Coterie Pizza
$ • Pizza
Hours:
1850 S Randolph St, Garrett
(260) 226-6606
About Coterie Pizza
Customers' Favorites
Coterie Pizza Reviews
Share your opinion about Coterie Pizza
Normally we LOVE this restaurant. Delicious food and good service. Last evening, 10/20/25, it was sub par. Bacon not well cooked on my chicken bacon, which I normally love, and way too much oil drizzled on the chicken bruschetta. Also, the staff was very noisy and goofing around in the restaurant and at one point the music was blaring. We were the only four customers in there, and were shocked to have this experience. If this had been our first visit, we wouldn't come back,...read full review
One of the best Pizza Places around. we make the trip there when we can and the entire family loves it. The service is always great and they always take very good care of us. I cannot say enough about this place, other than everyone needs to try it!
The hot honey pizza absolutely SLAPS
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 9PM |
People in Garrett Also Viewed
Coterie Pizza offers a clean and welcoming dining area with great service. Their pizzas, such as the hot honey pizza and pepperoni with beef sausage and red onion, are highly praised for their unique flavors. The restaurant also features a beer wall with a selection of craft beers and a popular beer cheese dip. The brick oven style pizza is fresh and delicious, with some reviews highlighting the unbelievable taste and great value. The 12” pizza size is perfect for two people and often enough to satisfy hungry diners. The bread with beer cheese appetizer is considered one of the most delicious items on the menu and is incredible. The restaurant accommodates vegetarian options and allows customers to create their own pizzas. Friendly staff and a warm atmosphere make it a must-visit spot. The service is great and the pizza is even better. The crust was great, the sauce was phenomenal, and the cheese was fantastic. The self-serve beer taps are a great feature. The marinara sauce with the cheese bread is fire and highly recommended. The seasonal Mexican Street Corn Pizza is really good and available for a limited time.