Papa Johns Pizza

334 S Emerson Ave, Greenwood
(317) 889-7272

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Samantha Glover

Just called them because my pizza didn’t get delivered, and Derek was incredible about it. Shoutout to him!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

William Foster

I love papa Jon's pizza but don't go to this location the last three times I have been there the pizza was horrible one time the pizza and cheese bread had a bubble in the dough which was half the pizza all the topping where on one half and did not have much on them to begin with last night I got carry out so I could check it out before I payed for it took a quick look and it looked all right but got home and the bottom of the pizza and the cheese sticks were burnt. I have been in the food service for many years if you mess something up you remake it most people will wate for good food. I wasted my money the last few times I have been there will never go to this one again. Find another location or go to another pizza chain they don't know how to cook a pizza here.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Afril Trueheart

It's pizza. It isn't the best, isn't the worst. Not much to say here.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Elvis Presley

Paid for two meats, received one. Paid for extra cheese, didn't get it. If it weren't for the brownies it would have been a ruined evening. Truly pitiful.

Food: 1

Service: 3

Nicole Sterrett

Every time we order from Papa John's, we make sure to ALWAYS order from this location rather we are picking up or having it delivered. Jacob, Marissa and the entire team are always polite, helpful and the service exceeds our expectations. Their pizza is fresh, hot and made exactly how I order it. Keep up the great work and thank you for always delivering 5 stay service!! ~ The Sterrett Family

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: The Works Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza Sliced by Hellen Keller, Cinnamon Pull Apart, Banana Peppers, 8 Mega Chocolate Chip Cookie, Cheesesticks, Breadsticks, Pizzas Wings, Extra Large New York Style Pizza, Snack Size-10 Piece - Chicken Poppers

Crystal T

The guy that looks like post malone, makes the best pizza and jalapeno knots.
Super hot, the pizza was purrrfection.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Patrick Hagman

No menu, not helpful. Order was not ready 20 minutes after being g notified it was ready. Very poor experience. Never going gnto a papa John's again

robaro green

This is the worst Papa John I've ever been too. Possibly the worst pizza I've had. Terrible place

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Sliced by Hellen Keller

Nativee Kouture

Dude with the long hair has a terrible attitude. Don’t be mad at your customers be you have to work here and live in your mom’s basement 🙄

Gretchen Fox

Disgusting. I rarely post reviews but this place was inedible. Nearly 40 bucks for a soggy cold pizza and garlic knots that were brown on the outside and literal dough on the inside. Never again.

Food: 1

Shane Sullivan

Placed an order for pickup at 4:30 PM set to pick up at 6:15 PM. I got to the restaurant at 6:15 and had to wait over 15 minutes before someone even acknowledged me.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Gita Shrestha

Bought 4 large pizza for takeout. While asked for Parmesan cheese, the server gave me two packet.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: The Works Pizza, Garden Fresh

Jonathan Nolte

Can't follow simple instructions, won't puck up the phone. They made my pizza incorrectly and I couldn't eat it due to allergies. I called the store and they put me on hold for 20 minutes before I gave up. I skipped dinner because they don't understand customer service at all

Dietary restrictions: They put cheese on a pizza when I asked for NO cheese due to allergies.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Stephanie Baker

Pizza un done very doey cheese looking at me you guys use way too much cheese ordered on line my two pizzas were ready 2.2 seconds after ordering there’s no way I was so hungry I went and picked my pizzas up this pizza is disrespectfully nasty I won’t be going back only good thing was the employees I didn’t receive my two sauces I paid for bad experience you only get one time to serve me bad pizza very disappointed customer

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Kevin Massa

10/4/2024. I do not post much reviews but when I do I want them to have an impact. Picked up my nephew and niece from sitters to help out my sister while she was working OT. She ordered a pizza and some wings from this location. Order was supposed to arrive no later than 6:04 PM on Friday Night. I get that Fridays are busy. No show on delivery. My sister calls around 7:10 pm which is an hour later. They said they will resend and have out in half an hour. Still no show. Then manager calls her up and says delivery never went out so we are sending you 2 orders and will be there in 30 minutes. 40 minutes passes and my sister calls back and said that Door Dash took order then brought back to the store. Long, story I know. She ended up taking kids to Taco Bell after 9pm. BTW, I did make a salad for the kids after 1st order did not get here. Kids are usually in bed by 7 to 8pm and they were good but ready for bed and hungry. Peyton or Shaq. Please call me. This is out of this world.

Loading...