Normally we LOVE this restaurant. Delicious food and good service. Last evening, 10/20/25, it was sub par. Bacon not well cooked on my chicken bacon, which I normally love, and way too much oil drizzled on the chicken bruschetta. Also, the staff was very noisy and goofing around in the restaurant and at one point the music was blaring. We were the only four customers in there, and were shocked to have this experience. If this had been our first visit, we wouldn't come back, but since we're there about once a month, we knew this wasn't the norm. We'll give it another chance and hope the owner is there next time we visit and things will be under control. Very disappointed in our dining experience last evening.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 4
Kent Hill
One of the best Pizza Places around. we make the trip there when we can and the entire family loves it. The service is always great and they always take very good care of us. I cannot say enough about this place, other than everyone needs to try it!
Anna Hartsuff Williams
The hot honey pizza absolutely SLAPS
Tenn Lions
Very busy when we went but the service was still on point. We had the brisket BBQ pizza and the seasonal street corn pizza. Both were ok but the ratio of mushrooms to brisket on the BBQ pizza was not balanced. This was mushroom pizza with a little bit of brisket. The street corn pizza was really good but needed more sauce on it. As always, the beer cheese appetizer was incredible.
Jaylee Frye
Coterie has great pizza, but I would highly not recommend booking them for a private event/wedding. They catered my 150 person wedding in July and did not deliver what was promised. They were so slow that several guests gave up on getting food entirely. They ended up pushing back our entire schedule for the night which caused issues with other vendors. So disheartening!
Food: 4
Service: 1
Donald Goff
Beer cheese appetizer is fantastic!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Brad Phares
This place is amazing! The pizza is definitely one of our favorites in the area! Made a little side trip when coming home from Ft Wayne tonight and it's oh, so worth it! The service is great and the pizza is even better! Get the Mexican Street Corn Pizza while it's available for the next 3 months or so! Go get some!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bryan Coyle
I don't write a lot of reviews unless I highly enjoyed or majorly disliked something. This was a place I really enjoyed, so I had to share my experience. I'm not from around here, I was only in the area for the Midwest Geobash in Wauseon, Ohio, then back to Pennsylvania, I would go. But, the first night I arrived here, I wanted a pizza, but being from an area of pizza shops that cater to the Philadelphia palate, I'm pretty picky when it comes to a good pizze. I chose this place by accident, I was going to go to a place to the north, but they were packed for an event of some sort, and I'm glad they were, because I ended up here. I have never been to the state of Indiana before, yet somehow, I stumbled upon one of the best pizzas I have ever had. The crust was great, the sauce was phenomenal 👌, and the cheese was fantastic. It's hard to find a place that masters all 3, but this place did it. Not only that, but self-serve beer? I'll be honest, I wasn't expecting that at all. When I asked where my glass was and was introduced to the self-serve taps, I was in disbelief, I had never seen such a phenomenon before in my life. The employees were really nice, too, even assisted me with how to use the taps. I will definitely drive out of my way to stop in again next time I'm in the area. Whatever it is you are doing, keep doing it! That marinara sauce with the cheese bread is fire, and I highly recommend it! Will definitely pass the word on to my fellow travelers for when they're in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Bread with Marinara and Beer Cheese
Stella Brooks
This place is great! We are never disappointed! The staff works hard and they are all so friendly every time!! They are busy on the weekends but they all work so hard and remember us from time to time and are extremely friendly! The pizza is good, the beer cheese and bread is wonderful! If you get a chance to go in the summer, get the street corn pizza. You won’t regret it!
Normally we LOVE this restaurant. Delicious food and good service. Last evening, 10/20/25, it was sub par. Bacon not well cooked on my chicken bacon, which I normally love, and way too much oil drizzled on the chicken bruschetta. Also, the staff was very noisy and goofing around in the restaurant and at one point the music was blaring. We were the only four customers in there, and were shocked to have this experience. If this had been our first visit, we wouldn't come back, but since we're there about once a month, we knew this wasn't the norm. We'll give it another chance and hope the owner is there next time we visit and things will be under control. Very disappointed in our dining experience last evening.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 4
One of the best Pizza Places around. we make the trip there when we can and the entire family loves it. The service is always great and they always take very good care of us. I cannot say enough about this place, other than everyone needs to try it!
The hot honey pizza absolutely SLAPS
Very busy when we went but the service was still on point. We had the brisket BBQ pizza and the seasonal street corn pizza. Both were ok but the ratio of mushrooms to brisket on the BBQ pizza was not balanced. This was mushroom pizza with a little bit of brisket. The street corn pizza was really good but needed more sauce on it. As always, the beer cheese appetizer was incredible.
Coterie has great pizza, but I would highly not recommend booking them for a private event/wedding. They catered my 150 person wedding in July and did not deliver what was promised. They were so slow that several guests gave up on getting food entirely. They ended up pushing back our entire schedule for the night which caused issues with other vendors. So disheartening!
Food: 4
Service: 1
Beer cheese appetizer is fantastic!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
This place is amazing! The pizza is definitely one of our favorites in the area! Made a little side trip when coming home from Ft Wayne tonight and it's oh, so worth it! The service is great and the pizza is even better! Get the Mexican Street Corn Pizza while it's available for the next 3 months or so! Go get some!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I don't write a lot of reviews unless I highly enjoyed or majorly disliked something. This was a place I really enjoyed, so I had to share my experience. I'm not from around here, I was only in the area for the Midwest Geobash in Wauseon, Ohio, then back to Pennsylvania, I would go. But, the first night I arrived here, I wanted a pizza, but being from an area of pizza shops that cater to the Philadelphia palate, I'm pretty picky when it comes to a good pizze. I chose this place by accident, I was going to go to a place to the north, but they were packed for an event of some sort, and I'm glad they were, because I ended up here. I have never been to the state of Indiana before, yet somehow, I stumbled upon one of the best pizzas I have ever had. The crust was great, the sauce was phenomenal 👌, and the cheese was fantastic. It's hard to find a place that masters all 3, but this place did it. Not only that, but self-serve beer? I'll be honest, I wasn't expecting that at all. When I asked where my glass was and was introduced to the self-serve taps, I was in disbelief, I had never seen such a phenomenon before in my life. The employees were really nice, too, even assisted me with how to use the taps. I will definitely drive out of my way to stop in again next time I'm in the area. Whatever it is you are doing, keep doing it! That marinara sauce with the cheese bread is fire, and I highly recommend it! Will definitely pass the word on to my fellow travelers for when they're in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Bread with Marinara and Beer Cheese
This place is great! We are never disappointed! The staff works hard and they are all so friendly every time!! They are busy on the weekends but they all work so hard and remember us from time to time and are extremely friendly! The pizza is good, the beer cheese and bread is wonderful! If you get a chance to go in the summer, get the street corn pizza. You won’t regret it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My favorite pizza spot!
Restaurantji Recommends
Delicious 😋
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza ever 👍
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food and service were amazing! We will 100% be back!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Clean and timely service. Will try again.
What a great find! Chz was melted and crust very good! I had the mushroom. Yummy
Loading...