This is a cool, local place with a neat ambiance. There is memorabilia all over the place, which makes this place unique. The service was really good, but the food was mediocre at best. For $50 per plate, the fish had little flavor and the prime rib was tough and the horseradish sauce tasted like mayo. Serving this with fresh horseradish sauce would have been better.The sides were good and the desserts looked amazing although we didn't get any. We were both disappointed with our entrees, especially for the price paid. We love to support local businesses and will give Yesterdays another try, and are hopeful that the food will be better.
Airis
Delicious & wonderful atmosphere as always!! They have the best service & always make you feel at home. 10/10 everytime
Mike
This is roughly our 20th visit to Yesterday's, and it always exceeds expectations. The food, drinks, service, and ambiance are unrivaled in our area. Stay away from bland corporate menus and dine local. You will not regret it.
Mashelle
We never knew the restaurant existed, but went in and totally loved the food and ambience.
Brad
The food, service, and drinks were all good. They have good menu choices and many options not available at other top restaurants in the area.
Leah
We had a reservation at 4:15 and didn't sit down until 4:30 because they were “polishing the silverware” and “setting up our room”. Meanwhile, there were no other customers in the restaurant. When we did sit down, we were at a table right by the entrance, so not sure what the wait was about... The service was good and there was an abundance of food, however, one person in our party order halibut in a bag, but the oil in the bag was rancid and ruined her fish and another person ordered Filet Neptune and it was over done by two temps and tough. They did take the fish off of our bill. The desserts were good, as always, and they celebrated and recognized a person in our party's birthday, however overall, it was average food and over priced for the quality. We used to love Yesterday's and have been there quite a bit, but in the last couple of years have not been happy and this experience confirmed why we haven't been back in a while.
Jason
Excellent as always!!! You won't find a nicer staff in the business and of course food quality second to none!!
Richard
I had a very bad experience. It was my anniversary and we showed up to the restaurant and it was closed until mid September for renovation. When the restaurant is closed you should not be able to reserve a reservation. Good thing I live close by but If I had driven a long distance it would have even more upsetting.
Paulina G
Food was amazing! We all ordered the Godfather, Buffalo potato skins for appetizer, and LOTS of cheesecake for dessert! Def a must try if you’ve never stopped in here
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kelly
Yesterday's provided a dining experience with an attentive server, portions that are plentiful, and to go boxes (if needed) packaged carefully. The Cha Cha Beach (coconut shrimp was served with a great dipping sauce. The shrimp were large and perfectly crusted with a coconut batter. The prime rib was done (medium rare) to perfection. This was our second visit and we will continue to return. Our server, Katelyn, was delightful.
Love the food and the vibe. Great place to be a regular!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amanda
Just had another wonderful meal at Yesterday's Restaurant, and as always, it did not disappoint! The food is absolutely amazing every time, and the atmosphere is so cozy and comforting. Truly one of my favorite places to be. ❤️🍴
Michele
My husband and I were in town from California, visiting family and decided to visit Yesterday's for our anniversary. We used to stop in occasionally when we lived in Mishawaka. We hadn't been to Yesterday's in many years but were happy to see that the same comfortable atmosphere and amazing food had not changed! Thank you for a great time! ❤️❤️❤️
Todd Connolly
If you know you know. Can't beat it. Everything is amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeff
Great place. Very cozy and interesting interior. Forget sitting at the bar. Locals cover it up and don't move. Drink pours very generous and large portions. Lots of interesting selections and the desert is to die for. Plan on taking home the leftovers!
This is a cool, local place with a neat ambiance. There is memorabilia all over the place, which makes this place unique. The service was really good, but the food was mediocre at best. For $50 per plate, the fish had little flavor and the prime rib was tough and the horseradish sauce tasted like mayo. Serving this with fresh horseradish sauce would have been better.The sides were good and the desserts looked amazing although we didn't get any. We were both disappointed with our entrees, especially for the price paid. We love to support local businesses and will give Yesterdays another try, and are hopeful that the food will be better.
Delicious & wonderful atmosphere as always!! They have the best service & always make you feel at home. 10/10 everytime
This is roughly our 20th visit to Yesterday's, and it always exceeds expectations. The food, drinks, service, and ambiance are unrivaled in our area. Stay away from bland corporate menus and dine local. You will not regret it.
We never knew the restaurant existed, but went in and totally loved the food and ambience.
The food, service, and drinks were all good. They have good menu choices and many options not available at other top restaurants in the area.
We had a reservation at 4:15 and didn't sit down until 4:30 because they were “polishing the silverware” and “setting up our room”. Meanwhile, there were no other customers in the restaurant. When we did sit down, we were at a table right by the entrance, so not sure what the wait was about... The service was good and there was an abundance of food, however, one person in our party order halibut in a bag, but the oil in the bag was rancid and ruined her fish and another person ordered Filet Neptune and it was over done by two temps and tough. They did take the fish off of our bill. The desserts were good, as always, and they celebrated and recognized a person in our party's birthday, however overall, it was average food and over priced for the quality. We used to love Yesterday's and have been there quite a bit, but in the last couple of years have not been happy and this experience confirmed why we haven't been back in a while.
Excellent as always!!! You won't find a nicer staff in the business and of course food quality second to none!!
I had a very bad experience. It was my anniversary and we showed up to the restaurant and it was closed until mid September for renovation. When the restaurant is closed you should not be able to reserve a reservation. Good thing I live close by but If I had driven a long distance it would have even more upsetting.
Food was amazing! We all ordered the Godfather, Buffalo potato skins for appetizer, and LOTS of cheesecake for dessert! Def a must try if you’ve never stopped in here
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Yesterday's provided a dining experience with an attentive server, portions that are plentiful, and to go boxes (if needed) packaged carefully. The Cha Cha Beach (coconut shrimp was served with a great dipping sauce. The shrimp were large and perfectly crusted with a coconut batter. The prime rib was done (medium rare) to perfection. This was our second visit and we will continue to return. Our server, Katelyn, was delightful.
Restaurantji Recommends
Love the food and the vibe. Great place to be a regular!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just had another wonderful meal at Yesterday's Restaurant, and as always, it did not disappoint! The food is absolutely amazing every time, and the atmosphere is so cozy and comforting. Truly one of my favorite places to be. ❤️🍴
My husband and I were in town from California, visiting family and decided to visit Yesterday's for our anniversary. We used to stop in occasionally when we lived in Mishawaka. We hadn't been to Yesterday's in many years but were happy to see that the same comfortable atmosphere and amazing food had not changed! Thank you for a great time! ❤️❤️❤️
If you know you know. Can't beat it. Everything is amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place. Very cozy and interesting interior. Forget sitting at the bar. Locals cover it up and don't move. Drink pours very generous and large portions. Lots of interesting selections and the desert is to die for. Plan on taking home the leftovers!
Loading...