Taylor's Bakery

8395 E 116th St, Fishers
(317) 596-2253

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Triple Chocolate Ganache Cake

Taylor’S Bakery Gummy Bears

Cinnamon Roll Butter Danish

Cookie with Icing Sandwich

Miniature Alligator Danish

Miniature Birthday Cake

Butterhorn Apple Danish

9 Dutch Cherry Pie

Gingerbread Person

Multi Grain Bread

Photos

+59 photos

+58 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Square

Bakesmart

Recent Reviews

This review is mixed. Absolutely loved the chicken pot pie. All thought it tasted great! We also bought a couple of desserts: the spiced pumpkin roll and the Caramel Apple Coffee cake. Unfortunately not that great. Our opinion is the pumkin roll frosting to cake ratio was off. Way too much frosting thus resulting in an overly sweet dessert. The caramel apple coffee cake was too dry. Prime rib dinner went great and the only left overs were the 2 desserts.
All...

November 2025

The donuts are the best! However, was disappointed in the carrot cake. Very dry and definitely could have used more icing. I have had the sheet cake before and it was awesome so I was sad to find the carrot cake sub par.

October 2025

Taylor’s Bakery is fantastic! My co-worker placed an order for a colleagues birthday today. He realized he had accidentally placed the order for tomorrow instead. This was a special cake with a printed image and Yolanda and her team were able to get it put together last minute for us. The cake was delicious and the service was top notch. Would definitely recommend for your next event!

September 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in Fishers, IN

Taylor's Bakery

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Taylor's Bakery