Vito's Pizza

4215 S Anthony Blvd, Fort Wayne
(260) 456-6900

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Ashley Dwan

They Don’t Deliver The Food And Still Charge
You For It!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Matt Dominguez

phone service and delivery service is bad .. I tried to call and get a delivery today and the employee was very rude and not helpful at all and refused to set up delivery because the time of day because it was lunch time , had to order from a different place …

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 2

Jose Serrato

Called around midnight to order food. Guy that answered the phone was very attentive, nice and quick. Let me know I'd have my food in around 30 minutes. Didn't have carrot cake like I saw on an old menu, but quickly offered an alternative! Will update if my food is not great, but I'm expecting it to be good!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dennis Lindsey II

The Pizza was really good!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Corinna

They have a great pepperoni with jalapenos and pineapple . The pizza crust is on spot . The baked spaghetti with meatballs are fire . Highly recommended . 😁😁

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Terrance Williams

The pizza was cold, and besides that I ordered a sausage pepperoni extra sausage and extra pepperoni, I'd rather have a frozen store-bought Pizza the worst Pizza I ever had.Sad

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Nicole “MISS NIKKI” Parks

First of all the fries were old and dry. The garlic bread was hard as a rock. My partner ask for onion rings instead of fries. They put like 5 onion rings over the fries. NEVER EVER AGAIN!!!!!!!!!! If you order from them GO IN!!!! You should take PRIDE in making people's FOOD.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Becca Nelson

Ordered delivery around 1:30a on a friday night/Saturday morning. I am very impressed with the quickness & pleasant service!!

Kimberly Washington

Needless to say the restaurant is not being managed correctly. So many issues
1. Trash full in the dining room from the previous day
2. Smells so terrible when you walk in like dirty mop water
3. Dead bugs on a dirty table
3. No ac in the dinning area
4. So called the manager on days never has anything prepared and is always a long wait.
5. Evening time smells like straight weed in there.
6.
I called back to talk to someone in charge besides the day manager and yet he was rude so I asked how to get a hold of the owner he said the owner doesn't talk to anyone. So if the owner doesn't talk to anyone does he not know how his store is being run? They are losing business and the team running doesn't care as long as they get a check. Checks will only come in if us customers keep coming in.

Mitchel Bachand

Visited: May 21, 2025

Ordered a large Hawaiian pizza with peppers on half. The building itself felt a little sketchy—especially the order window setup—but the staff were friendly enough, offered a smile, and kept things simple on the small talk, which I’m good with.

The pizza took a bit longer than expected—maybe 5 to 10 minutes more than I’d guess for a place like this—but it wasn’t a big deal. As for the food: it was decent. Not bad by any means, just not anything that stood out.

Would I recommend it? I’d probably shop around and try other pizza spots before coming back here.

My star ranking system:
1: Bad / Don't go there
2: Could be better
3: Average
4: Above average but not the best
5: A true top notch place

Jordan Biehl (JordanFromTheFort)

I needed pizza admittedly extremely late but I had messed up and ended up being out way later than originally thought. Didn't want to head back out so gf said Vito's is open and figured why not let's continue my personal journey through low star rated places Fort Wayne finding a jem here and there. Ordered an app sampler, a chicken bacon ranch pizza (requested no onions or tomatoes as gf is allergic) and an order of bread sticks was told it would take an hour which I mean sure it's late but I really needed food and everything else to be good like please. When it came the driver was nice and friendly even calling ten minutes before arriving about an hour and ten minutes later so 80 min when quoted 60 not bad at all especially this late awesomeness! However, once I got back inside I realized someone messed up far worse than I had tonight. Our pizza had both of the items she requested be omitted meaning gf is both hungry and pissed and I didn't have an order of bread sticks. She called back as it was almost $50 and even if everything had been there that's pricey. She was told by whoever picked up the phone that he never heard me ask for onions or tomatoes to be omitted nor did hear her order breadsticks but still the bill was nearly $50? True there are three pieces of pizza gone in the picture because I don't care personally about the onions or tomatoes and she was so hungry she stripped one piece of the pizza of toppings and ate that as there were even onions under the cheese and we didn't touch the sampler after we tried everything and said eh and that was what was left. Food was okay but everything but the driver was well let's say more or less sad. Pizza at best was okay, everything else was tasted and left despite being hungry. Made some shakes with ice cream and milk at home and ate those instead. Happy-ish ending but only cause milkshakes, Vito's had no hand in that whatsoever quite the opposite. I was hoping the reviews were off but they were sadly proven to be spot on.

Aaron Schofield

Great pizza, decent price. Came in on a whim and left far too full.

Aysha Craig

I called in a order and when I went to pick it up they hadn’t even made it despite telling me it would be ready they hadn’t even started on my order smh!

Tessa Goode

Last night we ordered from there and instead of the lady giving me my change back she took 6 dollars and tipped herself like who does that and because of her I will not order from there again thanks a lot

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza, Fries

Rob Niemeyer

Good pizza, slightly expensive.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 4

Loading...