Nicey Treat

11547 Yard St Ste 840, Fishers
(317) 712-3908

Recent Reviews

Sort by
patrick province

Good customer service šŸ‘ tasty strawberry cream. The banana cream however did not taste like banana had a toffee/coffee flavor idk if they burned the cream when making it maybe.

Sara S

Visited this place last year while traveling for business and it was great! This visit, I walked in and no one was at the front. I waited for 5-8 minutes. The girl comes to the front, gen z stares me with no apology and just a quiet awkward ā€œheyā€, and I just say ā€œnevermind I’ve been waiting for 10 minutes.ā€ It took me off guard how bad the customer service was. It wasn’t her fault as she was probably busy in the back. I was just hangry and annoyed. Hire more people or have a bell of some sorts.

Ayana Russell

Nicey treats are consistently great! The new price for a dozen treats has dramatically increased though.

Olivia Dent Hency

We love Nicey Treat popsicles and rented the cart for dessert at our wedding reception! Delicious and everyone loved it! Highly recommend!

Lori Jo

Ice cream, coffee drinks & many other treats

Angela L.

This place is amazing. New owner is kind, gracious and the best coffee I’ve ever tasted is coming. Check this place out after the remodel.

Jenilee

Nicey is a modern, trendy ice cream shop that specializes in popsicles, offering a unique twist on traditional ice cream. The flavors are creative and full of unexpected combinations, setting it apart from typical ice cream spots. I especially love the option to dip popsicles in chocolate, with plenty of topping choices to customize your treat.

The branding, color scheme, and decor are all on point, giving the place a fresh, inviting vibe. The only reason I’m giving it four stars is that on my last three visits, they hadn’t restocked their chocolate dips in time, which feels like something that should be easy to keep up with. Still, it’s a fun and delicious spot that’s definitely worth checking out!

Aj

It was a nice experience, just wish they had more options

Scott Gregg

Fix your fishers stores hours!!! We’ve went multiple times only to find it closed even tho the hours say open.

ASYPT

We tasted the pumpkin, butterscotch and mango flavors, and they were delicious. The ice cream/ nicey stick was made with quality ingredients.

Denise Reppen

So yummy. Vegan choices

Ailee Darmos

Delicious ice pops!!! We will be back!

G Fatima

Just a hot day and fancy popsicles in a very chic location. Just the right combo! I tried the vegan POG passion fruit, orange and guava and the Strawberry Rhubarb. Both the flavors were so different and extremely flavorful. Each lick was a different taste and summery vibes all along.The store is spacious and the lines go pretty quick. I, for one found the price pretty accurate. Service was really good where the server took the time out to share the ingredients, that was helpful since I wanted vegan only.

Jake

Got the strawberry mint. It was AWESOME!

M. Y.

So GOOD!

Loading...