Hostess and waitress were excellent Both wished us Happy Anniversary. Berkshire chop and scallops were excellent but husband thought 3 scallops was not much for price of the dinner. Love the baguettes and whipped butter starter. Noise lrevel was high. We had difficulty hearing each other talk.
Peter
Our Server Kristen was fantastic. We had a wonderful experience. All of us thoroughly enjoyed our meals. The crab cakes, the pork chop and the bolognese paste was fantastic.
Kent
We've been to HCT many times and have always enjoyed it. I'm glad last night wasn't our first experience there because we wouldn't go back. The noise was off the charts. Our waitress was slow, unresponsive, didn't know the menu very well, and overall not good. At one point I actually had to flag her down to have her come back because she never took my wife's order. They were out of things we like (e.g. standard menu items like the lobster cargot) and making small modifications to an entree order (e.g. getting green beans instead of mashed potatoes) was not possible for some reason. I wouldn't say we won't be back but with the level of competition on the northside of Indy these days, we'll tray a lot of other options before returning.
Sarah
Everything was pretty good. But the prices are way too high for the value. It's not fine dining. If the service was more professional, then perhaps you could justify the prices.
Jamie
Everythung was perfect. The food was fresh, hot and delicious. Our server was attentive and personable. It was a special treat for a 16th birthday celebration and my guests were very impressed with all of it
Hailee
Service was quick and the food was good quality. Fairly noisy but not overwhelmingly so! Another great experience at HC Tavern! Highly recommend!
Lisa
We were seated upstairs and it was open on a chilly day. We asked to be moved and was moved to a table still upstairs, still chilly but better. We ordered hot coffee to warm up. I know it was extremely busy and appreciated the move. My fries were cold and the waitress got me hot fries. Then I tasted my ribeye sandwich and it too was cold. It was medium well but when it was reheated it became well done and tough. I'm chalking this experience up to the Easter holiday and the number of guests they were trying to serve, as this has not been the case when I've dined there previously.
Ed
Everything was great. Everyone in our party of three had something different and were very pleased. Our server was always attentive and friendly.
Barbara Rodrigues
My husband and I went for the second time to HC Tavern after knowing that the food and service were excellent. However, this time we had an unfortunate and unpleasant experience with our server (I know her name) after she made a discriminatory comment and racist question knowing that we were not native english speakers. In my opinion, training the staff to attend with excellence despite ethnicity/race is as important as serving good food in a great environment. We left without ordering anything, and will never come back.
Was there to film some media of the Nutcracker Suite Holiday Pop-Up, and the hospitality was great!
Huge shoutout to Josue, Jonathan, and the team for the spectacular service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Terrence Raftery
Had the pork chop, very nice. Very attentive staff even on a busy night.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Horseradish Mashed Potatoes
Megan Siebert
Food was great! We only saw our server when she took our order and it was time to pay. Other servers around us were very attentive.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 2
AJ B
I was skeptical at first but after our visit we will definitely be back Kayleigh and Cyndi are awesome bartender and the service was excellent
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
STEPHANIE MEALS
I attended the rhythm & brunch for the first time with my sister and fell on a perfect day this month: my birthday. The atmosphere, the restaurant decor, dj spinning great music, and the good food and service was a vibe. I'm glad I went on this perfect weather day as this is the one and only time I'll visit HC Tavern.
Hostess and waitress were excellent Both wished us Happy Anniversary. Berkshire chop and scallops were excellent but husband thought 3 scallops was not much for price of the dinner. Love the baguettes and whipped butter starter. Noise lrevel was high. We had difficulty hearing each other talk.
Our Server Kristen was fantastic. We had a wonderful experience. All of us thoroughly enjoyed our meals. The crab cakes, the pork chop and the bolognese paste was fantastic.
We've been to HCT many times and have always enjoyed it. I'm glad last night wasn't our first experience there because we wouldn't go back. The noise was off the charts. Our waitress was slow, unresponsive, didn't know the menu very well, and overall not good. At one point I actually had to flag her down to have her come back because she never took my wife's order. They were out of things we like (e.g. standard menu items like the lobster cargot) and making small modifications to an entree order (e.g. getting green beans instead of mashed potatoes) was not possible for some reason. I wouldn't say we won't be back but with the level of competition on the northside of Indy these days, we'll tray a lot of other options before returning.
Everything was pretty good. But the prices are way too high for the value. It's not fine dining. If the service was more professional, then perhaps you could justify the prices.
Everythung was perfect. The food was fresh, hot and delicious. Our server was attentive and personable. It was a special treat for a 16th birthday celebration and my guests were very impressed with all of it
Service was quick and the food was good quality. Fairly noisy but not overwhelmingly so! Another great experience at HC Tavern! Highly recommend!
We were seated upstairs and it was open on a chilly day. We asked to be moved and was moved to a table still upstairs, still chilly but better. We ordered hot coffee to warm up. I know it was extremely busy and appreciated the move. My fries were cold and the waitress got me hot fries. Then I tasted my ribeye sandwich and it too was cold. It was medium well but when it was reheated it became well done and tough. I'm chalking this experience up to the Easter holiday and the number of guests they were trying to serve, as this has not been the case when I've dined there previously.
Everything was great. Everyone in our party of three had something different and were very pleased. Our server was always attentive and friendly.
My husband and I went for the second time to HC Tavern after knowing that the food and service were excellent. However, this time we had an unfortunate and unpleasant experience with our server (I know her name) after she made a discriminatory comment and racist question knowing that we were not native english speakers. In my opinion, training the staff to attend with excellence despite ethnicity/race is as important as serving good food in a great environment. We left without ordering anything, and will never come back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
Great all-around experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Horseradish Mashed Potatoes, Sweet Tea Fried Chicken
Restaurantji Recommends
Was there to film some media of the Nutcracker Suite Holiday Pop-Up, and the hospitality was great!
Huge shoutout to Josue, Jonathan, and the team for the spectacular service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had the pork chop, very nice. Very attentive staff even on a busy night.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Horseradish Mashed Potatoes
Food was great! We only saw our server when she took our order and it was time to pay. Other servers around us were very attentive.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 2
I was skeptical at first but after our visit we will definitely be back
Kayleigh and Cyndi are awesome bartender and the service was excellent
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I attended the rhythm & brunch for the first time with my sister and fell on a perfect day this month: my birthday. The atmosphere, the restaurant decor, dj spinning great music, and the good food and service was a vibe. I'm glad I went on this perfect weather day as this is the one and only time I'll visit HC Tavern.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Loading...