clean restaurant.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chips, Grilled Chicken Salad, Pickles, Harvest Chicken Salad
The best place for quick, fresh food that is a good price and makes you feel good about what you're eating. Sweet & Smoky chicken sandwich is delicious
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a doordash through this location, called to request extra pickles and Evan came in clutch! Great experience, love mccalisters
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very clean, employees were very friendly and double checked with me about getting order correct. Food was prepared well
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Oh my goodness this place was amazing
You have to get the iced tea lemonade
Sandwiches where the best
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Broccoli Cheddar, Baked Potato
Many of our favorite items have been removed from your menu. Very dissapointing....
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
As expected. Cuban sandwich and chips were very tasty.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chips, Pickles
This is a great McCallister's. A young man named Carter assisted us and he was incredibly kind and helpful. We will be back!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
$12 for an avocado and chicken salad and this is all the avocado you get?? That's just not right...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Things missing from the order that I didn’t notice until I was already home. The place was not clean (drink stand, and bathroom). McAlisters is not what it was. Why don’t you guys fill the beverages anymore? That public drink stand is a bad move.
We had a wonderful lunch!! The sandwiches and potato salad were pretty amazing!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...