New York Pizza Garden

9522 E 126th St, Fishers
(317) 284-1163

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza
Shawarma
Sandwich
Tenders
Wings
Sauce
Gyro

Menu

Featured items
Family Special
2 extra large pizzas 1 topping each, 15 pieces wings, 2-liter soda, and fries.
Wings
Super Supreme
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, mushrooms, olives, onion, green peppers, and extra cheese.
Shawarma
Comes with fries. Chicken or beef.
Philly Cheesesteak Chicken
Comes with fries.

Deals
Family Special
2 extra large pizzas 1 topping each, 15 pieces wings, 2-liter soda, and fries.
Pizza (2 Xl), Toppings (2 pcs)
One Large Toppings (2 pcs) & Wings (15 pcs)
One Large Toppings (2 pcs) & Tenders (15 pcs)

Featured Items
Wings
Cheese Breadsticks
Shawarma
Comes with fries. Chicken or beef.
Chicken Parmesan
Comes with fries.
Gyro
Comes with fries.
Meat Lovers
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, beef, and extra cheese.
Super Supreme
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, mushrooms, olives, onion, green peppers, and extra cheese.
Chicken Tenders (4 pcs) with Fries
Grilled Chicken Salad

Pizza
Meat Lovers
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, beef, and extra cheese.
Super Supreme
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, mushrooms, olives, onion, green peppers, and extra cheese.
Mooney's Alfredo
Alfredo sauce, chicken, bacon, tomatoes, and cheese.
Buffalo Chicken
Chicken, banana peppers, and cheese.
Marama Veggie
Mushrooms, olives, onions, green peppers, tomatoes, and thyme.
Hawaiian Special
Ham, pineapple, and extra cheese.
Greek Pizza
Gyro meat, onions, kalamata olives, feta cheese, with extra cheese.
Margherita Pizza
Garlic, tomatoes, basil, and extra cheese.
BBQ Special
BBQ sauce, chicken, onions, and extra cheese.
Medium All-american Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and red onions.
Chicken, Bacon, Ranch
Chicken, bacon, tomatoes, and ranch sauce.
Bacon, Cheese, Burger
Beef, bacon, and cheese.

Build Your Own
Cheese Pizza (Large)
Cheese Pizza (Medium)
Cheese Pizza (Small)
Cheese Pizza (Extra Large)

Chicken Wings
Wings
Wings (6 pcs) with Fries

Chicken Tenders
Chicken Tenders (4 pcs) with Fries
Chicken Tenders (20 pcs)
Chicken Tenders (10 pcs)
Chicken Tenders (7 pcs)
Chicken Tenders (15 pcs)

Side Orders
Cheese Breadsticks
Extra Sauce
Okra, Onion Rings, Mushrooms, and Large Fries
Fries M
Breadsticks

Fish Family Meals
Catfish Fillet (20 pcs)
Catfish Fillet (10 pcs)
Tilapia (10 pcs)
Tilapia (20 pcs)

Salads
Grilled Chicken Salad
Greek Salad
Garden Salad
Grilled Steak Salad

Fish Dinners
Tilapia (2 pcs)
Comes with fries.
Catfish (2 pcs)
Comes with fries.
Catfish Nuggets
Comes with fries.

New York Meals
Philly Cheesesteak Chicken
Comes with fries.
Gyro
Comes with fries.
Chicken Parmesan
Comes with fries.
Chicken Wings (6 pcs)
Comes with fries.
Falafel with Drink
Comes with fries and a drink.
Cheeseburger
Comes with fries.
Pizza Puff with Drink
Comes with fries and a drink.
Philly Cheesesteak Beef
Comes with fries.
Tenders
Double Cheeseburger
Comes with fries.

Shawarma
Shawarma
Comes with fries. Chicken or beef.

Kebab
Kebab
Fries, tomato, onion, and parsley.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: facebook
+36 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+35 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

This place has gone through a few owners and management. Excited to see the rebrand in the coming months. Tony is always excellent and is incredible at taking care of you consistently.
October 2023
The food is amazing ,we got cheese phelle steak ,shawrma and kofta,and it was amazing, thank you for the lovely food the chef is great

Dietary restrictions: It's all halal 100%
October 2023
Very friendly and enjoyable experience.The pizza was average (not terrible — toppings were good, but crust was subpar) and the restaurant was grimy with dirty tables.Staff was pleasant, friendly, and attentive. I’d like them to be successful.
August 2023

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Colosseo Pizzeria - 9522 126th St
Pizza
Hong Kong Cuisine - 9524 126th St
Chinese
Texas Roadhouse - 12950 Publishers Dr
Steak House, Barbeque, American, Gluten-Free, Vegetarian

New York Pizza Garden

9522 E 126th St, Fishers, IN 46038
(317) 284-1163