A Piece of Cake

484 N Madison Ave, Greenwood
(317) 887-2253

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Sara Rasmussen

Honestly, one of the best lemon meringue pies I've ever had. The meringue was just perfect. Very friendly service, generous prices, I highly recommend!

Chelle B

It is always a pleasure to do business with A Piece of Cake. The cakes are phenomenal, and we use them for any celebration we have in the family.

Katie Sherwood

We have used A Piece of Cake for many years! It's always delicious and beautiful!

Simarjit Kaur

They always make great and delicious cakes, and they have reasonable prices!

Cristina Napier

My daughter was so happy with her birthday cupcakes! The frosting was amazing and the cake was so soft. We will be coming back.

Rachel Montgomery

Best Place for Cakes. Even in a snowstorm.

Alex Barrett

A Piece of Cake did our wedding cake, and they did absolutely amazing! They provided a free consultation to plan our design for the cake, were thoughtful in their choices, and were easy to work with throughout the whole process. The cake tasted and looked amazing, the people were professional, and they delivered a very high quality product. I would highly recommend A Piece of Cake for any occasion that you need an amazing cake for.

P.S. my wife said this was the best white cake she’s ever had :)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Hillary Houston

Oh my, every time I get a cake from here I say it’s the best cake I’ve ever had! The Spider-Man chocolate cake I ordered was absolutely delicious and decoration was perfect! I’m already pondering when the next occasion is that I can order another cake from you guys! Thank you!!!!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Regina Marie Kalen Mangus

I just love Debbie and her entire family! It has been 3 years since I ordered a cake which is far too long! Banana Cake is the Bomb Diggity🩷🩷🩷 I was blessed to partake in a plethora of Debbie’s yummy treats this past weekend! You cannot go wrong with any choice you make! Her secret ingredient must be LOVE ❤️

Jina Desai

Great cake at an even greater price!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Charlie Sizemore

Amazing and delicious! I went in with a bunch of ideas and they captured it perfectly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

Sarah Holba

First timer here! I went in to get something sweet after lunch... I walked in and it literally smelled like heaven. The lady inside was very kind.

I was surprised to see their "cake trash" container was much bigger than expected. And for only $3!!! I got the white cake with white frosting and it was so delicious. Will definitely have to come back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Theleia Philia

The most beautiful and delicious celebratory cakes and cake pops I've tasted! Debbie, Jodi and Kim are true artists!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Christine Landis

With one week before the big "I do", I realized I forgot to order a cutting cake for my daughter's wedding. The lady was so assuring that she had zero issues, and to just email her an inspiration photo. Tuesday before the wedding I emailed it, and spoke again with her Wednesday. Saturday we came to pick up the cake, and it was exactly what she wanted. Thank you so so much! The cake was almond with raspberry, and tasted soooo good! (I did sneak a bite before boxing it all up after wedding) I was amazed how little she charged us for such a perfect little cake.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Heidy Grageda

They are the best! The cakes are very delicious, reasonable prices, and they pay attention to details.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...