Although no category received a 5 star , all were very high 4 star ergo the 5 star rating. We have been to Murphys on several occasions, it is our go to on nights when nothing is planned for dinner and neither of us want to cook. We usually eat in the dining room, but this night we when in side room Speakeasy. It was crowded and loud. Our service was rough. The servers were the bar tenders, and they would come out , take an order and go back , mix the drinks then deliver them. We later found out that the server that was supposed to be there, had called in sick. Our server took our drink orders and delivered them in a reasonable time. He then took our food order. Sometime around this time, t he server misplaced something and at that point he was solely focused on what was misplaced. You would think this would automatically lead to a bad service score, however, the other staff members stepped in and covered fairly well. The food was tast enough. We had the chicken ranch sliders, ham and cheese sliders as well as the parmesian tater tots. All solid bar food. The manager/owner was making rounds and checking on people. We shared with him the shortcomings of the service and applauded the servers that stepped up. He tossed in an order of their butter cake as an apology, which was well accepted. Bottom line, what could have been a rotten service night. Was an ok service night. Management acknowledged their shortcomings and offered a token to make amends
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Chris Stocks
This is the best ever Kendra is amazing!! Best old fashioned drink ever! Just what fishers needed!!
Jennifer Sheets
The Murphys Barstoner experience deserves a 5 star rating all around. This speakeasy delivered a flawless experience. The atmosphere is intimate without feeling cramped, and every detail—from the dim lighting, candle lit tables, to the curated playlists—sets the mood perfectly. The cocktails are exceptionally crafted, each one balanced, inventive, and presented with care. Service was warm, knowledgeable, and never rushed. It’s the kind of place you want to keep secret… but it’s too good not to share.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Adrienne Hamada
Amy was absolutely amazing and my husband and I had a great time!
Service: 5
Robert Joseph
I’ve eaten at Murphy’s for decades but I just walked out tonight. After standing at the hostess stand for 20 minutes before getting seated at 8:30 pm after church I sat at the table for 15minutes and no one even came and took my drink order. Enough is enough I’m off to Culver’s for better service!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Tyler Beeson
I never leave reviews, but Amy was such a good waitress I had to! This place is amazing. Such a good experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hannah Beeson
We stopped in to catch the end of the IU game and had an incredible all around dining experience. The food was incredible and the atmosphere was great. We had Amy F as our server and she was outstanding! Will be back very soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hi Lo
Always right with the food and friendly service. Love the Barstoner Lounge too.
To an amazing staff: thank you so much for the pre-party for Dave Matthews Band Creekend weekend! The food and drinks were amazing as always! Can’t wait for next year!!
Stephen Fox
We had Amy as our server tonight and she was absolutely amazing! The food was great and the service was excellent! We realized we should be coming here more often!
Jessica Manifold
Terrible food. Stale hoagie on cheesesteak with the smallest portion of fries we've ever had at similar places. Two old pieces of asparagus so fibrous it was inedible, tough steak, old tasting dry mashed potatoes. First and last visit here. French onion soup was also not good, too salty, packaged crouton top with seemingly microwaved cheese on top. very disappointed. Server was polite and they did remove the soup and steak dinner as it was inedible...
Best burger in town. The steak is also good.
Fast and friendly staff!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great local hangout. Live music and a good bar.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Although no category received a 5 star , all were very high 4 star ergo the 5 star rating.
We have been to Murphys on several occasions, it is our go to on nights when nothing is planned for dinner and neither of us want to cook.
We usually eat in the dining room, but this night we when in side room Speakeasy.
It was crowded and loud. Our service was rough. The servers were the bar tenders, and they would come out , take an order and go back , mix the drinks then deliver them. We later found out that the server that was supposed to be there, had called in sick.
Our server took our drink orders and delivered them in a reasonable time. He then took our food order. Sometime around this time, t he server misplaced something and at that point he was solely focused on what was misplaced. You would think this would automatically lead to a bad service score, however, the other staff members stepped in and covered fairly well.
The food was tast enough. We had the chicken ranch sliders, ham and cheese sliders as well as the parmesian tater tots. All solid bar food.
The manager/owner was making rounds and checking on people. We shared with him the shortcomings of the service and applauded the servers that stepped up. He tossed in an order of their butter cake as an apology, which was well accepted.
Bottom line, what could have been a rotten service night. Was an ok service night. Management acknowledged their shortcomings and offered a token to make amends
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
This is the best ever Kendra is amazing!! Best old fashioned drink ever! Just what fishers needed!!
The Murphys Barstoner experience deserves a 5 star rating all around. This speakeasy delivered a flawless experience. The atmosphere is intimate without feeling cramped, and every detail—from the dim lighting, candle lit tables, to the curated playlists—sets the mood perfectly. The cocktails are exceptionally crafted, each one balanced, inventive, and presented with care. Service was warm, knowledgeable, and never rushed. It’s the kind of place you want to keep secret… but it’s too good not to share.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amy was absolutely amazing and my husband and I had a great time!
Service: 5
I’ve eaten at Murphy’s for decades but I just walked out tonight. After standing at the hostess stand for 20 minutes before getting seated at 8:30 pm after church I sat at the table for 15minutes and no one even came and took my drink order. Enough is enough I’m off to Culver’s for better service!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I never leave reviews, but Amy was such a good waitress I had to! This place is amazing. Such a good experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We stopped in to catch the end of the IU game and had an incredible all around dining experience. The food was incredible and the atmosphere was great. We had Amy F as our server and she was outstanding! Will be back very soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always right with the food and friendly service. Love the Barstoner Lounge too.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Very clean place and very nice people
To an amazing staff: thank you so much for the pre-party for Dave Matthews Band Creekend weekend! The food and drinks were amazing as always! Can’t wait for next year!!
We had Amy as our server tonight and she was absolutely amazing! The food was great and the service was excellent! We realized we should be coming here more often!
Terrible food. Stale hoagie on cheesesteak with the smallest portion of fries we've ever had at similar places. Two old pieces of asparagus so fibrous it was inedible, tough steak, old tasting dry mashed potatoes. First and last visit here. French onion soup was also not good, too salty, packaged crouton top with seemingly microwaved cheese on top. very disappointed. Server was polite and they did remove the soup and steak dinner as it was inedible...
Great lunches.
Loading...