Hall's Commissary

216 IN-930, New Haven
(260) 493-6622

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Cynthia Hamer

Great food, many items to choose from on the menu! Old timey ambiance, and attentive service! I definitely will return to Hall's, given the chance!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

andy bowers

Lady at drive thru is very mean. She is very rude when we order and not very friendly

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Jolene Blaine

We picked up food from here and I was never so disappointed. We ordered the chicken Cobb salad which was very good but also we got the beef and noodles special. It seriously tasted like they opened the lid if the salt and dumped it all in. I have never had to throw something away because it was that salty but that is right where it went...in the garbage! It was $14.00 worth of waste!

Food: 1

Frank Grzybek

Food was excellent as is expected from a Hall restaurant.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Serena Gilman

I ordered several items to try for takeout.
Southwest eggrolls:
in my opinion, needs beef instead of chicken, less beans, and thicker crust. Flavor was alright.

Mozzarella sticks: breading was too thin, marinara was good.

Buffalo chicken loaded mac n cheese:
Mac n cheese itself was creamy but needed salt/ lacked flavor. Toppings made it better . Definitely would get again.

Denver burger: cooked perfectly and delicious. No complaints at all.

Memphis two fister:
THE STAR OF THE SHOW! Burger was cooked perfectly. Topped with plenty pulled pork and delicious coleslaw. The sauce was delicious will definitely order extra on it next time.

The sides:
Potato salad: flavor was perfect but the texture showed that it was previously frozen.
Fries: delicious

Also would like to add the lady hostess was very welcoming and kind.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Steven Bartlett

Very good employees very good food every thing is very good I love it here

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Debra Schimmoller

We happened to be in New Haven last night & decided to stop in for dinner. Sure glad we did! Best fresh food we've had in a long time in one of the cleanest places too! I believe Hall's new generation is making their Grandpa proud. We won't wait to be in New Haven to come back🥰 Rick & Deb Schimmoller

Justice Fuller

Hall’s is a classic. Bonuses of the Commissary specifically include the drive thru speaker and breakfast all day

Most things are made fresh and while prices have increased, it’s still a good value for the money.

Cocktails are a bit meh, to be honest. But I love Hall’s.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Wolfieamadeus

Hall’s is a classic. Bonuses of the Commissary specifically include the drive thru speaker and breakfast all day

Most things are made fresh and while prices have increased, it’s still a good value for the money.

Cocktails are a bit meh, to be honest. But I love Hall’s.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Steve Hall

Anytime we drive from Central IL to Detroit this will be our stop to AND from. Sam was our server and was wonderful. Recommended the Chicken Sandwich and it was one of the best Ive ever had.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Laura Wellstead

Nice local diner, shares and entry way with a tap room. It's a little worn around the edges, but plenty comfy. Okay food, great service. ?

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 5

J R

Food was gross, service was poor. Steak under cooked and full of gristle, kids mac n cheese was over cooked and cold on a hot plate, mashed potatoes had hard chunks in them, burger was over cooked and wrong. Server was almost nonexistent. Just an over all bad experience. We went for my son's 7th birthday. Mistake. Won't be back.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Tammy Brandner

I really don’t like to leave negative reviews for a restaurant, but unfortunately, this is the second time I’ve eaten inside the restaurant and both times have not been a very good experience. The first time I got sick from the food so I would only go through the drive thru.

I will leave a separate review for the drive-through because I’ve never had a bad experience with them so far.

My waitress today was not very good, she was slow and only came to our table one time and never came back again. I couldn’t tell her the fruit was no good. It was rotten. It should’ve been taken back or replaced. She just disappeared and acted like we weren’t there because they were slammed. They got busy all the sudden I’m just being honest cause I don’t want to get nasty, but it did upset me quite a bit the way she talked to me.

Here’s what happened!

The waitress was not able to keep up with the flow and how busy it was, and when I asked for the check from the hostess because we were in a hurry and had to leave the hostess, told the waitress that I said she couldn’t keep up and the waitress got upset and argued with me right in front of the manager and the hostess! And the customers also could hear… I only said that because we were in a hurry, had been there for well over an hour, and I explained I would still happily leave her a tip, but we just couldn’t wait no more.

Then the waitress made a snotty comment and I tried telling her I was being nice if I did, I was still gonna leave her a tip, but after all that happened, I’ll never go back inside again!

How can anybody hire a waitress who is gonna argue with the customer in front of everybody for the whole restaurant to hear she started an argument wouldn’t listen that I tried to tell her I was being nice and I was still gonna tip her, but she got so nasty that I won’t even go back inside the restaurant no more so they really messed up. This girl needs to be fired and I’m sorry, but I don’t never say that about nobody What she did was absolutely despicable.

Hands-down, I’m done! ? Only the DRIVE THRU for now hopefully that won’t go bad!

I loved this restaurant all this time but now I just don’t know! Ugh

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Lauri Haney

Dirty. Greasy food. Just

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Nicole

Food and service are great, especially for the price! But restaurant needs some updating.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...