The HC Tavern + Kitchen

9709 E 116th St, Fishers
(317) 530-4242

Recent Reviews

Chad Hollenbeck

Food was incredible and service was super friendly. Atmosphere got a little noisy, but otherwise

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Shrimp Tortellacci

Tracy Warrum

Ribs, street corn, coleslaw and espresso martini were excellent!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Elizabeth Deahl

Delishious food with a clean modern setting.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Garrison Kruse

Justin, our server, was fantastic. He made it a wonderful dinner for my wife and I. When we paid via the QR code, Justin made sure to come over before we left because he "believes in personal service". He is a true artist of a server perfecting his art.We will be back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Lobster Roll, Horseradish Mashed Potatoes

Calibr8tor

Corn soup is ‘lick the bowl' amazing. Sweet Tea Chicken is getting it again delicious. Wife really liked the trout. I'm a BBQ snob so I didn't love the ribs. Dry rub was not in my wheelhouse, warming spices were strong for my flavor profile. I like a clean bite tug, so I thought the ribs were overcooked. This being said the majority of folks would love the ribs.

Mackenzie Whitehead

Love this restaurant and have dined here many times. However, my last experience was a little off-putting. I came tonight as I was craving the filet that I love so much, and it happened to come out slightly overcooked from the medium rare that I ordered. I’m not usually one to send something back, but I really love a medium rare steak and found this one to also be a little tough and almost burnt on the outside. My issue is not with the steak though, it is instead the fact that I was seated next to the kitchen and could hear everything the cooks said regarding me sending my steak back. This was so off-putting that I really had no desire to eat the new steak that was sent out and instead boxed it up to take home. My waitress was great, and the rest of my food was delicious as it always is, but this was wildly disappointing to experience.

Elizabeth Martin

I went here for my mom’s birthday, my parents and I ordered a French press coffee my dad said it was good and he said he liked the Steak Diane. My mom ordered a crab cake for dinner and a Diet Coke and for dessert she ordered a cheesecake and she said it was really good. I ordered a crab cake and cauliflower Rice both good and for an appetizer we ordered 1 Roasted Tomato and mozzarella Flatbread that was delicious and for dessert I ordered 1 Bourbon Cherry Cobbler that was good, I would go here again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Steak Diane

RayOna2009

Food was great but I feel I could have spent similar money at 1933 lounge and had even more tasty food and more for the money (like two sides instead of one). The music was quite loud and it was 80s rock which was a weird choice for the environment. Service was great and we had a great experience overall.

LawrenceD

The food and drinks were excellent and at a reasonable price. Our server (I wish I could remember her name) was outstanding. My date wasn't very hungry and didn't eat much of her dinner and our server insisted on removing the entree from our bill over my protests. I will definitely be back!

CodyA

The host staff was great in welcoming us and even presented us with an Anniversary card signed by staff members. Our server was awesome, food was fantastic, drinks were on point, but the dessert won the night. Will definitely be going back!!

AmberK

Everything was perfect! Val was our server and bartender and did a fantastic job. We had brought friends that had never been before and they want to make it a weekly event! We tried a bit of everything and it was all spectacular!! Loved the ambiance, vibe and food. Never skip the lobster cargot!

Sara Dailey

We have been here several times before and have always had a good experience, but unfortunately Saturday's date night was not one of those. It started off great, our waitress seemed attentive, our appetizer was delicious (baguette with cheese & jam), and our drinks were great. Unfortunately both the food and service went downhill from there. We shared a wedge salad, which was over-loaded with dressing, but our bad, we didn't ask for it on the side. Our second round of drinks were forgotten for quite a while. Then our steaks came out & the wrong type of steak was brought out to me (I ordered a filet) and they brought both my husband and I a ribeye. This was corrected. His was supposed to have been medium rare but came out medium. He said something but we felt bad about sending another streak back. The chef came out to apologize, which was nice, and we overheard him tell our waitress to give us a free round of drinks & desserts. Our waitress seemed generally annoyed ever since she forgot our drink order and we were never offered the dessert. On top of all of that, we spent $250 on a meal for 2 and the steaks were bland. Tender, but bland. It's sad when the best part of a steakhouse meal is the bread.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 2

Joe Souders

Very good food. Excellent service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sam Summitt

Crab cakes were

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Greg Morris

HC Tavern is always great! And I always request to sit in Renee’s section. She is absolutely the best!!! Please tip well!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Grilled Caesar Salad, Corn Bisque

Load More